Do you think you’re happier in finance than if you worked in another industry?
How does your happiness compare to people you know who work in other fields? Do they seem less or more content than you do, and why?
Would be helpful to know what segment within finance you’re currently in
Based on the WSO Dataset, I can tell you that happiness in the finance industry can vary greatly from person to person. For me, I've found great satisfaction in my current role, having transitioned from Private Equity to Hedge Funds. The primary source of my happiness stems from my intellectual curiosity and the fulfillment I derive from working towards my career goals.
Comparing happiness across different fields can be tricky, as it's highly subjective and dependent on personal values and goals. However, I've noticed that the key to happiness in any job is not to compare yourself to others. The moment you start doing that, you're on a slippery slope.
As for your question about the segment within finance I'm currently in, I'm in Hedge Funds. I made the pivot from Private Equity and have found it to be a rewarding decision.
Remember, at the end of the day, it's about finding what makes you happy and fulfilled. Whether that's in finance or another field, only you can make that determination.
Sources: Are you guys happy with life? Help me please., Who is happy & satisfied with their current role?, Saying Goodbye to Finance?, What makes you happy outside of work? Have it all but stuck in a void., Who is happy & satisfied with their current role?
ChatGPT is running a hedge fund? Wow they grow up so fast.
People working in other fields may have more free time but many seem miserable from what I’ve noticed, just in different ways than an analyst feeling overworked
How so?
mundane work. not much comradery with peers. more than usual corporate political BS. idiot co workers
People not in top tier fields are usually miserable because outside of family and friends they often have zero purpose in life, especially the average corporate job. At least in IB and similar fields you can feel like you are competing with smart people.
Medical residents on average are the most miserable bunch to be around. Finance bros are probably a close second.
Medical profession especially with upcoming Gen Z are a crazy money hungry group of people who don't understand basic business or economic terms (many medical residents I know went into medicine for the money / prestige). At least finance bros aren't as naive.
I disagree with this a decent amount this is coming from someone who has a lot of experience in both of these circles
Medical residents/physicians are just as likely if not moreso to have a big ego for sure, but they don't go into that occupation solely for money or 'prestige' that comes with it, instead usually for some passion or interest in the field. If there is prestige it reflects in a completely different way than how bankers / lawyers / MBA types view prestige. Medicine prestige is about getting research published, what health system or academic institution you work for, and just a general respect that comes with being a doctor. MBA/Law type prestige is more... commercial maybe? When I visit my friends in NYC it is MUCH more appearances based than anything I have ever seen from doctor colleagues. A 'who you know, what type of work do you do, how much money you make' etc. type conversation all the time.
Money is a byproduct of being a doctor, but it usually isnt the goal - this isnt the case for high paying white collar profesional jobs. If you made a decision tree on their decision to be a doctor then on average 'money' would rarely be at the top, often might not even be top 3. That wouldnt be the case for a consultant/lawyer/banker who would make a career change to taste testing cat turds if it came with a $MM bonus every spring (speaking as one myself)
You are spot on that they are miserable though. They work similar hours to banking and the pay is shit, and similarly they get treated like shit on the job by not just doctors but also nurses. And medicine isnt as refined as corporate jobs in terms of 'soft skills' so your feedback when you suck will have no punches held back, compared to a struggling 23 year old who needs to work on 'attention to detail'.
they are naive and pretty bad when it comes to money will give you that. In fact, assuming you have decent financial knowledge, you are honestly better off building wealth by going to a state school and getting a CPA and doing B4 schtick than by becoming an AVERAGE doctor in terms of building wealth. They spend so much time hyper focused on one area that they really have no idea what a budget, investing, mortgages, etc. look like once they get their attending salaries.
Fair enough. Very familiar with the space and used to have a lot of friends in the space.
I was generalizing a lot and agree with a lot of your points.
'Medicine prestige is about getting research published, what health system or academic institution you work for, and just a general respect that comes with being a doctor.' - so true, probably the most arrogant person I know is a Harvard medical resident right now and it's literally become his personality.
MANY medical professionals are in it for money and prestige (perceived bc there is none). Don’t fool yourself. Go read White Coat Investor forum or Student Doctor Network and get a glimpse. Every other thread is about how to make more money, how $500k isn’t enough, and how they shouldn’t have to work call etc.
Doctors are greedy, they just suck at business and finance and are too proud to admit it imo.
Lol it sound like in the US, society is one of the most unequal and divided in many ways so many people will be unhappy regardless of professions they choose to do
Comparions and high expectations about what life should be leads to misery.
Munger said that the key to a happy life is to have low expectations about anything, and that's true. Many people in the 20th century stayed all their life in the same job, being happily married with the same person for decades, etc. but current generations feel that they're life should resemble some famous influencer or they're a failure.
Life must be very different in the US lol. We as people naturally tend to compare ourselves, but in France we do not seem to have the same aspirations as you folks from wall st. People here are more content with ourselves than what I see from students on this site, which I would think is also rather niche and not representative of everyone else, but the societies and cultures are vastly different regardless which may be why attitudes and expectations are different
I think the discontent and status aspirations of Americans is part of what makes our economy the fastest growing and most robust in the developed world.
Europeans are too busy taking long lunch breaks, retiring early, blocking mergers and regulating technology to accelerate beyond what they are now.
Agreed - free markets and capitalism is what drives innovation and economic development
The Europeans with their long lunches and mandated holiday may result in less resilient economies - but if they're more satisfied as a result, surely there's a lot of value in that?
In some ways I could see this being the case for many people
Europeans (French for sure) have given up on trying to accumulate wealth or consider different career alternatives it’s virtually impossible for them to do so. Their economies have been lapped for decades. They have resided to taking naps, working 35 hrs a week and going to festivals while obeying their nanny state gov like good little sheep. After doing this for a few decades, they believe they should be able to retire with gov pension so they can go to the beach and hit up more festivals. They bitch when austerity measures are back on the table.
Europe is nothing to aspire to. You can claim that wasn’t the point of your post and you are just pointing out differences but it’s clear what you are trying to say.
Also, Texas is bigger than France. Good day.
Probably part of why many people are unhappy
People aren’t going to be happy if they compare themselves to others.
There’s always going to be some people who have it better in some ways, but if we compare ourselves to everyone else, it’ll seem like person A is smarter, person B has more time, person C makes more, etc.
Social media has made this worse where people mainly see others with tons of free time always posting about their vacations and doing cool stuff, while we chose a path in finance so we work 70+ hours every week, and with the little free time we have we see others having more fun so we think people in other fields have it better but it may not be that way for everyone
“Comparison is the thief of joy.”
This is it, every time I compare I feel myself becoming less and less happy. Living a comparison free life and genuinely being happy for others is such a good way to live.
Medicine, law, finance, consulting -> work long hours and feel overworked, leading to unhappiness
SWE / Engineering-> Hyper competitive, need to be really smart and keep creating new ideas and keep up with newest developments, people become unhappy
Every job sucks in some ways and if it takes up too much of your time or your thoughts
If it takes up too much of your time or thoughts, then what? Don’t leave us hanging…
I have been in a variety of different industries outside of finance.
You cannot have 8 favorites.
You remind me of my college advisor. I told her I wanted to study Business and Spanish and get dual degrees. She said it wasn't possible. I proceeded to get a B.S. in Business, a B.A. in Spanish, and started a new minor called East Asian Studies, whereby I specialized in Chinese and studied through Columbia learning Mandarin at Peking University.
I started off in academia and did a brief stint in medical writing before joining the street and I can 100% say I'm happiest where I am. I also briefly worked in tech while on a non-compete and experienced what it's like to be a start-up type of environment, and still chose to go back to high finance. To me finance is a welcome challenge and worth the extra effort it requires. For starters, getting paid well matters and motivates you. I also enjoy the faster pace and like the excitement of daily market movements and trying to stay on top of things. It's also a bonus being surrounded by other smart, motivated people (for the most part). In many ways the environment is like academia in that I'm always learning new things and challenging myself, except it is actually faster paced and less adherent to group-think. I would say one of the only downsides is that you do tend to encounter more sociopaths and eccentric personalities, but at least it makes for good stories. The rigid office environment used to be somewhat of a bummer too, but thanks to Covid it's now still acceptable to WFH at least a couple days a week which makes a huge difference.
In general, I think if you don't like challenges, aren't competitive and have a strong lazy streak then finance is not for you and you'll be miserable, not even the money will make a difference.
Dang, that last line characterizes my current state of mind lol
I want to fit in
Lol seems like every other person is unhappy in some ways after graduating college
Repellendus accusantium est eius placeat aspernatur laudantium. Ut voluptatem consequatur voluptatem sint ut odit quas. Incidunt delectus quis sunt est soluta ipsa ipsum. Ex eius nulla molestiae ut laudantium ut temporibus.
Ratione iusto ex rerum qui officiis quibusdam repellendus. Voluptatem rerum occaecati sequi atque dolores.
Dolor minima non tenetur nostrum a ut. Blanditiis quidem eius error natus explicabo velit necessitatibus. Voluptas praesentium porro ab. Placeat aut nostrum vero magnam dicta enim non. Vero laudantium aut ea dolores provident dicta est.
Nisi nisi tenetur autem quam rerum qui itaque temporibus. At quasi praesentium quia id sit aut. Officiis commodi totam dicta beatae odit aut et.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
In asperiores quia perferendis corporis debitis. Error et eaque autem alias quia.