Fresh CS Ph.D. Offers: BB S&T vs. Prop vs. Silicon Valley
I'm a fresh CS Ph.D. from a top 5. I have three offers:
1) BB S&T quant. Not as a desk strategist, but on a longer-term modeling group that supports traders and desk strats. Offer is $105 base + $45 sign-on + variable annual bonus (no guaranteed minimum). 2) Stat arb at a top-10 prop shop. On a small team of a couple Ph.D.s and a manager. Offer is $80 + variable annual bonus (guaranteed minimum $40). 3) Modeling at a large Silicon Valley tech firm. Best offer is $190 annual + $50 sign-on. The $190 is $140 base + RSU package worth $50 annually at current valuations.
Any obvious conclusions? Things that matter most to me:
1) Total comp over short, medium and long haul. 2) Work hours.
Any thoughts on how the three options stack up along these dimensions? The BB and prop higher-ups are tight-lipped on bonus expectations. I've seen plenty of numbers on WSO, but none specifically for quants, and I'm guessing they're lower. I tried asking about bonuses on the popular quant forums online but got voted off the island quickly.
not another quant guy......
shrugs
whatever
The world will learn
Obviously each offer is getting you paid so just do the one you want to do the most.
LOL -- guess I haven't learned! I'm aware WSO isn't for quants. I tried this on a popular Internet forum geared towards quants, but they downvoted me quickly and eventually deleted my post. I see a lot more hard numbers on WSO, so I thought I'd give it a go here.
^lmao
congrats on the offers.
Have a friend in BB quant and a friend in a prop shop...
BB S&T expect 55-70 hour weeks maybe more/less with weekends...
My buddy is a 2nd year at a well known prop shop, works 9am-4pm M-F no weekends does something like 95K base with 100%-200% bonus
just my $0.02
Go to Silicon Valley. I don't need any more competition.
oh yeah I was just curious...can you elaborate on the position at Silicon Valley...modeling at large tech firm? sounds more interesting and less risky than the first 2
Thanks oldmansacks! The tech company is a large Internet site and the work involves algorithms for ranking search results, targeting ads, revenue-optimizing various parameters of the site, etc.. This was my best of three SV offers -- the two I turned down were $190 total without a sign-on, and $170 total + $10 sign-on.
You gave me a good idea of BB hours -- those are certainly more than tech. Any idea on whether the bonuses would make it worth it? What's a reasonable expectation as a % of base? Remember: non-desk quant, S&T, BB, doing models to support the desk strats and traders. They're not divulging any historicals or averages, but claim that over the long haul I'll make more there than in tech. Still, the immediate gap makes me wonder if the break-even isn't 5 or 10 years out.
Dude, take number 3. Tech work is so much more interesting than the crap you would be doing in S&T.
Have you checked out quantnet.com? Andy Nguyen gives good advice. Best not to discuss comp directly,
Statistical arbitrage at a prop shop is probably going to give you the opportunity to add more insight to trade decisions. It's also going to offer less job stability. All depends on what you are looking for.
Dude, have you worked in S&T before? With your education, the work may not be that interesting. I know a guy who uses his Ph. D. in computational biology to fill in excel sheets at DE Shaw. I know another who does fairly simple database management stuff at a BB.
I would go with offer number 3.
i vote for #3 hands down.
Absolutely depends on what he wants to do. Lots of tech work is incredibly boring as well.
Grass isn't always greener like some people make it seem. The decision is simple: 10 years out where do you see yourself?
I am utterly not qualified to give you advice, but cmon man, you don't want to become a fucking finance jockey. Take that gig out West. Make money and enjoy life.
240k all in starting in California? Take it, that's more than enough to live very well.
i'm someone who has no interest in tech or startups, but even for me, #3 seems like the obvious choice. Great pay, interesting work, and you get to live in california. Stat arb at a prop shop is incredibly boring, same with BB S&T quant where you're just supporting traders and strategists rather than trading yourself. Now, if the offer was say from a quant hedge fund like citadel or AQR, then it would be a tougher call.
(1) This offer doesn't sound too great/interesting. (2) Highest long-term comp potential (by far) and longest work hours, but can be incredibly interesting for the right role (research/trading). Although not one of your criteria, this is also the best pedigree choice for your career. (3) Reasonable but long-term comp here is limited. You'll have little to no influence on the performance of the firm (and your RSUs), and you won't be making much more money five years down the line. California ain't cheap btw.
IMO the choice is between 2 and 3. Unless you have obligations (family, etc.), I'd try out #2.
I think if you go with 1/2, you'll probably have the option to go to 3 if you don't like your choice. I don't think the converse is true.
Quod consequatur sit nostrum iusto consequuntur laboriosam occaecati asperiores. Voluptas dolorem dolorem rerum voluptatem assumenda. Autem tempora ducimus enim veritatis alias provident neque. Voluptatem quia repellat nulla quibusdam occaecati.
Vero molestias dolores fugit. Quae voluptas amet iusto laboriosam modi. Cum autem eos voluptatem odit voluptate. Ipsam cupiditate consequatur voluptatem commodi perferendis repudiandae ut. Ducimus rerum laboriosam et perferendis est iusto accusantium nisi.
Est ut quia quis. Veritatis aliquid quam dolorem atque. Aliquid quisquam eos aliquam quam excepturi.
Hic sit non incidunt alias cum. Accusamus omnis asperiores voluptatum quisquam. Qui molestias sed dolore ipsa tempora est consequatur.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...