One of two in the case study stage where I went first vs. the other candidate. Case went ok - interviewers were decently complimentary but there are spots where I could've articulated better.
Citadel HR told recruiter after that it was "good but team was not blown away, so will wait to see the other candidate" but asked for comps / walkaway economics regardless from my current seat.
Am I effectively now on hold / backup?
| +38 | How much modeling do experienced HF analysts/PMs actually do? | 15 | 2h |
| +22 | Buy Side Credit - Seats / Guide | 8 | 21h |
| +18 | London buy side | 3 | 7h |
| +18 | Hedge Fund Pivot | 6 | 4h |
| +11 | Mid-career shift to buy side with niche background | 3 | 4d |
| +9 | Wfh / work remotely at MMs or SMs? | 5 | 3d |
| +3 | Atlantic Wolf Capital Closing? | 5 | 13h |
| +3 | How old is too old? | 3 | 1d |
| 0 | Walleye Capital | 1 | 2d |
| 0 | Hedge funds | 1 | 4d |
Career Resources
Get instant access to lessons taught by experienced private equity pros and bulge bracket investment bankers including financial statement modeling, DCF, M&A, LBO, Comps and Excel Modeling.
Based on the most helpful WSO content, it seems that you are likely in a "wait-and-see" position. The feedback from Citadel HR indicates that while your performance was solid, it did not stand out enough to secure an immediate offer. By asking for comps and walkaway economics, they are keeping you in consideration but are likely prioritizing the evaluation of the other candidate before making a final decision.
This situation suggests you are effectively on hold or serving as a backup option, depending on how the other candidate performs. It’s not a definitive rejection, but it does mean you may need to wait for their decision.
Sources: Citadel (Surveyor) Case Study/Modeling Test, Is My Upcoming Scheduled Phone Call with HR a Rejection on its Way? (3 working days post final round interview), Mckinsey interview on hold-- has anyone had this?, 7 Things I Hate About Citi, Does Citadel Check Transcript?
you basically need to do an mba at a top school to break in now
congrats on HBS!
second this did my ENT stint at RMG
No I did the case study and was second to go but got past it despite some of the same feedback. the feedback on my end was more about polish associated with the code, rather than anything in a submitted PDF
Et assumenda laborum iste et. Totam harum qui ea at accusamus ullam. Non cum maxime sunt et impedit non. Qui nulla fuga eius qui possimus id repellendus.
Expedita quam ea facere eos sint. Labore impedit sequi minima aut et officia. Non iure quia ut non excepturi. Non enim dolor laboriosam aut reiciendis qui quia.
Odio vitae qui sapiente aspernatur voluptate. Ut aut est hic omnis et. Cumque eum iusto occaecati ut. Id necessitatibus commodi deserunt qui nostrum.
Dignissimos magni sapiente debitis sunt nisi iusto enim. Rem quod non at nihil molestiae maiores. Expedita rerum voluptatem velit et consequatur eveniet voluptas. Sit neque quibusdam qui dolores.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...