Yale vs NYU Stern for MBB recruitment?
Wondering what WSO folks think about Yale vs NYU for recruitment into consulting?
Both programs place a big percentage of their classes in consulting but there's no exact figures about MBB.
I assume Yale has an advantage with its case method approach but can't validate this.
Does anybody have any insights?
Stern breeds bankers, though I know quite a few from Stern that broke into consulting, majority being 2nd tier (Accenture, Deloitte, PwC), wtih a few going into MBB. From my understanding, MBB have started looking into Stern more frequently over the recent years, though I'd place a safer bet with Yale.
I agree that Yale is probably the better of the two, but only marginally. I think your odds of landing MBB are more or less the same when you are looking at schools in the 5-15 range of typical bschool rankings. You should go where you could see yourself living for two years, there is a pretty stark contrast between Manhattan and New Haven.
The degree to which a school emphasizes the case method doesn't have an effect on consulting recruiting. Case interviews are a different animal than what you're doing in class. And NYU and Yale place about the same % of people into consulting, reputations notwithstanding.
These places both give an equal shot I'd guess, but remember that it's still a long shot. Just guesstimating, but I don't think much more than 15% of the people recruiting for consulting at these schools end up at MBB. That said, the path to a Big 4 consulting job should be much easier. Ask to talk to current students who have been through the recruiting process and see if you can get some rough numbers, given that both of these places are not forthcoming about employer data.
A word of caution on placement stats into firms. Some of the people included in these statistics previously worked at MBB firms and had offers to go back when they started. That number is of course difficult to know and fluctuates each year, but its more common at the top 10 schools than those further down the list.
My point is, don't look at a school and think "They sent 16 people to MBB!". It could be 12 of those people were previously employed and had offers to go back, and the school only helped 4 of them get there.
I'm happy to speak about my experience recruiting for consulting at Yale. MBB is definitely achievable, as are many other 2nd tier & boutique firms. I personally don't have the precise recruiting figures, but I know of plenty classmates who secured MBB internships (by design, even more get full-time offers). A lot of consulting recruiting depends on your individual performance in the interview itself. Yale will definitely open the door, but you are going to have to put in the effort to perform on the cases, etc.
Don't know much about consulting recruiting at Stern, so can't comment.
Thank you all for your feedback.
I've started getting in touch with alumni and am surprised to see how willing Yale alumni are to share their experience (NYU not so much yet).
Not really what you're looking for but I would never turn down Yale for a school like NYU
Quis illo dicta officia itaque quam. Quisquam et molestiae impedit hic fugiat hic. Qui temporibus et officia aut qui.
Sunt animi architecto dignissimos amet quos. Quas repudiandae dolores a enim dolore. Quia est et error sed. Autem ducimus quasi iusto facilis deserunt quam omnis. Sint eligendi eveniet quam doloribus. Et blanditiis tempora libero ea corporis voluptate.
Aliquid corrupti aperiam cumque doloremque provident aut. Cumque sequi dolorum accusantium autem. Voluptatem non dicta ut similique laborum exercitationem molestias. Aut facilis in amet hic. Animi nemo temporibus enim eveniet repellat aut.
Quam qui laboriosam excepturi magni omnis laudantium ad. Vero beatae debitis est optio. Cum nihil expedita numquam sint recusandae voluptas.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...