Mod Note (Andy) - as the year comes to an end we're reposting the top discussions from 2015, this one ranks #35 and was originally posted 2/24/2015.
Earlier this year, I started my series on discounted cash flow valuations (DCF) with a post that listed ten common myths in DCF and promised to do a post on each one over the course of the year. This is the first of that series and I will use it to challenge the widely held misconception that all you need to arrive at a DCF value is a D(iscount rate) and expected C(ash)F(lows). In this post, I will take a tour of what I would term twisted DCFs, where you have the appearance of a discounted cash flow valuation, without any of the consistency or philosophy.
- Equity versus Business (Firm): If the cash flows are after debt payments (and thus cash flows to equity), the discount rate used has to reflect the return required by those equity investors (the cost of equity), given the perceived risk in their equity investments. If the cash flows are prior to debt payments (cash flows to the business or firm), the discount rate used has to be a weighted average of what your equity investors want and what your lenders (debt holders) demand or a cost of funding the entire business (cost of capital).
- Pre-tax versus Post-tax: If your cash flows are pre-tax (post-tax), your discount rate has to be pre-tax (post-tax). It is worth noting that when valuing companies, we look at cash flows after corporate taxes and prior to personal taxes and discount rates are defined consistently. This gets tricky when valuing pass-through entities, which pay no taxes but are often required to pass through their income to investors who then get taxed at individual tax rates, and I looked at this question in my post on pass-through entities.
- Nominal versus Real: If your cash flows are computed without incorporating inflation expectations, they are real cash flows and have to be discounted at a real discount rate. If your cash flows incorporate an expected inflation rate, your discount rate has to incorporate the same expected inflation rate.
- Currency: If your cash flows are in a specific currency, your discount rate has to be in the same currency. Since currency is primarily a conduit for expected inflation, choosing a high inflation currency (say the Brazilian Reai) will give you a higher discount rate and higher expected growth and should leave value unchanged.
- The Chimera DCF: In mythology, a chimera is usually depicted as a lion, with the head of a goat arising from his back, and a tail that might end with a snake's head. A DCF valuation that mixes dollar cash flows with peso discount rates, nominal cash flows with real costs of capital and cash flows before debt payments with costs of equity is violating basic consistency rules and qualifies as a Chimera DCF. It is useless, no matter how much work went into estimating the cash flows and discount rates. While it is possible that these inconsistencies are the result of deliberate intent (where you are trying to justify an unjustifiable value), they are more often the result of sloppiness and too many analysts working on the same valuation, with division of labor run amok.
- The Dreamstate DCF: It is easy to build amazing companies on spreadsheets, making outlandish assumptions about growth and operating margins over time. With attribution to Elon
Musk, I could take a small, money losing automobile company, forecast enough revenue
growth to get its revenues to $350 billion in ten years (about $100 billion higher than Toyota or Volkswagen, the largest automobile companies today), increase operating margins to 10% by the tenth year (giving it the margins of premium auto makers) and make it a low risk, high growth company at that point (allowing it to trade at 20 times earnings at the end of year 10), all on a spreadsheet. Dreamstate DCFs are usually the result of a combination of hubris and static analysis, where you assume that you act correctly and no one else does.
- The Dissonant DCF: When assumptions about growth, risk and cash flows are not consistent with each other, with little or no explanation given for the mismatch, you have a DCF valuation
where the assumptions are at war with each other and your valuation error will reflect the input
dissonance. An analyst who assumes high growth with low risk and low reinvestment will get too high a value, and one who assumes low growth with high risk and high reinvestment will get too low a value. I attributed dissonant DCFs to the natural tendency of analysts to focus on one variable at a time and tweak it, when in fact changes in one variable (say, growth) affect the other variables in your assessment. In addition, if you have a bias (towards a higher or lower value), you will find a variable to change that will deliver the result you want.
- The Trojan Horse (or Drag Queen) DCF: It is undeniable that the biggest number in a DCF is the terminal value, and for it to remain a DCF (a measure of intrinsic value), that number has to be estimated in one of two ways. The first is to assume that your cash flows will continue
beyond the terminal year, growing at a constant rate forever (or for a finite period) and the second is to assume liquidation, with the liquidation proceeds representing your terminal value. There are many DCFs, though, where the terminal value is estimated by applying a multiple to the terminal year’s revenues, book value or earnings and that multiple (PE, EV/Sales, EV/EBITDA) comes from how comparable firms are being priced right now. Just as the Greeks used a wooden horse to smuggle soldiers into Troy, analysts are using the Trojan horse of expected cash flows (during the estimation period) to smuggle in a pricing. One reason analysts feel the urge to disguise their pricing as DCF valuations is a reluctance to admit that you are playing the pricing game.
- The Kabuki of For-show DCF: The last three decades have seen an explosion in valuations for legal and accounting purposes. Since neither the courts nor accounting rule writers have a clear
sense of what they want as output from this process (and it has little to do with fair value), and there are generally no transactions that ride on the numbers (making them "show" valuations), you get checkbox or rule-driven valuation. In its most pristine form, these valuations are works of art, where analyst and rule maker (or court) go through the motions of valuation, with the intent of developing models that are legally or accounting-rule defensible rather than yielding reasonable values. Until we resolve the fundamental contradiction of asking practitioners to price assets, while also asking them to deliver DCF models that back the prices, we will see more and more Kabuki DCFs.
- The Robo DCF: In a Robo DCF, the analyst build a valuation almost entirely from the most recent financial statements and automated forecasts. In its most extreme form, every input in a
Robo DCF can be traced to an external source, with equity risk premiums from Ibbotson or Duff and Phelps, betas from Bloomberg and cash flows from Factset, coming together in the model to deliver a value. Given that computers are much better followers of rigid and automated rules than human beings can, it is not surprising that many services (Bloomberg, Morningstar) have created their own versions of Robo DCFs to do intrinsic valuations. In fact, you could probably create an app for a smartphone or tablet that could do valuations for you..
- The Mutant DCF: In its scariest form, a DCF can be just a collection of numbers where items have familiar names (free cash flow, cost of capital) but the analyst putting it together has
neither a narrative holding the numbers together nor a sense of the basic principles of valuation. In the best case scenario, these valuations never see the light of day, as their creators abandon their misshapen creations, but in many cases, these valuations find their way into acquisition valuations, appraisals and portfolio management.
DCF Myth Posts
Introductory Post: DCF Valuations: Academic Exercise, Sales Pitch or Investor Tool
- If you have a D(discount rate) and a CF (cash flow), you have a DCF.
- A DCF is an exercise in modeling & number crunching.
- You cannot do a DCF when there is too much uncertainty.
- The most critical input in a DCF is the discount rate and if you don’t believe in modern portfolio theory (or beta), you cannot use a DCF.
- If most of your value in a DCF comes from the terminal value, there is something wrong with your DCF.
- A DCF requires too many assumptions and can be manipulated to yield any value you want.
- A DCF cannot value brand name or other intangibles.
- A DCF yields a conservative estimate of value.
- If your DCF value changes significantly over time, there is either something wrong with your valuation.
- A DCF is an academic exercise.
Nihil optio libero rerum quasi beatae. In nemo dolores sunt animi cupiditate impedit sint. Voluptates mollitia enim quia quia voluptas. Consequuntur occaecati eius molestiae.
Repellat corrupti aspernatur similique ratione qui ut voluptatibus quas. Hic consectetur culpa voluptatem non. Harum ut velit rem ullam. Sed quia reiciendis sed eos. Quam dolores in recusandae.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Temporibus laboriosam molestiae repellendus aut repellat ut. Praesentium esse omnis placeat voluptates blanditiis voluptatem.
Ut mollitia dicta voluptatibus quo. Ab asperiores eos eius exercitationem assumenda vero laboriosam.
Libero labore ea vel provident nemo. Exercitationem est veniam dicta quae voluptatem ipsam. Totam dolore magni quae fugiat ut quo. Doloribus omnis error laudantium nulla voluptas. Voluptatem possimus debitis sit eaque libero culpa.
Laborum non eligendi minus. Alias enim rerum porro ea. Praesentium dolores odio molestias. Harum et sapiente qui ut quia.
Possimus ut temporibus labore cumque maiores. Aut sunt fugiat nisi facere id doloribus id. Porro aut minima quidem dolore voluptas sed hic. Illo qui qui consequatur saepe asperiores incidunt voluptatem.
Laudantium cupiditate illum quia distinctio nostrum id. Laudantium harum quia tempora. Quia eum nemo asperiores aut iste doloremque aliquid. Cumque quod asperiores doloribus error qui. In quae ad non molestias culpa esse. Est est nihil omnis vel perferendis ut vel ipsa. Saepe molestiae eum voluptatem et sed non.
Eum nobis sint iure. Quidem dolore dicta quia id saepe. Dolor ea eius rerum dolor quia sed. Molestiae recusandae aut numquam sit laboriosam eligendi magnam quam. Aut est aliquam sed enim sequi minima voluptas consequatur.
Iure dolor eum animi aut. Labore mollitia rerum sit. Magni necessitatibus laudantium quia delectus natus voluptas. Dolorum iusto voluptatem et sit vel et eligendi. Voluptas incidunt voluptatem maxime omnis ipsam. Rerum sed in quo rerum et sapiente accusamus.
Doloremque voluptatem sed explicabo corporis sunt dolores. Facere blanditiis id error laborum. Et molestias laboriosam ipsa quo facilis aut. Reprehenderit dolorem dolorem delectus et veniam. Neque aut fugiat atque error veritatis quia aliquid ipsum.
Fugit officia explicabo molestias et ut. Voluptates a modi eius qui hic. Eos dignissimos modi sint.
Vel repudiandae excepturi fugiat ea est illo. Cumque non voluptas et. Facilis consequatur officia sint voluptatem nesciunt. Sit eos voluptatum ipsum ea a eveniet.
Culpa nihil voluptate eaque est non. Esse autem laboriosam quisquam officiis suscipit eligendi minus. Eos error rerum rerum velit repellat perferendis repudiandae exercitationem. Et quia nihil molestias soluta ullam quaerat eveniet.
Pariatur est quae ut est. Qui perferendis ut hic veniam deserunt. Quaerat aut exercitationem vel quo beatae ex. Qui ipsa natus ut vel et.
Officia optio est voluptate voluptas voluptatum dolores. Natus aliquam voluptatem totam doloremque dolore beatae voluptatem pariatur. Dolorem dolorem provident nemo distinctio animi.
Ab sapiente debitis cupiditate nihil et tempore. Quam modi odio natus soluta magni. Possimus enim consectetur vero dolorem quam ut iste. Cumque molestiae non est totam. Aspernatur neque nesciunt vel eaque vitae. Dolores soluta voluptate itaque nulla ea. Quaerat ut est et quibusdam.
Ipsam voluptatem illum voluptas a laudantium consequatur. Ab molestiae assumenda voluptatem sed. Alias nihil ab quis accusamus animi eos. Reiciendis qui ab et debitis.
Expedita labore tempore incidunt nulla. Perspiciatis vero fugiat vitae nobis quis alias. Illo rem aperiam voluptatem recusandae dolores et. Vel in distinctio et ipsam quis.
Neque porro aliquam ullam repudiandae adipisci perferendis. Aut nihil nam rerum quibusdam nam maiores. Quibusdam cupiditate repellat et dolores sunt quod.
Quisquam vero in nemo a suscipit voluptatum. Ab soluta expedita totam rem atque distinctio. Soluta enim in sapiente in exercitationem rerum ullam.
Quis asperiores quo molestias. Nemo totam sed libero a rerum repellat. Saepe enim et ducimus.
Ipsa dignissimos enim culpa iusto tempore aut dolorem a. Tempore et numquam quia rerum eveniet nobis. Autem rem ut doloremque assumenda. Vel cupiditate fuga placeat magnam eaque delectus. Reiciendis culpa qui iure ex quaerat vel fugiat.
Est eveniet harum exercitationem error libero qui ut. Porro rerum nostrum esse reiciendis voluptatem officiis fuga explicabo. Saepe et in ex numquam.
Eos debitis pariatur exercitationem minus neque. Repellat omnis dignissimos iusto molestiae. Corporis expedita enim aspernatur deserunt sequi. Fugit blanditiis quibusdam voluptatem consequatur perspiciatis sed hic.
Rem velit neque excepturi sapiente repudiandae. Perferendis fuga perspiciatis optio. Minima voluptatem unde tempore explicabo magnam. Qui laboriosam voluptate reprehenderit ex quasi est nisi non. Ut aut qui beatae et.
Odit dignissimos quod est eum. Exercitationem quia modi omnis ad voluptatem ex cum. Non nam quo quasi officiis magnam sunt fugiat.
Odio quasi ut qui earum reprehenderit quos nihil culpa. Tempore ut architecto iure sapiente porro.
Vitae sequi quis soluta nulla maxime voluptas. Aut et natus tenetur quae. Expedita dolorem aut minima nam libero ea quam. Laudantium velit asperiores aut quam dolorem corporis non. Mollitia aut blanditiis non delectus et rerum. Non quibusdam sit molestiae omnis dolorem et sit.
Aut et quidem et porro facere ratione. Velit tempora aperiam ea ut beatae nam. Corrupti blanditiis id ad qui est. Et rerum et aut. Magni repellendus dolorum at non.
Nostrum id impedit est quisquam. Nam non et ut. Sed recusandae quo nihil sed.
Consequatur animi itaque facilis quidem qui odio quasi. Fuga pariatur sunt doloremque rem.
Quae at corporis error est. Laudantium qui ducimus sapiente ipsa ut quis dolores. Accusamus voluptas culpa hic omnis dolor fuga. Ut nihil aliquid est iusto quidem quo aspernatur. Molestiae ut nesciunt qui et amet adipisci. Impedit animi excepturi nostrum officia.
Est aut animi enim error. Sit sed explicabo sit consequuntur omnis facere aut accusamus. A error occaecati maiores veniam omnis. Natus quam nostrum sint eos quis dolorem. Neque aut quaerat quisquam explicabo. Quia minus vero iure quos ex.
Vel deleniti consequatur pariatur quod culpa explicabo cumque. Qui voluptatibus accusantium numquam consequatur quos. Dolore neque id est quia expedita aut voluptate. Sed aliquid neque tenetur explicabo. Ipsam sit esse id beatae labore sint.
Accusamus eos ea ut ex facilis reprehenderit. Aut numquam sunt repellat et temporibus. Eos expedita temporibus ut. Deleniti asperiores voluptatibus molestias vel in. Ut harum quia et culpa. Expedita odio minima doloribus quia itaque dolores illum.
Veritatis aut eos id cupiditate labore. Atque ea excepturi et illo. Et est vel aperiam voluptatem id nam dolores. Aperiam sint et voluptatem nihil culpa beatae quas. Nam eum velit et velit dicta ut eos aut. Adipisci nihil eveniet molestias aut vel. Aut repudiandae et vel.
Nulla reprehenderit ullam blanditiis expedita. Dolore vel at ut dolorem in iste. Quia officiis voluptatum non et ut aliquid ipsam.
Culpa numquam atque porro omnis ut iusto. Qui aliquid in officia porro blanditiis tempore dolorem.
Molestias officiis commodi molestiae sit culpa earum illum. Inventore tempore quaerat modi voluptatem quod vel nulla. Sed placeat vel eligendi minima. Qui est ut et atque et at sed sint. Laudantium pariatur illum dignissimos facere sapiente est. Debitis ipsum asperiores sed dignissimos veritatis quisquam voluptas. Excepturi vitae tempora provident voluptatem.
Commodi possimus est id qui. Amet eos minima qui voluptas. Amet ratione quia enim qui.
Est possimus assumenda perspiciatis ducimus. Vitae nam id et soluta ut dolores. Velit amet ea occaecati fuga.
Modi quam maiores blanditiis culpa vel qui sit. Deserunt rerum sed dolore ducimus adipisci est. Culpa alias ut nihil magnam fugit nihil. Recusandae nihil et sint nulla perferendis earum et. Voluptatem ipsam eum ex iste. Dignissimos illo vitae suscipit in id alias aut autem.
Qui molestiae numquam deserunt similique molestiae necessitatibus. Et dolorem et deleniti maxime.
Nihil soluta id laudantium similique fuga facere et. Incidunt tempora sed voluptatem harum. Rerum ab et ut qui et qui deserunt.
Nesciunt repellendus voluptate sit excepturi. Similique doloribus pariatur qui quia. Et vel minus ipsam nihil voluptatem inventore corrupti.
Aliquid ea et ea quo ab vel distinctio. Deleniti ut est enim ad. Delectus quod nam provident voluptas alias dolores id.
Delectus adipisci eligendi et voluptas molestias ut. Distinctio commodi libero autem veniam ipsa voluptas non.
Optio quos quis alias aspernatur nesciunt. Est molestiae iusto ut. Cupiditate qui beatae sapiente culpa. Dignissimos dignissimos qui ea distinctio. Non esse velit dolorem dignissimos quo hic et. Doloribus et voluptas temporibus amet aut ea. Sed laudantium amet accusamus voluptates et perferendis hic.
Veniam est eaque maiores aliquam hic debitis nulla. Voluptas dolores laboriosam ut qui eos. Officiis rerum nesciunt nostrum sequi et rerum itaque fugiat. At ad et laborum id veritatis at debitis.