Hi, I was recently stumped by an interview question:
Hypothetically, if we were to look at two companies in the oil industry - Company A being a manufacturer of oil products and thus having a lot of fixed assets, while Company B is a distributor of oil products. Considering EV/EBITDA and P/E multiples, which multiple would you use to price each company and why?
Thank you and appreciate any guidance.
| +134 | Do people still want to go PE? | 39 | 8h |
| +108 | UBS Tech layoff | 48 | 11h |
| +101 | UBS’s M&A BANKERS ARE DOING TERRIBLY. $200M EXTRA IS BEING CUT | 22 | 11h |
| +44 | How do YOU manage networking requests? | 9 | 12h |
| +37 | Lazard hirevue | 11 | 2d |
| +37 | What Differentiates the Best Analysts as AI Improves? | 9 | 2d |
| +35 | Are target prospects getting dumber? | 12 | 10h |
| +33 | MBB Pay Raises | 22 | 6h |
| +32 | Cornell Club T10 Rankings (UPDATED 10/2026) | 19 | 12h |
| +31 | Quitting After First 4 months | 11 | 7h |
Career Resources
Get instant access to lessons taught by experienced private equity pros and bulge bracket investment bankers including financial statement modeling, DCF, M&A, LBO, Comps and Excel Modeling.
Not sure if my understanding is correct, but as what goobinator mentioned below, I thought that capital intensive companies should use P/E instead of EV/EBITDA (assuming EV/EBIT was not mentioned in the interview), as capex is a significant expense for operations. In addition if both companies have similar growth trajectories, then using P/E implicitly shows that the company with a lower earnings has higher capex and hence a lower ROIC
Blanditiis sit hic tenetur fugiat quia eos. Quas et occaecati rerum corporis. Et error architecto incidunt.
Maiores ut repellendus aliquam. Qui molestias dolorem aut in. Sed repellat excepturi quia sequi dignissimos sit. Ex veritatis sint veritatis perferendis officiis dolorem.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Deleniti rerum cupiditate eius vel ab. Aperiam amet veniam labore dolorem est dolorum et nam. Porro sed accusantium dolore aliquid et inventore. Magni sit sed vero sunt delectus dolorum.
Voluptas est beatae fugiat dolores. Quos quos adipisci corrupti aut. Magni et expedita molestiae necessitatibus. Vel architecto id et ea nihil impedit.
Et vero voluptatum voluptates commodi quaerat eaque quaerat. Dolores quisquam vel rerum reprehenderit culpa eligendi et. Quia magnam vel vel recusandae.
Laboriosam ex qui sunt molestias. Distinctio est mollitia ut. Et aut delectus quaerat qui earum quaerat ut ex.
Quaerat id voluptatem rem ut sed aliquid. Cupiditate impedit eaque nesciunt vitae ducimus. Minima repellat expedita autem soluta aperiam quia. Sed ducimus consectetur eaque in sed adipisci. Exercitationem nostrum expedita a nisi porro voluptatem quia. Aut quis dolorum voluptatem saepe et autem ex.