I currently analyze the financial sector for St. Bonaventure University's Students in Money Management group. I'm running a valuation on First Niagara and am having trouble with the Dcf which I think is coming from crazy working capital projections I am getting because First Niagara has been acquiring HSBC assets for the last year causing big swings in their nwc. Any ideas on how to fix this problem?
Dec 03, 2012
Trending Content - Management Consulting Forum
| +12 | MBB FT Choices | 1 | 15h |
| +8 | What's the Culture at A&M Like? | 10 | 2d |
| +6 | learn casing in a week | 3 | 50m |
Career Resources
Career Advancement Opportunities
July 2026 Consulting
-
Boston Consulting Group 99.5%
-
Bain & Company 98.9%
-
McKinsey and Co 98.4%
-
Oliver Wyman 97.9%
-
LEK Consulting 97.4%
Overall Employee Satisfaction
July 2026 Consulting
-
Cornerstone Research 99.5%
-
Bain & Company 98.9%
-
Boston Consulting Group 98.4%
-
McKinsey and Co 97.9%
-
Oliver Wyman 97.4%
Professional Growth Opportunities
July 2026 Consulting
-
Bain & Company 99.5%
-
Boston Consulting Group 98.9%
-
McKinsey and Co 98.4%
-
Oliver Wyman 97.9%
-
LEK Consulting 97.4%
Total Avg Compensation
July 2026 Consulting
-
Partner (4) $361
-
Principal (30) $294
-
Director/MD (58) $274
-
Vice President (53) $247
-
Engagement Manager (113) $232
-
Manager (171) $173
-
2nd Year Associate (185) $142
-
3rd+ Year Associate (116) $135
-
Senior Consultant (354) $132
-
Consultant (642) $122
-
1st Year Associate (577) $121
-
3rd+ Year Analyst (164) $121
-
NA (16) $114
-
Engineer (6) $114
-
2nd Year Analyst (391) $104
-
Associate Consultant (176) $101
-
1st Year Analyst (1163) $90
-
Intern/Summer Associate (208) $83
-
Intern/Summer Analyst (633) $68
16 IB Interviews Notes
“... there’s no excuse to not take advantage of the resources out there available to you. Best value for your $ are the...”
Leaderboard
| 1 |  |
99.2 |
| 2 | |
99.0 |
| 3 | |
99.0 |
| 4 | |
99.0 |
| 5 | |
98.9 |
| 6 |  |
98.9 |
| 7 | |
98.9 |
| 8 | |
98.9 |
| 9 |  |
98.9 |
| 10 |  |
98.8 |
From 10 rejections to 1 dream investment banking internship
“... I believe it was the single biggest reason why I ended up with an offer...”
Generally, do not use a DCF for banks/insurers. Cash flows will not paint an accurate picture, unless you go back and normalize them.
You are better off projecting operating earnings, then coming to a valuation based on a multiple of their forecast book value and/or future earnings.
The value of a Bank/Insurer is on the balance sheet. Projecting earnings is not terribly difficult. But how much capital can they deploy? How much will management deploy? And in what form? By the sound of what you just said, First Niagara is buying up HSBC assets. What impact will those have on earnings? How will this impact their loan loss reserves? You get the idea.
Thanks. I had an idea that a DCF wouldn't do much for financials because the fluctuation in their numbers were just way too high.
It isn't that you can't use a dcf; it is just that there is so much noise you need to back out to get a reasonable estimate of cash flows. You could use after tax operating earnings, and that would get you pretty close.
Some financial companies trade on Book Value (of various varieties), others on earnings, and others on cash flow. Value it a few different ways, spread comps for several multiples, figure out which are important by looking at past price movements, and then weight each value appropriately. It isn't an exaggeration to call valuation more art than science.
I should have said changes in Net working capital. I used estimations of future operating earnings and got a number that looked pretty close to what I expected to be. Thanks for the tip, I'm going to try to go back and try to get a good idea of what it trades on.
DCF models don't work for financial institutions. One of the most popular metrics for evaluating financials is the price to book ratio.
Qui blanditiis rem sit dolorum delectus. Dolores iure qui dolorum cupiditate voluptatum. Qui dolor voluptates quia dolor alias.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...