GMAT arms race: stats from top schools

Looked through top mba class profiles and it looks like a lot of averages for class 2019 went up again substantially:

Stanford 737
HBS 730
Kellogg 732
Columbia 724
Booth 730
Yale 730
Wharton 730
Sloan 722
Tuck 722
Haas 725
UCLA 716
Stern 714
Ross 716
Darden 713

Stanford GMAT throughout time:
Stanford

Importance of GMAT (no idea how old this is): Importance

 

I worked at a f500 company in FP&A/Corp Dev (doing yearly budgeting at individual salary level) non-coastal location. Most topped out at 170 with 15% bonus for AVP, VP, Director, SVP. Division heads would hit the $220-$300 range though (like 45-55 year old with 20 years industry experience).

 
Best Response

It's a joke anyways. A complete scam. They let you take the test as many times as you like and the schools only consider the top scores. You get people who take the test 10x until they get a favorable result. The rankings only care about the posted number. The average scores continue to rise, GMAC makes more and more money, but the value of the signal (high score) only declines.

“Elections are a futures market for stolen property”
 

Still, you are on point. Because somebody may take the test 5 times and scores above 700's, and somebody else with only one try at 650 will be overlooked! That does not make any sense!

 

This upwards trend has been going on for a long time. Nothing new.

Granted, it'll be truly ridiculous when the average score across the top 10 is 760.

US News could end this nonsense overnight by reducing the weight given to GMAT and GPA in its ranking process.

The truth is you're the weak. And I'm the tyranny of evil men. But I'm tryin', Ringo. I'm tryin' real hard to be the shepherd.
 

If I took the GRE and scored well (334; 170/170 quant, 97th percentile, 164/170 verbal, 94th percentile), would it be worth taking the GMAT if I want to go to b-school and think I can score equivalently well (~750-770ish)? It would take some preparation but I'm confident I could score highly, but I'm not sure how much using the GMAT vs. the GRE will improve my application.

Thanks a lot! Any advice is much appreciated.

 
BreakingOutOfPWM:
If you can score a 770+ on the GMAT, it provides a boost in recruiting through OCR, especially for IB/Consulting. GRE doesn't provide the same benefit, but it won't handicap you. That being said, it's definitely diminishing returns at this point.

So you're required to list GMAT for consulting and IB recruiting?

 
LifeInTheMM:
As a graduate of a top-25 part-time MBA program, I think they will only continue to grow in popularity. Not only did I not have to dedicate 1.5 years of my life to the GMAT to get a 750, but the total expenses were 1/3rd of the full-time program.

I think 1-year MBAs, part-time MBAs, and specialized masters programs such as CS, finance, machine learning, etc., will be on the rise. The full-time 2-year MBA program is fine if you want to do consulting, banking, F500, but if you're looking for something outside the traditional OCR path, not sure how much value it really adds.

 
Rufus1234:
LifeInTheMM:
As a graduate of a top-25 part-time MBA program, I think they will only continue to grow in popularity. Not only did I not have to dedicate 1.5 years of my life to the GMAT to get a 750, but the total expenses were 1/3rd of the full-time program.

I think 1-year MBAs, part-time MBAs, and specialized masters programs such as CS, finance, machine learning, etc., will be on the rise. The full-time 2-year MBA program is fine if you want to do consulting, banking, F500, but if you're looking for something outside the traditional OCR path, not sure how much value it really adds.

Two year full time MBAs make a lot of sense if you’re making a big career shift or you really want IB/tech/MBB. Otherwise I agree, a 1 year MBA or part time degree makes much more sense.

 

Current CBS student here.. the GMAT arms race is getting a bit ridiculous. My classmates know who the bright/successful students are, and I don't think knowledge of their GMAT score would change how anyone is viewed. That being said, it's hard for me to assess how important it is in admissions. My employment/undergrad profile was weak, but I had a 760 (along with CFA/CPA, good essays, a lot of effort/visits/student chats, etc.) and got in. So who's to say? I usually advise students to shoot for their school's average, especially if you're an American white/Asian/Indian male. If you're a female, URM, or int'l, hitting the average isn't as important I wouldn't think. (Hint: focus on VERBAL.. an improved verbal score boosts your overall score a lot faster than an improved quant score, and an improved quant score can take months of painful studying)

Also, you may find this interesting... we are advised to disclose our GMAT score on our resumes if its above 700. I am not sure how much employers weight your score (I'm sure each industry is different). That being said, a surprising # of AM shops, especially hedge funds, request a breakout of your SAT score.. yes, you heard that right.. SATs, in addition to your GMAT breakout. So some employers must value your test scores to some extent.

 
TommyGunn:
Whats the rough percentage of student that go in to finance/IBD? I know that it declines year on year. What will come first, banks recruiting at lower tier schools or MBA associate programmes being phased out?

I've seen grads from Penn State MBA land BB Associate positions. I don't know if you consider PSU a "lower tier" school.

IMO they will rely on A2A promotions more. I for one, am interested in going to banking post B School.

 

Banking and consulting look for 700+ gmat scores as quick measures of intellectual horse power. A 760 is clearly more impressive than a 710 but it would rarely be used as a differentiating factor in the hiring process (esp if both candidates went to top schools). Also, many top schools have grade non-disclosure policies so it is frowned upon to include your GPA although you can disclose it if asked.

UG GPA is usually given as a cumulative number with difficulty of major taken into account. I've never been asked to break out my course grades during an interview.

 

Banks and consulting firms will ask for your gmat scores most of the time, and sometimes may ask for your undergrad GPA.

But keep in mind that they do so just to gather additional data point - it's hardly a determining factor (i.e. they're not going to hire you over someone else just because you had a 740, and the other guy had a 680).

Alex Chu

Alex Chu www.mbaapply.com
 

i felt they were more interested in your UG school, general work experience, extra-curriculars/accomplishments, and presentation (i thought this was a key deciding factor... how polished are you and can you clearly/effectively communicate your thoughts/ideas). along with this is a basic understanding of finance/accounting.

 

I certainly hope hiring firms take GMAT, UG school, and difficulty of major into account. I'm entering a top-15 program this fall with a 770 GMAT, but a weak 2.97 UG GPA (Biological and Environmental Engineering at Cornell). The GPA is really the only blemish on my record, but it kept me out of the three MBA business schools">M7 schools I applied to (at least that's what I think kept me out). As a career changer - blue chip engineering experience seeking M/B/B or BB I-Banking - I hope it won't continue to hold me back 6+ years on from UG.

 

Grades don't matter that much and neither do gmat scores. Not being a tool bag is what really matters. Do some self reflection and if you're honest with yourself and you're not a douche, you'll get a good job. If you have great scores and all that worthless crap and you don't get the job you want... then you're obviously a douche.

 
x35109:
Grades don't matter that much and neither do gmat scores. Not being a tool bag is what really matters. Do some self reflection and if you're honest with yourself and you're not a douche, you'll get a good job. If you have great scores and all that worthless crap and you don't get the job you want... then you're obviously a douche.

You're a douche and you got a job.

 

i guess Temple University has been focussing its entrance requirements on the ability to determine someone's relative douche bag status.

too bad for you other schools didn't regard that ability as highly.

good luck getting a job from Temple.... my dry cleaning is piling up, i'll give you 50 cents to drop it off for me

 

Thanks a lot Short, I figured as much.

I know that people usually get blasted on here for such questions (and I tend to agree), but what about a 720 with a 46q (77%)...I can't imagine anyone recommend that I retake the gmat for the 80%+ in q, but will not having that actually hinder some chances? - (not for trading or HF, but for banking).

Are scores acutally a first screener, or just part of the interview questioning?

And are some firms bigger on this than others? I've heard GS, JPM, and MCK are the toughest with scores (730+ and 80/80) any truth?

Thanks guys

 

are you sure a 46 is a 77? i have a 48 and its 82 so i think a 46 is 73 or so, isnt it?

i think you should be fine with that, i dont know how insanely picky the b schools are though to be honest.. i know the 'first' hurdle is the 7-- handle on your score and then 2nd they want 80%+, but dont know how stingy theyd be with that.. 700 is the first minimum score you can get for the 80/80 ( 82/83, booyaaaaaaa) , ive never heard the 730 thing only the 7 and 80/80 splits... first for hiring, the latter more so for recruiting..

 

I took it right after graduation. Taking it earlier than later is definitely a good idea, since being in the work force for a couple years definitely takes you out of the "academic mindset".

Founder, Volunteer Forever http://www.volunteerforever.com
 
swbluedevil:
I took it right after graduation. Taking it earlier than later is definitely a good idea, since being in the work force for a couple years definitely takes you out of the "academic mindset".

A lot of people at my bank took it right after graduation, before training started. Some banks will actually pay for your prep course (mine does), so if you want to take a course and don't want to pay the $1500, the option might be there.

 

If you have the time then definitely take them during school. If you are a reasonably intelligent person, which you must be in you got a gig at BB, then a couple months of GMAT prep will fine for you. Scoring over 700 (or 750) on the GMAT is really a product of putting in a couple months of practice. Once you understand the various types of questions and get some practice on the timing & setup then you will do fine. I would recommend buying some of the gmat prep books (GMAT 800 and Manhattan Prep for Quant) rather than paying $1000 bucks for a Kaplan course. The Kaplan courses are very basic and don't really touch on the difficult questions that make the difference between 650 and 700.

good luck

 

If you have the time then definitely take them during school. If you are a reasonably intelligent person, which you must be if you got a gig at BB, then a couple months of GMAT prep will fine for you. Scoring over 700 (or 750) on the GMAT is really a product of putting in a couple months of practice. Once you understand the various types of questions and get some practice on the timing & setup then you will do fine. I would recommend buying some of the gmat prep books (GMAT 800 and Manhattan Prep for Quant) rather than paying $1000 bucks for a Kaplan course. The Kaplan courses are very basic and don't really touch on the difficult questions that make the difference between 650 and 700.

good luck

 

Thanks for you comments all. mtones9 recommended "GMAT 800" and "Manhattan Prep for Quant." Does anyone else have any specific titles that they would recommend?

 
Jimbo:
places generally wont take applicants who already have an MBA.

Do you know that based upon fact? I know a couple of people who've gotten a second MBA because their first wasn't reputable. One got one at Columbia one got one at Wharton..

-------------- Either you sling crack rock or you got a wicked jump shot
 
ChimpUSMC:
As you all know that I was in the military and completed my MBA already. However, I have numerous friends that are exiting the service with an MBA. Many including myself are re-thinking of going back to B-school just to get into better programs. That would also most likely mean better school.

Do you have info on attractive GMAT score to get into NYU, COLUMBIA, and WHARTON.

...and do you think that the extra military experience can offset a lower GMAT score?

Where did you complete your MBA?

Have you already applied to places and been rejected, or not?

 

Median scores for Stanford, HBS and Wharton are ~710-720. We had a Kaplan tutor who came into the office for GMAT prep and explained this bar varies based on demographics. Not to sound racist or sexist, but the instructor bluntly explained that a white male from consulting / IB should be closer to 750 for safety's sake. Personally, I had originally aimed for a lower "target" GMAT score of ~700, and only tried for a higher score in an effort to win a bet against an associate in my class - I was happy with a 770, but still lost out to her 800 (she also had better essay scores)

 
smuguy97:
Personally, I had originally aimed for a lower "target" GMAT score of ~700, and only tried for a higher score in an effort to win a bet against an associate in my class - I was happy with a 770, but still lost out to her 800 (she also had better essay scores)

How much preparation did you do, did the girl at least let you sleep with her for the 770? I hope. You two could make babies that score 785 ceteris paribus.

 

Eum voluptatem qui harum est. Dolores iure esse facilis et. Qui voluptatem vel sequi quia id quia. Autem eaque aut aliquid est voluptate natus. Officiis voluptatem voluptatem in rerum sunt culpa.

Quia aut omnis repudiandae id consequuntur minima voluptatum. Ad sed ratione at laboriosam enim iste. Eos quo nihil occaecati facere.

Voluptas illum sapiente aut ipsam ut. Eaque eveniet asperiores molestiae dolore. Veritatis atque odit temporibus rem doloremque exercitationem maiores. Consectetur delectus soluta et explicabo laborum.

Cumque explicabo necessitatibus voluptatum nihil eum modi. Facere tempora sit beatae qui totam hic optio in.

 

Cumque iusto blanditiis iste fugiat quo ratione. Officia exercitationem aspernatur veritatis maiores sint non cupiditate ea. Maxime et amet officia quae quia. Expedita eaque voluptas id corporis quia odit. Consequatur natus dolor ipsa minima repellat molestiae ut. Rerum totam possimus enim tempora. Velit quae esse incidunt iste ullam accusantium.

Ut animi rerum ad laborum aut necessitatibus. Autem omnis libero omnis voluptas nobis provident sed. Est id et veniam molestiae vel in. Corporis voluptatem eligendi totam iure eius aut omnis. Impedit error repellendus itaque alias occaecati magnam.

Ea consequuntur quo rerum ut. Eveniet quasi non omnis explicabo. Maxime veritatis atque ea nihil voluptatem aut.

[Comment removed by mod team]

Career Advancement Opportunities

April 2024 Investment Banking

  • Jefferies & Company 02 99.4%
  • Goldman Sachs 19 98.8%
  • Harris Williams & Co. New 98.3%
  • Lazard Freres 02 97.7%
  • JPMorgan Chase 03 97.1%

Overall Employee Satisfaction

April 2024 Investment Banking

  • Harris Williams & Co. 18 99.4%
  • JPMorgan Chase 10 98.8%
  • Lazard Freres 05 98.3%
  • Morgan Stanley 07 97.7%
  • William Blair 03 97.1%

Professional Growth Opportunities

April 2024 Investment Banking

  • Lazard Freres 01 99.4%
  • Jefferies & Company 02 98.8%
  • Goldman Sachs 17 98.3%
  • Moelis & Company 07 97.7%
  • JPMorgan Chase 05 97.1%

Total Avg Compensation

April 2024 Investment Banking

  • Director/MD (5) $648
  • Vice President (19) $385
  • Associates (86) $261
  • 3rd+ Year Analyst (13) $181
  • Intern/Summer Associate (33) $170
  • 2nd Year Analyst (66) $168
  • 1st Year Analyst (205) $159
  • Intern/Summer Analyst (145) $101
notes
16 IB Interviews Notes

“... there’s no excuse to not take advantage of the resources out there available to you. Best value for your $ are the...”

Leaderboard

1
redever's picture
redever
99.2
2
BankonBanking's picture
BankonBanking
99.0
3
Secyh62's picture
Secyh62
99.0
4
Betsy Massar's picture
Betsy Massar
99.0
5
dosk17's picture
dosk17
98.9
6
kanon's picture
kanon
98.9
7
GameTheory's picture
GameTheory
98.9
8
CompBanker's picture
CompBanker
98.9
9
bolo up's picture
bolo up
98.8
10
numi's picture
numi
98.8
success
From 10 rejections to 1 dream investment banking internship

“... I believe it was the single biggest reason why I ended up with an offer...”