MS. Finance VS MBA (No Industry Experience)
I’m currently a rising sophomore at a semi-target university (think Rice/Vanderbilt) where I am also a student-athlete. This summer, I was fortunate to secure an internship in commercial real estate asset management and brokerage, which was a significant opportunity, especially during my freshman summer.
My academic advisor has suggested that I take 15 course hours next summer to accelerate my graduation (this would allow me to graduate a year early), allowing me to pursue a graduate degree at another institution through a grad transfer, leveraging my remaining athletic eligibility. While graduating early is certainly appealing, this plan would prevent me from pursuing an internship next summer, as my schedule would be fully occupied with coursework.
Given these considerations:
Would graduating early and obtaining an MBA or MS in Finance provide more long-term value than the experience and networking opportunities from a sophomore summer internship?
Additionally, I’m curious whether an MS in Finance or an MBA would be the better path for breaking into investment banking.
Any insights or advice would be greatly appreciated!
Based on the most helpful WSO content, here are some insights and advice regarding your situation:
Graduating Early vs. Internship Experience
MS in Finance vs. MBA for Investment Banking
MS in Finance:
MBA:
Recommendations
Additional Considerations
In summary, while both paths have their merits, the experience and networking opportunities from internships are crucial, and an MBA might offer more long-term value and a broader network compared to an MS in Finance.
Sources: Graduating early - worth it or not?, Am I Thinking About an MBA Wrong?, Current Value of MBA for Highly Successful Young Professionals, Turning down HBS/GSB/Wharton for the Promote-Through, Q&A: From Sellside Research to Strategy & Finance at Rapid Growth Start-up
First, wouldn’t do an MBA now, generally considered something to do after a few years work experience. Mfin is the one to do post grad.
Tbh (I’m guessing you’re at vandy since rice doesn’t have a mfin program) if I were you I’d do the classes and get the mfin. Great recruiting out of that program, provides optionality between fields and is well respected.
It’s a little different if you seriously envision yourself going into RE, but at this age it may not be wise to bank on the fact that what you want now is what you’ll want at graduation.
Tbh while it’s harder to get that junior year internship without you should be able to get a decent look with your background and story regardless.
If you have a vandy undergrad/mfin, student athlete and a couple good gigs out of school, you’re looking at a T-10 MBA as well.
Thanks for the reply!
I'm currently an undergraduate student at Rice in their Business Finance program (sorry, I should've clarified that in the op). I'm not particularly interested in RE, it was just the internship experience I was able to get my hands on my freshman year summer. Ultimately I would like to work in either IB or S&T, but I'm fairly open to most finance roles. Do you think pursuing an MFin would make getting an MBA worthwhile later on? Is it unrealistic to consider that while an MFin might not directly lead to recruiting for associate roles immediately after graduation, starting as an analyst and advancing through the ranks would provide more value than pursuing an MBA? Would staying in the industry be a more beneficial path than returning to school?
To be honest, I think you could break in without an MBA (like what... 3-4 years post undergrad + 2 year MBA = 28 in IB). If you're at Rice, you already have a great chance of breaking in. I say go all in on a good sophomore summer internship, recruiting prep, networking, and you'll make it to a good bank.
If you end up somewhere that's not EXACTLY what you want (let's say MM in NYC or maybe BB in a tier 2 or 3 city), you can always work there (there is good pay still) and then MBA at T-7 school, followed by basically whatever bank you want. I think that you should use what you have right now to your advantage. You're fortunate enough to be in a good spot, plus student-athletes seem to have better looks from banks sometimes.
I say go all in. Go get a sophomore internship and recruit for junior year. If it doesn't go well, then take classes next summer, graduate early, pursue whatever MFin program. You can always not do the sophomore summer internship as well. They will be upset if you go back on your offer, but it probably won't be at a huge firm so they won't care too much (hopefully). Maybe recommend someone else to the job so they're not left empty handed. Something along those lines.
Thanks for the reply!
While I can definitely break in without needing to get a masters degree, I'm trying to take advantage of my remaining athletic eligibility post- undergrad graduation. Upon my graduation (if I graduate early) I will have two years of athletic eligibility remaining, which would allow me to enroll in a MSF or MBA program for free (will be on athletic scholarship). I was more so curious as to which masters program would be more beneficial in my case, as I know it is usually best to delay receiving an MBA later into your career.
You're right, I didn't consider that. Then my advice is to go for the Masters in Finance. I don't think the MBA at a T-7 school is possible in this situation, or very very unlikely at least. The MSF will be good for recruiting and you may not need an MBA ever at that point.
You generally can't get an MBA without experience.
Student athletes who decide to grad-transfer from their undergraduate institution with a competitive gpa (3.5>) are able to receive admission into MBA and other graduate programs regardless of industry experience.
Unde error omnis maiores et nesciunt. Inventore sunt sit sit laboriosam.
Voluptatem aperiam omnis qui deserunt veritatis doloribus. Atque culpa deserunt temporibus sunt enim quia.
Ut sunt provident quaerat expedita ducimus ut excepturi. Veritatis id et quia.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...