TRADE IDEA, TEAR IT APART!

Just been asked to come up with a trade idea for my desk that will be hinged upon thursday economic data releases - french bonds sales, spanish bonds sales, EU rate decision and UK rate/QE decision. The strategy has to be very current and I must invest in at least one equity, 1 commodity and one currency.

My thoughts so far:

ECB cut to be 0.25 basis points but no cut in deposit rate
UK cuts not going to occur potential quantitate easing
strong spanish and french bond sales

All this would point to a rally in equities markets. Thus thinking of going with equities with a higher beta which tend to have higher upside when market is in uptick and simultaneously shorting defensives (hedge) - eliminating most systematic risk

As regards currency I'm thinking long USD as positive bond selling will translate positively in US market and short sterling as QE demonstrates UKs weakness.

Also thinking as my commodity strategy to go long on copper and oil as these tend to do well in market uptick and have higher beta whilst simultaneously shorting gold?

1) My issue is how much of these predictions are already priced in.
2) Is my strategy way to basic? The more in depth and creative the better!
3) Are my assumptions correct

Any feedback, constructive criticism, tearing my idea apart. Adding to the idea. Giving me a completely now outlook on an idea would be very much appreciated!

FYI I am an intern hence the lack of sophistication and knowledge!

 
IMFUTURE:
I thought when there is an uptick in the mark more risk is taken on and growth is seen to be temporarily driven and as a result copper (a big indicator of growth) and oil surges in a market uptick as there is more risk on. Can you elaborate on AUD/USD long auzzie short US?

Well this depends. If, for example, QE 3 is announced at some point the markets will surge. Not because of growth in a real sense but because suddenly there will be more money pumped into the system which will drive up asset prices. Moreover, asset prices will be pushed up because people are reaching for yield in a world where interest rates are ridiculously low. This should also push down the dollar because of inflationary worries because of the money printing. Gold should move up accordingly because it is seen as a safe haven from inflation which will come at some point assuming all of the liquidity the Fed is providing actually gets into the system (It isn't currently, which is why deflation is actually more of a concern right this moment). Oil surges for a few reason, one is that there will be more demand and more dollars chasing the oil and the hope that the easing will help spur growth which will also lead to an uptick in demand which pushes prices up. Add to that the debauchery of the US dollar and you get inflation which takes place in the form of energy prices, because when the dollar goes down it has less buying power and thus oil prices will increase accordingly.

Macro, do you think that they would actually do it though? I can't imagine the ECB with all the worries over Europe would suddenly raise rates. Unless your arguing a line of thought like the mortgage market in the United Sates where by raising rates you would spur people to actually go out and buy homes hoping that they don't miss out on the low rates. Currently, everyone is waiting and expecting rates to stay low and thus are waiting for prices to come down even further. In that respect, a shock might actually help out.

 
Addinator37:
IMFUTURE:
I thought when there is an uptick in the mark more risk is taken on and growth is seen to be temporarily driven and as a result copper (a big indicator of growth) and oil surges in a market uptick as there is more risk on. Can you elaborate on AUD/USD long auzzie short US?

Well this depends. If, for example, QE 3 is announced at some point the markets will surge. Not because of growth in a real sense but because suddenly there will be more money pumped into the system which will drive up asset prices. Moreover, asset prices will be pushed up because people are reaching for yield in a world where interest rates are ridiculously low. This should also push down the dollar because of inflationary worries because of the money printing. Gold should move up accordingly because it is seen as a safe haven from inflation which will come at some point assuming all of the liquidity the Fed is providing actually gets into the system (It isn't currently, which is why deflation is actually more of a concern right this moment). Oil surges for a few reason, one is that there will be more demand and more dollars chasing the oil and the hope that the easing will help spur growth which will also lead to an uptick in demand which pushes prices up. Add to that the debauchery of the US dollar and you get inflation which takes place in the form of energy prices, because when the dollar goes down it has less buying power and thus oil prices will increase accordingly.

Macro, do you think that they would actually do it though? I can't imagine the ECB with all the worries over Europe would suddenly raise rates. Unless your arguing a line of thought like the mortgage market in the United Sates where by raising rates you would spur people to actually go out and buy homes hoping that they don't miss out on the low rates. Currently, everyone is waiting and expecting rates to stay low and thus are waiting for prices to come down even further. In that respect, a shock might actually help out.

Thanks for clearing up the inverse relationship between USD and commodities. In that case is it a plausible strategy to in fact long commodities and short USD whilst also long gold. Is my theory of strong global equity prices will help USD appreciate then built on false foundations?

 
Best Response
IMFUTURE:
Just been asked to come up with a trade idea for my desk that will be hinged upon thursday economic data releases - french bonds sales, spanish bonds sales, EU rate decision and UK rate/QE decision. The strategy has to be very current and I must invest in at least one equity, 1 commodity and one currency.

My thoughts so far:

ECB cut to be 0.25 basis points but no cut in deposit rate UK cuts not going to occur potential quantitate easing strong spanish and french bond sales

All this would point to a rally in equities markets. Thus thinking of going with equities with a higher beta which tend to have higher upside when market is in uptick and simultaneously shorting defensives (hedge) - eliminating most systematic risk

As regards currency I'm thinking long USD as positive bond selling will translate positively in US market and short sterling as QE demonstrates UKs weakness.

Also thinking as my commodity strategy to go long on copper and oil as these tend to do well in market uptick and have higher beta whilst simultaneously shorting gold?

1) My issue is how much of these predictions are already priced in. 2) Is my strategy way to basic? The more in depth and creative the better! 3) Are my assumptions correct

Any feedback, constructive criticism, tearing my idea apart. Adding to the idea. Giving me a completely now outlook on an idea would be very much appreciated!

FYI I am an intern hence the lack of sophistication and knowledge!

Yeah, I agree with the other comment that going long USD and long commodities isn't exactly a good paired trade. Normally, a stronger USD is going to put deflationary pressures on commodities. I'd caution you also against taking any position in gold as part of your strategy. Gold is either a risk on asset or a safe haven depending on the mood of the market. It has seemed to track closely with equities recently and then whenever inflationary fears arise on the back of more stimulus it reverts back to the safe haven status. Just a point to think about.

As far as the rate cut, I think the significance of it is already built it. I think i'd worry more about the other side of your trade and what would happen should they not cut rates, and hedge against that happening. That is probably the more severe reaction IMO. I always spend more time looking at the other side of your trade to see why someone would go against you.

What equities are you looking at? Sectors? Country?

I wouldn't say your strategy is basic at all and as an intern I think you've definitely got a solid gist of how interconnected markets are working together.

 
Addinator37:
IMFUTURE:
Just been asked to come up with a trade idea for my desk that will be hinged upon thursday economic data releases - french bonds sales, spanish bonds sales, EU rate decision and UK rate/QE decision. The strategy has to be very current and I must invest in at least one equity, 1 commodity and one currency.

My thoughts so far:

ECB cut to be 0.25 basis points but no cut in deposit rate UK cuts not going to occur potential quantitate easing strong spanish and french bond sales

All this would point to a rally in equities markets. Thus thinking of going with equities with a higher beta which tend to have higher upside when market is in uptick and simultaneously shorting defensives (hedge) - eliminating most systematic risk

As regards currency I'm thinking long USD as positive bond selling will translate positively in US market and short sterling as QE demonstrates UKs weakness.

Also thinking as my commodity strategy to go long on copper and oil as these tend to do well in market uptick and have higher beta whilst simultaneously shorting gold?

1) My issue is how much of these predictions are already priced in. 2) Is my strategy way to basic? The more in depth and creative the better! 3) Are my assumptions correct

Any feedback, constructive criticism, tearing my idea apart. Adding to the idea. Giving me a completely now outlook on an idea would be very much appreciated!

FYI I am an intern hence the lack of sophistication and knowledge!

Yeah, I agree with the other comment that going long USD and long commodities isn't exactly a good paired trade. Normally, a stronger USD is going to put deflationary pressures on commodities. I'd caution you also against taking any position in gold as part of your strategy. Gold is either a risk on asset or a safe haven depending on the mood of the market. It has seemed to track closely with equities recently and then whenever inflationary fears arise on the back of more stimulus it reverts back to the safe haven status. Just a point to think about.

As far as the rate cut, I think the significance of it is already built it. I think i'd worry more about the other side of your trade and what would happen should they not cut rates, and hedge against that happening. That is probably the more severe reaction IMO. I always spend more time looking at the other side of your trade to see why someone would go against you.

What equities are you looking at? Sectors? Country?

I wouldn't say your strategy is basic at all and as an intern I think you've definitely got a solid gist of how interconnected markets are working together.

Thanks for your reply, very helpful!

As I think stock prices will rise I'm thinking cyclicals. Sectors I would be looking at those with higher betas and those with stock with less exposure to EU so either EU stocks whose operating profits are not entirely generated from EU or that their profits are generated from stronger northern area of europe (German, Scan, Austria) and additionally stocks with high beta (preferably cyclicals) I'm thinking maybe financials (although thinking more swedish banks as safer and have had less of the "upcoming positive news of rates cuts" priced in), Barclays I think still looks cheap, consumers, manufacturing , travel, construction.

Do you think a reasonable hedge for if rates were to rise would be to short the housing market/mortgage market as increased rates = higher mortgage payments= less housing buyer. Any suggestions on a feasible hedge?

 
IMFUTURE:
Addinator37:
IMFUTURE:
Just been asked to come up with a trade idea for my desk that will be hinged upon thursday economic data releases - french bonds sales, spanish bonds sales, EU rate decision and UK rate/QE decision. The strategy has to be very current and I must invest in at least one equity, 1 commodity and one currency.

My thoughts so far:

ECB cut to be 0.25 basis points but no cut in deposit rate UK cuts not going to occur potential quantitate easing strong spanish and french bond sales

All this would point to a rally in equities markets. Thus thinking of going with equities with a higher beta which tend to have higher upside when market is in uptick and simultaneously shorting defensives (hedge) - eliminating most systematic risk

As regards currency I'm thinking long USD as positive bond selling will translate positively in US market and short sterling as QE demonstrates UKs weakness.

Also thinking as my commodity strategy to go long on copper and oil as these tend to do well in market uptick and have higher beta whilst simultaneously shorting gold?

1) My issue is how much of these predictions are already priced in. 2) Is my strategy way to basic? The more in depth and creative the better! 3) Are my assumptions correct

Any feedback, constructive criticism, tearing my idea apart. Adding to the idea. Giving me a completely now outlook on an idea would be very much appreciated!

FYI I am an intern hence the lack of sophistication and knowledge!

Yeah, I agree with the other comment that going long USD and long commodities isn't exactly a good paired trade. Normally, a stronger USD is going to put deflationary pressures on commodities. I'd caution you also against taking any position in gold as part of your strategy. Gold is either a risk on asset or a safe haven depending on the mood of the market. It has seemed to track closely with equities recently and then whenever inflationary fears arise on the back of more stimulus it reverts back to the safe haven status. Just a point to think about.

As far as the rate cut, I think the significance of it is already built it. I think i'd worry more about the other side of your trade and what would happen should they not cut rates, and hedge against that happening. That is probably the more severe reaction IMO. I always spend more time looking at the other side of your trade to see why someone would go against you.

What equities are you looking at? Sectors? Country?

I wouldn't say your strategy is basic at all and as an intern I think you've definitely got a solid gist of how interconnected markets are working together.

Thanks for your reply, very helpful!

As I think stock prices will rise I'm thinking cyclicals. Sectors I would be looking at those with higher betas and those with stock with less exposure to EU so either EU stocks whose operating profits are not entirely generated from EU or that their profits are generated from stronger northern area of europe (German, Scan, Austria) and additionally stocks with high beta (preferably cyclicals) I'm thinking maybe financials (although thinking more swedish banks as safer and have had less of the "upcoming positive news of rates cuts" priced in), Barclays I think still looks cheap, consumers, manufacturing , travel, construction.

Do you think a reasonable hedge for if rates were to rise would be to short the housing market/mortgage market as increased rates = higher mortgage payments= less housing buyer. Any suggestions on a feasible hedge?

If rates are rising short bonds. That is your hedge. Naturally, if rates are rising bonds will be selling off so you will be hedging yourself against that. The housing play I think is dangerous because you aren't going to directly or literally short housing prices as they are already depressed and in regards to the higher mortgage rates that will only affect those who are either on ARM's (which if you took out an arm in the last two years you are an idiot IMO) or those that are buying as the rates are rising. Even then, I think the effects will be marginal. Housing will be more driven by people with stable jobs and less debt (think student loans) to deal with and are ready to plunk down on a house.

If I remember you are talking short term, which, most of the things your mentioning are really longer term plays than I'm think. When you are going short and looking at an event as your driver you need equities that either haven't performed and are high beta (Financials come to mind in the recent weeks) or are directly related to the decision. What is your actual horizon? A day? Two? Weeks? From what i'm gathering your caught between looking out a few months as to what is undervalued and will outperform and then hedging that exposure should you be wrong.

As I said, if you are buying US equities you should worry more about the unemployment numbers on Friday than the ECB decisions on Thursday IMO.

 
mfoste1:
do your own job and come up with a trade

LOL... Why do you come onto this site? This post was way more relevant and thought provoking than probably 80 percent of the stuff posted here. Do you want to know about what to wear on your first day on the job and have swagon tell you 10 different ways to wear a fucking gucci suit and then some asshole telling you he never spends more than x amount? Or what about our workout habits explained 50 different ways, when there are really only 3 ways, 3 FUCKING WAYS (don't workout, workout, workout a lot).

 
killfrankgoreshead:
mfoste1:
do your own job and come up with a trade

LOL... Why do you come onto this site? This post was way more relevant and thought provoking than probably 80 percent of the stuff posted here. Do you want to know about what to wear on your first day on the job and have swagon tell you 10 different ways to wear a fucking gucci suit and then some asshole telling you he never spends more than x amount? Or what about our workout habits explained 50 different ways, when there are really only 3 ways, 3 FUCKING WAYS (don't workout, workout, workout a lot).

your post is completely incomprehensible

 
killfrankgoreshead:
mfoste1:
do your own job and come up with a trade

LOL... Why do you come onto this site? This post was way more relevant and thought provoking than probably 80 percent of the stuff posted here. Do you want to know about what to wear on your first day on the job and have swagon tell you 10 different ways to wear a fucking gucci suit and then some asshole telling you he never spends more than x amount? Or what about our workout habits explained 50 different ways, when there are really only 3 ways, 3 FUCKING WAYS (don't workout, workout, workout a lot).

Amen to that..

 

Great thread. As a prospective trader, this is very helpful to hear about the correlations, ways to hedge, etc

@Addinator --- Any books you know of that outline these types of correlations across markets/asset classes?

I've picked up a good amount from following the markets daily, but it would be great if there was a book/blog that could serve as a solid outline for this info.

 
NYorbust:
Great thread. As a prospective trader, this is very helpful to hear about the correlations, ways to hedge, etc

@Addinator --- Any books you know of that outline these types of correlations across markets/asset classes?

I've picked up a good amount from following the markets daily, but it would be great if there was a book/blog that could serve as a solid outline for this info.

There isn't really one big repository for all of this, but place like Zero Hedge really bring it together. Granted, there have a bearish/realistic bias, but the information there is outstanding. The interesting part about most of the asset classes is everything is so correlated nowadays it is had to find hedges because so many things move in sync. Globalization has really helped to drive markets closer together and make everything so interconnected. The best way to do it is how you are doing it now. Follow the markets, pull of overlay charts of different markets and asset classes. I mean there are obvious finance books, all the classics you hear about (I forget who it is, I think The King has a bunch of awesome reviews on WSO) but also read books like the world is flat, guns germs and steel, history books. Understand how the world has worked and works together and it helps to understand why certain assets will perform against one another. Read EVERYTHING. Read industry reports, if your in school you can probably still get morningstar or something through your library, and just try and absorb everything. I mean you can read the Fabozzi's and technical books to get a solid foundation but really aggregating all the information you can and scanning through it daily is the way to get it.

Sorry, that was a pretty longwinded answer to your books question but I think that you can use the information better if your the one seeing the correlations yourself. One thing I have is a watch list with a couple hundred tickers of all the industries and ETF's that I care about. You watch that day in and day out I guarantee you that you'll be able to write the book soon. Out of curiosity, what are you looking to trade?

 
bobbyjacob2222:
Hi, why to go for a strong dollar ? the actual stats are quite bad (unemployment, internal consumption, ...) for currency I would go on emerging market, if long (morrocco, algeria)

It's as another poster mentioned, It is basically a flight to safety at this point. I think you have to disconnect yourself from the internals and underpinnings of a normally functioning market and throw a lot of it out the window. The environment we are in is historically an aberration, or at least to what we've known in recent times. As bill gross says, its the cleanest dirty shirt (or something like that haha)

 

The problem is the market has pretty much priced in rate cuts. Remember what happened when Fed extended Operation Twist? In my opinion, the biggest surprises would be no cut or cut 50 bps by ECB. You should trade these, while hedge against your position. In terms of the inter-market relations, if Europe decided to ease further, USD would fall as it's safe-haven currency. For currencies, I would long AUD/USD or CAD/USD in case of an easing policy coming out of Europe.

Personally, I don't have too much experience when it comes to commodities. But I think I would long oil and gold if ECB decided to ease further. This is because, easing policy boosting economy is likely to pump up demand for oil, while gold acts as safe-haven from inflation.

 

Rerum debitis doloribus non velit. Accusantium quis qui qui quis. Molestiae est cum numquam ipsa. Porro molestias omnis quidem. Tempora sed cum dolor qui sed ea recusandae. Excepturi qui et neque.

 

Voluptatem repudiandae nihil dolore consequatur delectus iure fuga iste. Qui et dolore at ex omnis deserunt. Voluptatem vel temporibus ea reiciendis in. Maiores ab in eum et esse repudiandae aperiam. Ipsum debitis velit voluptatem ullam. Nostrum nihil ducimus hic necessitatibus.

Ipsum quis dolore eveniet accusamus quis voluptatem veritatis. Et eos rerum nostrum.

Career Advancement Opportunities

April 2024 Investment Banking

  • Jefferies & Company 02 99.4%
  • Goldman Sachs 19 98.8%
  • Harris Williams & Co. New 98.3%
  • Lazard Freres 02 97.7%
  • JPMorgan Chase 03 97.1%

Overall Employee Satisfaction

April 2024 Investment Banking

  • Harris Williams & Co. 18 99.4%
  • JPMorgan Chase 10 98.8%
  • Lazard Freres 05 98.3%
  • Morgan Stanley 07 97.7%
  • William Blair 03 97.1%

Professional Growth Opportunities

April 2024 Investment Banking

  • Lazard Freres 01 99.4%
  • Jefferies & Company 02 98.8%
  • Goldman Sachs 17 98.3%
  • Moelis & Company 07 97.7%
  • JPMorgan Chase 05 97.1%

Total Avg Compensation

April 2024 Investment Banking

  • Director/MD (5) $648
  • Vice President (19) $385
  • Associates (87) $260
  • 3rd+ Year Analyst (14) $181
  • Intern/Summer Associate (33) $170
  • 2nd Year Analyst (66) $168
  • 1st Year Analyst (205) $159
  • Intern/Summer Analyst (146) $101
notes
16 IB Interviews Notes

“... there’s no excuse to not take advantage of the resources out there available to you. Best value for your $ are the...”

Leaderboard

1
redever's picture
redever
99.2
2
Secyh62's picture
Secyh62
99.0
3
Betsy Massar's picture
Betsy Massar
99.0
4
BankonBanking's picture
BankonBanking
99.0
5
kanon's picture
kanon
98.9
6
CompBanker's picture
CompBanker
98.9
7
dosk17's picture
dosk17
98.9
8
GameTheory's picture
GameTheory
98.9
9
Jamoldo's picture
Jamoldo
98.8
10
bolo up's picture
bolo up
98.8
success
From 10 rejections to 1 dream investment banking internship

“... I believe it was the single biggest reason why I ended up with an offer...”