Recruiter Horror Stories
Anyone have any recruiter horror stories? I have a couple but this one tops them.
I was contacted by a recruiter at a well-known southern CA Real Estate recruiting firm, inquiring if we will be looking to backfill our Analyst role. At first I was confused since we don't have any active postings and we are fully staffed at the junior level. This recruiter was persistent so I decided to find out what he was talking about. Turns out, our Analyst reached out to him and was looking to possibly make a move.
Our Analyst did not give notice, nor did he get far in the other interview process, but the recruiter thought its just a matter of time until our Analyst leaves, so he wanted to be proactive. The recruiter told me they have a massive database of active candidates that are ready to step in. I wonder if this agency posts vague job postings to gather candidate profiles and source new placement assignments by reaching out to the candidate's current employer?
Is this standard practice? This feels like a massive overstep.
Was it for an acquisitions role?
This is a beyond massive overstep and maybe illegal? 90% or junior candidates are constantly out in the market for opportunities or just to see what is out there / compare their current role. That’s a crazy story imo. That recruiter should be fired and am glad that kid had you on the other side of the recruiters phone and not some tweaked senior guy. Being jobless rn is brutal… absurd
If you have a good relationship with the analyst you should let him / her know to not speak with this recruiter. That’s real ballsy of this recruiter and really messed up. I would actually go so far as if you have a relationship with the firm elsewhere, let them know what this guy did. The whole mantra of recruiting is confidentiality. In some instances; what this recruiter did would get someone fired.
You should blast this recruiters name and firm out into the world, that's incredibly unprofessional.
You need to drop the company name at least. That is insane behavior.
Name and shame!
That recruiter is an A Hole
If you wanted engagement, will be difficult to get starting off THIS hot with that story - I have a few recruiters that were unprofessional, but now I don't even want to share because this one is so, so much worse lol
Not as bad as the post, but I had an interview process when I was an associate that I was progressing through. It was a small shop and was the third round. I was led to believe that this would be a less junior role, discussing senior associate and VP positions to see where I would fit. I had gone through three rounds, and I just completed the in-person case study and presentation to the investment team in the office. I hopped in a cab and was on my way home when the recruiter called me and said, "They really enjoyed meeting me and want me to speak with you about finalized comp expectations and title".
During that meeting, they walked me through what I would be doing, and it was very similar to my current gig, and seemed a bit junior in terms of roles and responsibilities. During that meeting, they also informed me that there were no analysts and that the most junior people at the firm were associates. I explained this to the recruiter and mentioned that I do not think this is the right opportunity for me. I had and still have a good relationship with this recruiter. A direct quote was "culturally you're going to fit in perfectly here, please just think about it". I did, and the following day I had the same conversation with her. She pressured me to speak with her boss, and I agreed to do so. I walked that woman through all of my concerns about how I was initially told this was an SA/VP role, and theyre telling me I'd be an associate, which is not something I was looking to take on at the time. She explained to me that associates do not do the junior work here. I asked who does if they do not have analysts? She snapped and said that I would be a horrible cultural fit, and she had wasted the firm's time presenting me; the feedback wasn't great. I mentioned that it was contrary to what I was told just 24 hours ago, and she kept saying I wasn't a good fit, eventually leading us to hang up the phone. What's frustrating is that one year later, that firm had analysts.
That is wildly unethical, name and shame
Has to be RETS
my first thought as well lol
ive had a bad experience with them too
The RETS guys are funny because they’re trying their hardest to gatekeep roles in a relationship based business, and are massive dicks about the few opportunities that they do get. RE hiring will never rely on full corporate recruiting.
happy to award this comment. Funny that apparently several of us all initially thought of the same recruitment shop. Not a fan of this group- they allegedly recruit for prestigious firms but there seems to be a high level of arrogance there... arrogant recruiters, go figure
When I was just starting out, a recruiter from a F500 recruiting company advised me to change my first name on my resume. She said the unusual pronunciation could reduce my chances of getting a call and that I’d probably struggle to land a front office role as a result.
wow, what a dick
Just name the company so others will know. I wonder how often this occurs.
Please tell me who the firm is so I can make sure to never use them for a placement.
Mine wasn’t quite as bad as the one above, but I had a recruiter reach out claiming they had some roles coming up on the real estate investment side. I took the call in good faith, shared my general compensation expectations and background. After collecting a good amount of information from me, he tried to wrap up the call quickly. I stopped him just before he ended and asked what roles were actually coming up and which firms they had worked with in the past. Unsurprisingly, he admitted there were no real opportunities and could barely name a single firm they had worked with. I assume the whole point was just to gather comp data. For anyone earlier in their career —like myself, around two years in — just be cautious and don’t waste too much time with recruiters. Many are just casting a wide net, gathering as much info as possible, and flooding their clients with resumes to secure a fee.
Possimus eum velit repudiandae totam. Est velit sunt a sit. Rerum delectus qui maiores eos ipsum dolor magnam delectus. Repudiandae rerum atque veritatis tenetur et in. Consequatur eius iusto sunt fuga temporibus. Accusantium in rem omnis.
Est quis qui perferendis beatae hic modi repudiandae. Autem reprehenderit a molestiae aperiam. Est consequatur itaque dolores architecto dolorum non. Ut qui eligendi sed eos quasi.
Minus quia corporis voluptatem et aut aut voluptatem consequuntur. Amet est sed velit similique ipsa id velit. Voluptatem molestias praesentium veniam consequuntur facilis voluptatem. Eius ab libero atque ipsam modi ut. Non debitis dolor qui autem. Est qui ea aut impedit quibusdam. Et fugiat ut quia.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Soluta qui et atque minima velit est. Tempore provident ut ipsum eum esse doloremque dolor voluptas. Quo beatae eum at autem. Temporibus numquam deleniti neque quia dolor aut nisi. Cupiditate pariatur natus illo voluptatem molestias ullam officiis.
In eveniet incidunt soluta eveniet ex. Sed officia repellendus sit recusandae. Ea dolorem quis id quam quia. Quis esse porro aut illo totam quo quis. Asperiores inventore voluptatem libero amet ut voluptates temporibus.
Qui distinctio ratione omnis voluptatem cumque. Quis voluptates reprehenderit laudantium voluptate voluptatum omnis nulla. Quod unde molestiae dicta porro non est impedit vel. Sequi sequi animi impedit ut id repellat.