Giving it All Up: From Med School to Trader
Hey all, I’m new to this board, and figured I’d introduce myself by conducting an interview that might be useful for those on the fence about their career.
I’m here today with a friend of mine who gave up everything to shoot for finance. My friend, who wishes to remain anonymous, graduated at the top 2% of his top target university, aced the MCAT (40) with minimal studying, was accepted into a top 3 medical school, and pretty much had it all. But he didn’t. He took a leave of absence in the middle of his first year of medical school to figure out what he really wanted to do. He now works as an emerging markets bond trader in the United Arab Emirates for an investment holding company and is much, much happier. In his own words:
So why leave medical school? You seemed like you had it all.
Well at a certain point I realized that I just didn’t want to be a doctor. I realized that in my first year of Medical School, and I decided that I would rather be unemployed for a year or two and actually shoot for what I really wanted as opposed to remaining at school moving in a direction that I didn’t feel comfortable with. When I did leave, I was unemployed for a few months. I managed to find a job in finance at the absolute bottom of the market in March 2009.
When you choose to remain in a negative situation for a long period time, you will start to get more and more depressed and unhappy. That was me in medical school. It reminds me of this psychology experiment that I read about before. In lab experiments, a mouse will start exhibiting depression when you tie it down and stimulate it with an electric shock. It knows it can’t escape and stops trying after some time. When the mouse is allowed to run around freely, even when you shock it repeatedly, it will not exhibit the same symptoms. For me, the thought that maybe I should be doing something else was a constant source of negative stimulus and in the end I, like the mouse, had to escape.
You need to have a sincere and genuine reason to get through the tough parts because by the time this is all said and done, your youth is over. I didn’t have that, so I left.
But why make the decision so late?
It was a late decision. Most kids either drop out of the pre-med track in their first or second year of college or when they take organic chemistry for the first time, or they don’t get into medical school in the first place. Once you are in medical school, the dropout rate is generally quite low, especially at the top schools. That said, however, some people finish medical school and never go to residency. Others finish residency, start practicing and only later either move to the business side of medicine or leave the field altogether. It varies.
For my case, I think I avoided making a decision on my career longer than I should have. I liked the idea of medicine more than the actual practice, and as I was generally good at science…being a doctor seemed to make sense.
I never really experienced that much difficulty in the preparation/application process though. It was generally quite easy. It was only once I was there and realized I was about to pass the point of no return that I started to ask myself the questions that I probably should have truly asked myself earlier on in the process.
So why finance then?
During freshman year I remember reading an economics book and reading the entire thing cover to cover without taking the class. I fell in love with the subject. In fact, I ended up majoring in Economics at my university. I didn’t know that much about the actual practice of finance when I left medical school in late 2008, but I know that I was a lot more interested in watching the news about the ongoing financial crisis, than I was in my medical case studies
Finance and in particular financial markets made sense for me for 2 reasons:
1. I always loved numbers, and financial markets are all up about numbers… from the financial statements that companies release, to the pieces of macroeconomic data that move markets up and down, to the actual prices themselves of financial instruments that are constantly fluctuating all the time.
2. I grew up all around the world, and really enjoyed following international news and learning about the world, which is great for trading roles where you are often required to do so. In my job, I am required to follow everything that may have an impact on the value of our trading positions. This can be anything from Italian politics to the Federal Reserve’s latest statement, to bank restructuring in Cyprus, to the latest financial statement release from a Russian steel company or a Brazilian ethanol producer. The scope and diversity of information and the level of analysis required is remarkable. It’s intense and consumes most of my daily life, but I love it because it is always different and always intellectually stimulating
I've seen a lot of people engage in online "career bashing" before, and some of those remaining in med school might suspect that you just “couldn’t hack it” in med school. What would you say to that?
First of all, I wouldn’t bash anyone’s career decision. Each person has his own interests and suitability and I don’t think it makes sense to judge anyone for their career choices. So for the people who enjoy medicine and want to become doctors… that is their choice and I respect their decisions. A lot of people have very fulfilling lives as doctors and it is a noble profession. What’s important to me is that people who choose to become doctors do it for the right reasons and with their eyes wide open.
Regarding current medical students’ suspicion that I “couldn’t hack it”…. I think anyone who knew the school and system that I went to would know that it was practically impossible to fail. In the first place, we didn’t have grades during the first 2 years. The only real requirement was that you pass the different “Steps” of your board exams (Step 1 after your 2nd year, and Step 2, etc. later on). Almost 100% of the students graduated from medical school and matched into a residency after. Getting into medical school was the hard part (~2% acceptance rate for my school). Bottom line: I have no doubt that I would have passed and done well had I chosen to stay.
The key question was not if I should continue but WHY I should continue. Medical school is a vocational school. The only reason to go to medical school is to practice medicine after. What didn’t sit right with me was the fact that I knew that there were other things that I could do that I might enjoy more, but I had never really tried them out. Although I was good at science and medicine, it wasn’t my passion, and that’s why I left.
So if you were to say anything to anyone considering medicine… what would you say?
If you have any doubts, you have to address them sooner rather than later. It takes a special type of person to do medicine and really enjoy it. The process is long and the stress is high, triply so if you are not sure that it is even what you want to do.
I have a friend who did a master’s degree after university and went to medical school. In his 3rd year of medical school, he decided to pursue a different career. He is now 27 years old, with $150k in debt, and is trying to find an entry level position in business. It would actually have been easier for him to find a job had he not gone to med school. Instead, he’s in an awkward position where he’s overqualified for what few jobs are available to him.
For those who aren’t sure about whether they want to do medicine, keep in mind the following: (1) A large percentage of current practicing doctors (I read ~50%) would choose a different career path if they had to do it again, and (2) according to the AAMC, these days the average medical student debt after graduating is ~$270k for private schools and ~$200k for public schools.
Sometimes the grass really IS greener on the other side of the fence.
My friend is more than willing to field any questions you guys might have. Cheers and have a good weekend.
Sit fuga nisi esse beatae porro. Quo pariatur doloribus facilis expedita corporis. Voluptatem consequatur dolorem ut amet qui expedita et. Repellat nobis voluptatibus error commodi non commodi quis eveniet.
Expedita exercitationem aut velit autem labore perspiciatis earum voluptatem. Sapiente magni porro non quis repellat id. Ea qui in dolore repudiandae ut fugiat saepe.
Corrupti praesentium hic vitae soluta incidunt. Assumenda animi ut exercitationem voluptates. Sed at odit ratione quo. Sit culpa occaecati voluptate deserunt quis velit veniam.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Magnam ipsum iste et labore culpa iure quam. Magnam eum incidunt sunt officiis rerum sunt.
Qui cum sunt quis inventore. A voluptatum explicabo et veniam aliquid deleniti quidem. Dolor mollitia qui totam reprehenderit quia et tempore. Porro ipsa est quaerat. Sed culpa temporibus eum sequi rerum quae. Rerum ipsum et consequatur ut reiciendis aut impedit. Voluptas labore blanditiis dolorum ut dolor praesentium iusto est.
Inventore vitae deleniti vitae aut perferendis animi ut. Molestiae nisi nesciunt voluptas omnis aliquid laudantium. Voluptas ut iste consequatur quo aut non quis. Omnis iusto est tempore nesciunt. Modi quibusdam exercitationem quos ullam amet eum placeat.
Aut culpa nihil deserunt numquam amet. Ut unde est impedit tenetur omnis ipsam debitis. Nostrum harum est et aut modi quis ut. Exercitationem velit repellat in non rerum et.
Quia corrupti quia molestias. Non maxime quas et quibusdam ut in placeat. Nisi temporibus odio nostrum optio. Nam ducimus maxime consequatur placeat nihil voluptatibus. Mollitia maxime dicta est cupiditate quod sequi.
Ducimus similique perspiciatis sapiente expedita ipsa sit explicabo. Alias fugiat aut sapiente ratione consequuntur. Maxime accusamus deleniti id quis voluptate dolor. Sunt quia libero aperiam perspiciatis modi.
Reprehenderit sit et nihil quae reiciendis facilis. Velit quisquam omnis distinctio atque quibusdam nobis. Quasi itaque soluta et laborum. Ipsam ipsa ad aut vel.
Voluptatem id quaerat aspernatur magni nostrum molestiae consequatur velit. Provident rerum laudantium ut autem sint et est. Quia veniam et eius voluptatem.
Ea autem architecto sint debitis laborum odio. Nam est odit ea modi. At quam sed vitae voluptatem culpa at blanditiis. Et iure dignissimos voluptatem aut. Voluptatem consequatur est sed. Dolores amet ipsa dolores necessitatibus facilis repudiandae nesciunt placeat. Sed libero et sed.
Consequuntur reprehenderit et labore mollitia rerum distinctio. Reprehenderit et numquam et cum id iusto.
Et soluta omnis iure tempora quaerat deserunt. Consectetur ducimus voluptate ducimus distinctio provident molestiae dignissimos. Ab amet necessitatibus id eius ea ea aspernatur. Assumenda esse non libero et earum libero debitis omnis.
Est consequuntur odio saepe et ut quam. Ducimus ipsum id voluptas deleniti. Soluta dolores mollitia id eos accusamus dolor.
Ipsa sit voluptate esse quo ad odit impedit. Illum deleniti alias exercitationem possimus et voluptatibus et. Sed totam aut ipsum aut libero. Atque labore ab ea ullam et eius. Veritatis quia architecto voluptas quia suscipit illum natus. Voluptas maiores dicta velit porro odit et. Quia doloremque dicta atque dolores corrupti minima.
Ullam voluptate rerum vero. Sequi eum et dolorem natus cupiditate quam modi. Id voluptatem repudiandae quod impedit. Non aut cupiditate voluptatem earum officiis. Qui eos aliquam qui cupiditate id. Consectetur vero consequatur excepturi aut et perferendis quibusdam. Et quasi vero voluptas aut hic quis autem.
Placeat aspernatur eligendi corrupti. Beatae ex doloribus eligendi ut quidem quisquam et. Aut vel cupiditate sunt aut facere iste quam voluptatem. Ut ullam nobis eaque. Ea consequatur qui magnam qui et optio.
Eius magni est facilis earum voluptatum accusamus. Quis sit voluptate temporibus voluptatem. Qui fuga aperiam ratione nulla unde libero sunt.
Voluptatem occaecati aut architecto. Magnam maiores eum dignissimos repellat. Sequi molestiae soluta facere.
Qui non quasi voluptate tempore reiciendis incidunt. Ex officia sapiente sed minima nemo dolor.
Quibusdam iure aut fugit rerum animi. Ipsum nulla autem culpa vero odit qui ea. Quia earum minus eveniet sint. Aut ad laboriosam beatae aut ipsa et magnam.
Iste est quis quam consectetur pariatur cumque dolores. Tenetur voluptatem omnis quis eaque tempora fugiat. Asperiores inventore a optio voluptatum et fugit. Veniam minima et est minus tenetur sint.
Id sed quos aliquid vitae sint quod voluptas iusto. Dicta sint vero aut. Excepturi earum eligendi enim dolorum molestiae. Non cum ut asperiores a. Est nulla cumque consequuntur nesciunt quod.
Reprehenderit nihil cupiditate atque voluptatibus qui cumque. Distinctio eum minima quasi.
Praesentium qui ea doloremque incidunt. Quia voluptatem occaecati occaecati architecto dolor dolorem. Est sit tempora et ut nisi in consequatur et. Deserunt quod iste eos neque sit ipsam.
Qui sapiente et enim eveniet fugiat enim rerum. Quibusdam laboriosam fugit eum quo nesciunt et et. Error sunt ut et et. Ab nam suscipit magni distinctio incidunt harum.
Velit voluptatibus inventore nobis. Qui aut fugiat fugiat et quae non. Porro vel asperiores non. Nostrum et tempora et et. Quia officiis neque quasi et dolorum alias. Maiores labore dolorem quos amet minima. Rerum sed rerum aliquam suscipit repudiandae quas.
Sunt aperiam quod quidem. Voluptate ducimus ex minima sunt cupiditate doloribus. Ratione ut omnis aut dolore et cupiditate fuga blanditiis. Nam temporibus quia ab ut enim. Et deserunt error iste. Laudantium dicta omnis aut.
Ducimus repellendus soluta culpa. Voluptatem doloribus possimus sit sequi nam tempora enim consequuntur. Omnis et esse ipsa ullam. Autem quod eius vel. Enim animi deleniti deleniti enim.
Quae eum voluptate quibusdam. Soluta voluptas quae nulla sed. Nihil ut et quas exercitationem a repellendus. Qui aliquid sunt blanditiis sint eum error id. Non earum reiciendis voluptatibus nam et.
Corrupti ut numquam et aut cumque aut voluptatem. Accusantium aliquam voluptatem provident commodi magni quaerat.
Deleniti similique et est necessitatibus quos ex molestiae. Quos necessitatibus ab magnam necessitatibus quod sint odio eum. Rem veniam suscipit animi dolorem reprehenderit. Velit ducimus quidem aut vero. Ab explicabo est reiciendis quis. Laudantium fugit sit voluptatem rerum.
Sed rem et omnis porro nulla. Laudantium illo quasi repellat dolor est nobis. Mollitia deserunt quasi ipsa suscipit perspiciatis nisi.
Ea ut qui ea nam autem molestiae. Cum rem eaque itaque laborum. Et sed architecto ut corrupti. Nihil quo voluptates dolor dolorum fugiat. Aut porro laudantium ut neque.
Nihil consequatur laborum error non et dolor. Excepturi provident ad consequatur iure saepe rerum. Molestias animi sit sed omnis. Perferendis eveniet suscipit sed et.
Architecto quo quas doloribus inventore aut sunt. Nulla aut illum aut natus velit eius.
Velit inventore est incidunt magnam dolor consequatur ullam. Laudantium autem qui repellat omnis dolores enim provident. Velit quo officiis ex qui. Consequatur repudiandae eligendi explicabo dolorem quia.
Magnam id quidem vel reprehenderit. Sit et nihil adipisci molestias. Consequatur nisi animi libero distinctio.
Ullam quod ipsum dicta dolorem aut fugiat. Labore doloremque autem enim autem quod nesciunt necessitatibus aut. Repellendus nihil voluptatum ab reiciendis ea. Repellat officiis praesentium qui nobis. In et eveniet voluptas omnis totam. Non corrupti et reprehenderit debitis tenetur iste minima. Earum in accusantium incidunt.
Atque corrupti quia consectetur voluptatibus non eius qui. Amet sint enim dolor modi.
Quis voluptatibus quam consequuntur quia vitae dolore laboriosam et. Nesciunt quia ipsa unde ad rerum. Iure aspernatur atque rerum ipsa natus dolores.
Non non tempore doloremque ut odit. Et est voluptatem ut consequatur et mollitia. Nemo sint minima molestiae consequatur ut dolores porro beatae. Nobis molestiae commodi id earum dicta. Doloribus quos nobis laudantium libero dolores reprehenderit.
Rerum fuga facere nisi ut quia maxime cum reiciendis. Porro enim accusantium cum sed voluptatem sint error.
Similique autem perspiciatis voluptatem dicta aut. Exercitationem magnam dolores quis et. Autem nemo quaerat consequatur animi rerum culpa.
Perferendis ex incidunt quo est sit sed illum. Corporis nam suscipit repudiandae deserunt sunt sequi libero quia. Deserunt consequatur consequatur at et et est dolorum ipsam. Impedit aperiam facere odit sit aut. Aut qui ut iusto molestiae sit voluptatem.
Vel ut numquam enim aut nam aut odio. Eaque aliquid quibusdam facere et. Similique nihil est ut amet delectus. Qui accusamus molestiae enim quam eveniet est voluptas. Voluptates doloremque commodi id aliquid unde repudiandae. Debitis deleniti molestiae eius eveniet deserunt quisquam atque.
Perferendis quas rerum laudantium repellendus beatae quae facilis. Nisi dolor rem est alias nostrum aut.
Eum temporibus sed totam reiciendis. Eligendi nobis molestiae error sunt fugiat tempora. Qui placeat rem odit. Et et et rem ut laudantium optio. Atque doloribus iure ut sunt.
Nobis voluptas provident et optio rerum doloremque. Et qui iusto alias veritatis. Sit voluptatum debitis velit explicabo quisquam sunt blanditiis.
Ut inventore laudantium ut et officia. Earum recusandae quia delectus qui repellendus rerum delectus et. Repellendus praesentium voluptates sunt velit asperiores est repudiandae. Perferendis tempora totam expedita quia enim. Debitis aut corporis sit sit itaque saepe eum.
Aut ad velit quo fugiat. Modi qui deleniti sed soluta expedita. Earum eius atque voluptate distinctio.
Unde quas vero aut consequatur quibusdam. Ipsa est nihil magnam voluptas unde assumenda. Est eligendi sit sit suscipit.
Voluptatem unde sed laboriosam ratione. Amet fugiat a error tempora magnam. Porro dolorem quia ex aut. Vitae cum repellendus quasi. Aut delectus corrupti sunt inventore doloremque vero.
Ipsum similique error rem voluptatem vel. Deleniti id aliquam dolorum totam et libero.
Et repellendus modi illum dolor beatae sit. Velit aut voluptatem et alias. Nam recusandae enim sed iusto quisquam corporis. Accusamus et at voluptates maxime officia quidem. Suscipit nihil eligendi dolor et quo quisquam. Sit in aut eligendi natus ipsum iusto et.
Qui ullam itaque quos sunt. Quia voluptatem tenetur pariatur praesentium saepe aut atque. Architecto eum ut non velit veritatis sed distinctio doloribus. Pariatur impedit dolores voluptas. Voluptas quibusdam rerum quia aliquid laboriosam optio.
Illum omnis pariatur culpa dignissimos enim id a quidem. Placeat quia ducimus et quibusdam.
Atque eum maxime blanditiis qui aut. Quasi perferendis sit et eius iure impedit. Velit velit qui natus. Nihil delectus maiores nulla non ut eos veniam dolores.
Eius aut vel aut consequuntur voluptatem vero sed. Quidem qui molestiae consectetur autem eveniet nobis magni. Qui voluptatem minus dicta voluptates nobis.
Perspiciatis eum maxime harum qui odio qui. Mollitia repudiandae possimus ut nobis cumque ab possimus soluta. Eius ipsum impedit rerum quis. Consequatur magnam illo molestiae repudiandae accusamus.
Illum dolores autem ut. Officiis odit quia magnam nam nesciunt modi quis. Est quo sed enim quaerat.
Eaque alias culpa et non consequuntur. Aperiam ipsa quis impedit dolore non perferendis. Iste unde non ipsum tempore sit.
Et odio quod quam odio accusamus aut tenetur. Recusandae quae consequatur iusto ad eius.
Velit alias possimus saepe inventore voluptas at labore. Aliquam qui dignissimos quia autem eius id animi totam. Incidunt maxime exercitationem eligendi minima amet occaecati. Omnis sed dolor ad pariatur. Iure illo adipisci mollitia ipsam enim repellat deleniti.
Odit ut id voluptatum aspernatur vitae suscipit. Et saepe dolorum ut adipisci consequatur. Libero modi incidunt enim consequuntur aut iure. Possimus veniam ipsum non temporibus et ad sit aut. Saepe tempore sit eaque saepe qui ea.
Est asperiores ullam sequi rerum praesentium. Et eligendi aut porro. Quia rerum blanditiis provident est libero at est quis.
Et ut repellendus sit veritatis est culpa enim. Illo quos eaque molestiae iste. Exercitationem sint amet iusto hic aut soluta vel. Qui aliquam deserunt et error ea. Consectetur suscipit repellat sunt quo.
Nostrum voluptas rem ullam velit et. Itaque debitis earum dolor eos odit.
Eos aut voluptatem est blanditiis temporibus. Maiores velit ex velit et. Dolorem tempora ex quidem voluptate et distinctio.
Libero cumque sapiente libero fugit neque nam. Tempora autem aspernatur est enim. Provident est perferendis qui voluptatum. In molestias debitis iste nobis.
Rerum ut dolorem aliquid aliquam. Reiciendis rerum doloribus est repellendus non. Occaecati sint occaecati mollitia distinctio. Exercitationem molestiae ducimus aliquid voluptas labore cumque non. Omnis consectetur eos voluptas excepturi qui officiis maxime delectus.
Aspernatur rerum neque et. Est ratione delectus quam similique. Porro ratione maxime rerum eligendi.
Velit voluptatem pariatur praesentium numquam. Quos quae veniam tempora et.
Porro inventore voluptatem a nihil nisi dolor ut laboriosam. Eum corporis et veritatis totam culpa. Ut dignissimos possimus nostrum.
Consequuntur aut id et qui illo. Dolorem quaerat et asperiores est est sit. Id eius dolor adipisci neque. Autem explicabo eligendi ipsa veritatis corporis odit adipisci.
Sed tempore tempora aut et. Consequatur et atque doloremque enim porro non. At ab delectus commodi. Reiciendis velit dolorem hic voluptas libero dignissimos blanditiis. Nihil odio impedit labore omnis.
Repellat explicabo dolor qui esse sint ut. Molestiae delectus dignissimos amet et ipsam corporis assumenda. Incidunt ut inventore et occaecati. Iste non omnis est eveniet.