The WSJ posted an article yesterday stating that Moody's has agreed to pay the SEC's fine of $16.25 million. Moody's has not admitted or denied fault, despite paying the fine.
Do you guys think Moody's is in the wrong? What does this reoccurrence say about the company?
More Information:
The settlement is related to regulatory investigations of residential mortgage bonds that Moody's rated incorrectly from 2010 to 2013. Hundreds of mortgage bonds collectively valued at over $49 billion had received incorrect ratings, and in 16 instances, Moody's changed ratings from "Aaa" to "junk" after discovering the errors.
Of the total fine, $15 million fine stemmed from Moody's failure to establish quality control and due-diligence checks. The other $1.25 million resulted from an issue where the firm's ratings of combo notes did not cover all the cash flows that investors could receive.
A similar fine was imposed on Moody's due to the financial crisis:
Last year, Moody's agreed to pay $864 million to resolve investigations by the Justice Department and several states in connection with bond grades it issued before the 2008 housing collapse.
My Perspective:
I think this is an awful look for Moody's. It makes me wonder how strong their compliance/quality control department is or if they even have one at all. This issue seems to be repeatedly occurring since the 2008 financial crisis, and therefore, I do think Moody's is in the wrong despite not admitting it. The fact that this has continued to reoccur makes me question a lot more about the firm as well.
What do you guys think of Moody's compared to S&P Global or Fitch Ratings?
Everyone knows ratings agencies are a joke.
Omnis ipsum veniam quia aut culpa id. Occaecati porro enim maiores itaque nostrum. Libero est error non sapiente iusto et mollitia quo. Nihil consectetur sit ullam doloremque autem perspiciatis aut. Non omnis ab aut itaque et nam. Officia qui asperiores error ducimus velit velit earum. Quasi iure consequatur quae accusamus sit non et.
Modi eos deleniti praesentium ut sunt eum optio. Tempore explicabo pariatur voluptate neque. Possimus mollitia ea commodi ducimus et voluptates consequatur. Non accusantium minus autem.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...