Financial Restructuring
Explore in-court vs out-of-court options, debt vs equity restructuring, and key challenges.
What is Financial Restructuring?
Financial restructuring refers to reorganizing a company's capital structure and debt obligations to restore profitability or solvency or to provide liquidity, thus providing a further runway for the company to effect a turnaround.
Restructurings are aimed at providing a distressed business with a feasible plan to turn the business around and involve negotiations with creditors to assess the wide range of possible options, from asset sales to debt exchanges or amendments to terms.
Knowing financial restructuring is key to optimizing a company's performance in a tougher macroeconomic environment.
Restructuring activity and Liability Management Exercises (LMEs) are on the rise and only becoming more creative.
When a company wants to restructure, it can pursue either in-court or out-of-court transactions, depending on the level of distress and the willingness of stakeholders to cooperate.
- Financial restructuring helps companies facing financial distress by reorganizing the capital structure to improve liquidity and/or reduce debt. It can involve maturity extensions, interest rate reductions, debt exchanges, or a new money infusion.
- Restructuring transactions can occur in or out-of-court, with out-of-court always preferred where possible. Furthermore, they break down into Debt vs Equity restructurings, depending on what specific actions are undertaken.
- Stakeholder cooperation is crucial for a successful restructuring. The process requires careful negotiation between creditors, shareholders, and management (whose interests often don’t align) to produce a feasible solution, whether in or out of court.
Understanding Financial Restructuring
Financial restructuring involves complicated procedures, mainly in the organization's capital structures and balance sheet, aimed at bringing about better liquidity or more manageable maturity walls.
Maturity walls refer to periods when large portions of the company's capital structure come due. If these cannot be refinanced (as is common in distressed situations), the company faces a colossal debt repayment.
As mentioned above, a company has two options for financial restructuring: in-court transactions and out-of-court transactions.
In-court Transactions
In-court transactions involve a legal process where the company seeks protection from creditors through formal bankruptcy proceedings, such as Chapter 11 in the US.
During this process, the court oversees the restructuring and fair treatment of creditors, having to approve the eventual plan of reorganization. Creditors and the debtor are bound by the court's decisions.
In-court processes grant key advantages: Companies benefit from automatic stays that halt creditor actions, allowing them time to reorganize without the threat of foreclosure or asset seizure.
They also create binding agreements—restructuring agreements made in court are enforceable and binding on all parties, and dissenting creditors can be ‘crammed down,’ where an objecting portion of debt holders will be ignored if a sufficient majority consents to a restructuring plan.
Note
The in-court restructuring can be costly, time-consuming, and subject to public scrutiny, which may damage a company’s reputation.
Out-of-court Transactions
Out-of-court restructuring is more informal since the company will negotiate with creditors and stakeholders to obtain an agreement outside the courts. It's faster, cheaper, and more flexible compared to bankruptcy.
Some of the advantages are that costs are less expensive and confidentiality: with no legal fees and no court proceedings, out-of-court restructuring is more inexpensive. Since it's a private process, it doesn't carry the negative publicity that follows a bankruptcy filing.
Out-of-court transactions are always preferable due to the cheaper, quicker, and quieter process.
However, the success of out-of-court restructuring depends on voluntary participation and cooperation from all stakeholders. If certain creditors refuse to negotiate, the company may still need to resort to in-court proceedings.
Reasons for Financial Restructuring
Management is typically reluctant to initiate restructurings, as equity holders usually face a wipeout (or close to it). However, once things become sufficiently dire—or a critical event precipitates an urgent need—the company will face the inevitable.
Some reasons include:
- Over-leveraging and Debt Burden: Companies with excessive debt may struggle to meet interest and principal payments. Facing default, restructuring is often the only viable option.
- Operational Inefficiencies: Poor operational performance or declining revenues can lead to cash flow problems, such that a company may struggle to pay fixed expenses.
- Market Changes and Competition: Changes in consumer demand, increased competition, or technological disruption can erode a company’s market share and profitability, necessitating a restructuring to streamline its business model.
- Economic Downturns: Broader economic conditions (such as COVID-19) or industry-specific downturns often force companies to restructure to cope with temporarily depressed revenues/EBITDA.
In these scenarios, financial restructuring offers a lifeline by enabling companies to reallocate resources and adjust their debt obligations.
Types of Financial Restructuring
Financial restructuring can be categorized into two main types: debt restructuring and equity restructuring. Both are designed to alleviate financial distress but differ in the methods used and the parties involved.
Debt Restructuring
It concerns the change of existing terms of debt obligations a firm has to avoid insolvency and thus better its liquidity position. These negotiations are usually with the creditors, banks, and bondholders. Debt restructuring strategies include:
- Debt Rescheduling: This means that the company is extending the time in paying already existing loans. That way, it provides a company with extra time in servicing its debts. Therefore, spreading payments over time will reduce the cash flow pressure of the company on a short term.
- Interest Rate Changes: Creditors may agree to lower interest rates on outstanding loans to make debt servicing more manageable for the company. This helps reduce monthly payments, freeing up cash for operations.
Note
Alternatively, in combination with other techniques listed here, interest rates are often raised on debt during a restructuring—in return for a maturity extension, new money injection, or other measures.
- Debt-for-Equity Swaps: Sometimes, creditors agree to swap part of the debt for equity in the company. This decreases the burden of the total debt, but creditors receive ownership rights in the business. In this manner, creditors' interests are aligned with the long-term success of the business and may provide a better upside than debt investments to existing or new creditors.
- Debt Exchanges: Under extreme circumstances, lenders can be persuaded to exchange an existing debt for a new facility, usually writing down part of the debt against the total liabilities of a company on its balance sheet. This drastic measure can bring a quick respite to an ailing company.
Equity Restructuring
Equity restructuring focuses on the form of ownership of a company by changing its structure to enhance financial strength. This can be accomplished through new issues, existing share buy-backs, or debt-to-equity conversion. Some common techniques include:
- Equity Infusion: In raising capital and reducing debt, companies may issue new shares to investors, current shareholders, or new investors. This infusion of equity capital can be used in the payment of debts or in investment initiatives for growth.
- Share Buybacks: Companies with cash on their books may buy the shares from the market. In effect, it reduces the shares outstanding and increases the share percentage of the existing owners but also signals confidence regarding future prospects.
- Mergers and Acquisitions (M&A): Equity restructuring may occur through mergers with or acquisitions of other companies, where the surviving entity consolidates resources and financial assets to strengthen its position in the market.
Financial Restructuring Process
Financial restructuring involves multiple stakeholder management. The inclusion of management, creditors, investors, and regulatory authorities makes it a complex and tiring task. The following are the steps that are included in a typical financial restructuring.
Assessment of Financial Health
The first thing in financial restructuring involves executing a thorough evaluation of the company's financial health.
This includes reviewing the balance sheet, cash flow statement, income statement, and capital structure to understand the extent of the financial distress.
There are several key financial metrics involved in financial restructuring that assess the capability of the organization to meet its obligations. Some of the key metrics include debt-to-equity ratios, liquidity ratios, and interest coverage ratios.
Engagement with Stakeholders
Afterward, the company needs to engage with key stakeholders, typically the largest creditors (by holding and seniority) and potentially equity holders depending on the situation - in a highly distressed context, equity value is often wiped out, so their relevance decreases.
The company, as well as different classes of creditors, will engage advisers (restructuring investment banks, law firms, and operational turnaround consultants) and work on potential solutions.
Development of a Restructuring Plan
Stakeholders take an active part in restructuring plans because they assess what is feasible. These discussions and assessments can revolve around actions the company intends to take, such as debt rescheduling, asset sales, or new funding.
The key idea is to build a roadmap for current operations while balancing the demands of stakeholders.
Implementation of Restructuring Measures
Once the plan is approved by stakeholders, the company begins implementing the restructuring measures. This may include negotiating new loan terms with creditors, issuing new shares, or selling off non-core assets to generate cash.
Note
The implementation process should be monitored closely since it is critical to ensure that the company stays true to the organizational objectives and desired financial outcomes.
Monitoring and Adjustments
Note that restructuring is a cyclical process in which there should be continuous monitoring on the part of the organization in order to benefit greatly from the same.
Companies, in fact, should monitor some key financial indicator including cash flow, profitability, and debt levels in their attempts to assure effective measures in restructuring.
If need be, adjustments can be made to the plan to address the new challenges or opportunities arising.
Financial Restructuring Challenges
Some of the challenges an organization can face during the financial restructuring include the following:
- Stakeholder Resistance: The creditors and other stakeholders can't reach a consensus given their overlapping interests in the organization. For example, shareholders may resist debt-for-equity swaps that dilute their ownership, while creditors may be reluctant to forgive debt or accept lower interest rates.
- Legal and Regulatory Hurdles: Legal requirements may vary significantly across jurisdictions, so transactions and strategies common in the US may be impractical in the UK or EU.
- Operational Disruption: Implementation of restructuring measures, the sale of assets, and the reduction of the workforce have been known to throw life into disarray and render companies spending their precious financial assets. Companies must maintain disruption of short-term operation issues for the protection of a company's long-term financial welfare.
Conclusion
Financial restructuring is a strategic tool that distressed companies use to organize their capital structure, which allows the businesses a real chance of an effective turnaround.
Financial restructuring, in the form of debt restructuring or equity restructuring, is a process in which the primary goal is to improve liquidity, manage maturity walls, and place the company on a path of recovery.
While the process is complex and fraught with challenges, and in-court processes usually take a substantial period of time, restructurings ultimately produce the best possible solution for all stakeholders.
Those interested in reading more about it should visit WSO’s other articles on topics within the industry, as well as WSO’s RX Course.
Free Resources
To continue learning and advancing your career, check out these additional helpful WSO resources:
or Want to Sign up with your social account?