Guggenheim (NY) Vs. Rothschild (NY) Vs. William Blair (Chicago)
Have offers from these three firms for SA. Was hoping to get input on which offer is the best. Specifically, which will have the best exit opportunities down the road for PE (have not heard much about Guggenheim exits)?
Anyone feel free to step in here, but haven't heard great noises out of Roth NY recently (can't speak for RX though).
Won't say much about Guggenheim as I don't quite have my finger on the pulse. If you want to exit to most PE shops in Chicago, Blair will get you there
Choosing Blair over Gugg is just insane
No one made a recommendation. Pointed out that if you want PE in Chicago, Blair is your best option
Guggenheim hands down. Don't know why this is even a question haha
I am leaning towards Guggenheim, but I have heard very mixed reviews about their exit opportunities because it is such a new firm. Does anyone have any insight?
I mean, you have to be the best anywhere for good exit opps. Same would apply to Guggenheim
Guggenheim NY: have heard of 1 analyst placing at a mega fund in the past few years (strictly word of mouth). Most likely concentrated in MM shops. Again, purely hearsay on this.
Rothschild NY: have seen very few analysts from Rothschild at US buyout shops...may just be due to the class sizes relative to other places.
William Blair CHI: will get you looks from top Chicago PE (think GTCR, MDP), have heard great things about their healthcare group. Great firm with fantastic reputation and culture - the negative feedback on the firm is more likely due to WSO readers' prestige boners for GS TMT and MS M&A.
You've got great offers. If it were me, I would take William Blair Chicago in a heartbeat. Hope this was helpful!
I'm going to intervene here because I dont want you listening to the above poster. DO NOT GO TO BLAIR OVER Guggenheim. Guggenheim is at least in the conversation / is an elite boutique. Blair is a strictly MM shop, and it isn't even the best MM shop. Use common sense now.
I am assuming you are not from Chicago. Not saying WB> Gugg, but it all depends on what your career goals are. The vast majority of people I've spoken to at WB are very happy and love their jobs and work environment. This is worth considering, as I think at the end of the day a fantastic culture/ awesome group of co-workers goes a very long way.
I know a bunch of people who work at or have worked at GTCR and MDP. There are virtually no former William Blair banking analysts. They recruit from the bulge bracket and some top boutique banks. I'm not saying that Blair is a bad shop, but to take it over Guggenheim or Rothschild in hopes of landing at GTCR/MDP is misguided.
Agreed - accepting on the premise of landing GTCR/MDP is misguided, was more so making the point that those shops are not entirely closed off to WB analysts as they have historically taken associates from there.
Honestly not too sure if the comparisons are even apples to apples; reputation in the city each of these firms are based out of needs to be assessed separately.
Congrats on your offers and well done. FYI, Blair has had an incredible return offer rate for their SAs the past two years (>85%) - I know from trying to network in there this past year.
Would go for William Blair: deal flow is very solid and their analyst have very decent PE exit opps + the culture is amazing
source/examples?
Has Rothschild US really slipped that much? WB has really become a hot item in Chicago. No idea on Guggenheim.
William Blair is absolute king in Chicago and from what I understand a very robust experience at the junior levels (culture/deal flow/client exposure)
100% Can confirm
Blair is beasting it. Gugg has slipped so far.
Can you comment on why you believe Guggenheim has slipped. Seem as though their exits have improved over the past few years
Nobis voluptatum sed id enim quidem. Dolores odio iusto ut fuga et placeat. Aperiam commodi atque ut cupiditate reprehenderit ipsam consequatur cumque.
Et praesentium perspiciatis nam. Voluptate sint aut commodi voluptates. Exercitationem incidunt deleniti dignissimos unde aperiam molestiae.
Maiores quia dolorem cupiditate iusto blanditiis. In harum odio enim eos libero. Et velit impedit quaerat sed rerum labore velit.
Quasi quia expedita sapiente libero quis et. Ex harum odit doloremque commodi blanditiis blanditiis repudiandae qui. Eos quo aut laudantium exercitationem voluptas quae.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
A similique voluptatem eligendi recusandae officia sint nulla. Aliquid provident porro voluptatem totam dolorem libero.
Ad et sed recusandae facilis consequatur ut. Laborum nam natus sint optio autem. Quia rerum fugit qui dolorem harum quibusdam dignissimos. Eligendi necessitatibus sed officiis ducimus sequi. Beatae voluptatem sint eos enim.
Odit est voluptas rerum ratione nisi. Minima voluptates perspiciatis aut sed vero sunt. Facere et possimus et quo corporis quis ducimus. Magnam ut possimus nihil enim est.
Ea libero ab iste consectetur minima voluptatibus soluta. Qui voluptas natus voluptate ut velit odio odit. Rem modi excepturi ducimus eos. Dolorum fugiat voluptatum numquam dolorum dolorem. Eum aperiam rerum ad nostrum. Voluptatem libero placeat reiciendis quod.