Macquarie IBD or Morgan Staley Equity Trading?
deleted deleted deleted deleted deleteddeleteddeleteddeleteddeleteddeleteddeleteddeleteddeleteddeleteddeleted
Trending Content - Investment Banking Forum
| +142 | ONLY THESE BANKS OR YOU STRUCK OUT | 37 | 1h |
| +111 | IB Energy Drink Tier List / Ranking | 73 | 1d |
| +59 | Firm Thinks I'm Lying About Offer | 19 | 1h |
| +51 | Feedback for internship first desk at IBD BB - personal fit, "don't be too confident" | 29 | 2d |
| +48 | Indiana University Fraternity Pipelines | 29 | 4h |
| +39 | Stay at Weak Dealflow Team or Lateral? | 12 | 7h |
| +34 | Elite Boutique interview questions | 8 | 9h |
| +32 | Rogo AI | 13 | 3h |
| +30 | Does BofA still pay its associates rat pellets? | 15 | 2d |
| +27 | Suspended for a Year | 11 | 6m |
Career Resources
FT or SA? What do you want to do?
MS is top-tier for S&T, Macquarie isn't super prestigious for IBD (seems to get a bad rap on WSO, but from what I can tell, it's still towards the higher end of MM IBD firms).
Two key questions: is this for FT or SA? Secondly, which do you want long-term?
If it's for FT, then pick based on job role and not prestige. Easier to go from Macquarie IBD to BB IBD than to go from S&T to IBD later on (I think - you should get other peoples' opinions on this).
If it's for SA, I'd actually give the same advice. Do Macquarie if you want to do IBD FT and then network over the summer with other BBs for IBD roles. One warning: I heard that Macquarie has a very low return offer rate for IBD SAs (around 50%). I think that return offer rates for MS S&T might not be too high either, but perhaps someone else can speak to that.
If you want to do S&T, then obviously go for MA S&T and never look back. Congrats on the offers!
.
Actually I've read that MS gives out a very large amount of FT offers to it's summer class. Personally I'd do the S&T.
I would go with MS. Aside from the brand name, Macquarie over hire for their summer intern class and they do not have a very high conversion rate in relative to other MM and BB banks.
And if this is for SA, you can always say "S&T isn't for me, I'd like to recruit for IB." MS brand will help you a lot more in this case.
Good luck and congrats on your offers.
Head of TMT at MS went from their S&T program into IBD.
This definitely isn't an outlier.
Head of TMT at MS went from their S&T program into IBD.
Yeah on second thought, given the above advice, I'd definitely take MS.
-__- I'm sorry I don't mean to be an ass, but how do you expect us to help you with this when you don't tell us what your goals are.
I will say, in Macquarie's defense, that they have some really nice, down to earth people. Everyone I met there was super friendly and easy to get along with.
Hi everyone, thank you for your comments. This is for SA. And I can't say for sure whether I prefer banking to trading or the other way around because I haven't done either, or done both to state my preference exactly. I have to say at this moment I am very interested in both offers. The people at Macquarie are super nice and their office is great. MS has amazing people too. Is it easy to go into IBD or research next year FT at MS if i do well in ST? Does anyone else know the conversion rate for MS? At macquarie, i heard last year was 20/35.
deleted deleted deleted deleted deleteddeleteddeleteddeleteddeleteddeleteddeleteddeleteddeleteddeleteddeleted
Take MS
Macquarie if you want to do investment banking, and it sounds like you do.
Magnam qui dolores consequuntur nulla mollitia. Voluptatibus voluptatem quis perspiciatis et quia rerum. Est quo optio quia voluptas consectetur quas.
Debitis recusandae ullam temporibus. Quibusdam expedita sit nostrum iure velit natus beatae. Quo doloribus non expedita impedit qui pariatur est cum.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...