McK vs Bain for Bschool?

To get into H/S, is there any meaningful difference in my chances applying from McKinsey or Bain? My offers are for the Toronto offices if that makes a difference. Recognize this is a privileged and slightly douchey question and that I’m very privileged to have this choice. Thanks all!

Region
 

Thanks - is this because Bain is strong in PE? How significant of a difference is it between McK/Bain for H/S?

 

More about qualifiers that McK/Bain vs. H/S/W use. McK selects for leaders regardless of industry (tech, public sector, social sector, finance, etc.), and Bain selects for top talent with a skew towards finance. H/S similarly selects for leaders across industries, while W prides themselves in PE/IB/HF placements. Just check for Alumni and this will be clearly validated - there are obviously exceptions but this is directionally the case.

Wouldn't consider it to make a significant difference (still goes down to each candidate's story, experiences, so on) but definitely helpful.

 

Don't listen to astarryworld, she's completely incorrect, and the only reason they'd have more alum is because they are bigger, that's it. Hell, the director of admissions at HBS right now is a former Bain manager.

MBB has equal chances. After that, there's a dropoff with OW, LEK, Parthenon, etc. but you have just as much a chance of H/S at Bain as you do at McKinsey, and anyone else telling you otherwise is 100% wrong.

Remember, always be kind-hearted.
 

Check out these deep dives on the MBA class of 2020 at HBS and GSB - https://fortunaadmissions.com/resources/mba_class_analysis/

For HBS, 81 students had worked at McKinsey & Company, 55 at BCG, and 52 at Bain. Given that Bain has less than half the employees of McKinsey, and BCG has about 2/3 the employees of McKinsey, if we control for firm size, MBB firms have equal success rates across H/S. The story is similar for Stanford GSB.

 

If you think McK is meaningfully more prestigious than Bain in the eyes of people who matter (I'm not talking about your average reader of the NYTimes), then that is a naive take. Bain wins its fair share of cross offers against McKinsey. They're both the pinnacle of the industry and, again, there are 20 different things going in an MBA application. Your firm is a tiny piece of that.

I'm assuming we're talking about North American offices here. There may be pockets geographically where McK is the only game in town, but those are edge cases.

 

Candidly, Harvard and Stanford (and more Stanford than Harvard) admissions at both firms have gotten very, very challenging for MBB. Now days, if you’re not a URM or LGBT woman or have something very unique or impressive in your profile, you usually need to spend a year or more outside the firm to distinguish your story.

 

What do you think is the biggest driving factor of this trend? That mbb classes have gotten a lot bigger or because H/S are looking for a different kind of candidate now? What about for international applicants? Also, any idea what the acceptance rate from MBB these days are?

 

Not sure on the key drivers but bigger classes sizes is certainly a big part of it. The admission process is also generally just more demanding now (GMAT averages are higher, more requirements for your involvement outside of work, etc.)

Acceptance rates shared internally are only for sponsored candidates, and most MBB applicants aren't sponsored, so I don't have specific numbers to share. 

 

Can definitely corroborate this. We collect acceptance rates on anyone who worked with the grad school team to apply (since sponsorship decisions come after you get an acceptance, not before) and both H/S have seen a significant downward trend in the last 10 years. Rest of M7 (including W) still sees pretty great acceptance rates though. It's just H/S where it might actually be advantageous to leave and get more diverse experience before applying.

Would also caveat that even though acceptance rates are worse than before, it's still a much better picture than overall acceptance rates to H/S

 

Thanks, can you give some color on what H/S acceptance rates at your MBB are at now and how much they’ve declined in recent years? I heard that 10-15 years ago BCG applicants to HBS had a 60% acceptance rate or something ridiculous

 

Nisi consectetur sed repudiandae eum. Consequatur mollitia tenetur repellat deserunt. Facere beatae placeat vitae nam ullam dignissimos ullam. Expedita rerum fuga eum. Eligendi dicta veritatis saepe nisi impedit.

Voluptas accusantium eveniet nulla quis eius. Unde quas eum ea ut voluptatem. Veniam facilis enim et sit. Culpa vel debitis quas distinctio animi libero et. Omnis soluta minus quae a iusto dolor. Culpa odit aliquam odio totam ullam.

 

Aut cupiditate expedita et reiciendis omnis. Iure veritatis culpa aut maxime corporis repellat quaerat. Aut quaerat quae praesentium qui. Est cumque fuga architecto. Quis ad tenetur similique tenetur aliquid sapiente. Sequi et veritatis molestias quibusdam quia quod. Quia voluptatum dolor in voluptatem.

Praesentium a repudiandae excepturi laborum in repellat. Iure quis sint quae dolorem. Non nihil aut aliquid. Quia velit doloremque qui expedita voluptatem sed harum.

Voluptas accusamus repellat ut nostrum quam et repudiandae. Quod aut eum et ipsam. Voluptate maiores et quod ullam. Aliquid veniam veniam ducimus placeat repellendus sed. Magnam et harum autem sit. Eos odit rerum consequuntur aperiam soluta et nesciunt.

Assumenda ex provident occaecati. Nisi culpa ab ipsam fuga dignissimos. Illum aut perferendis laudantium dolorum reiciendis quisquam. Nihil pariatur suscipit modi labore ea ducimus odit.

The truth is you're the weak. And I'm the tyranny of evil men. But I'm tryin', Ringo. I'm tryin' real hard to be the shepherd.

Career Advancement Opportunities

March 2024 Consulting

  • Bain & Company 99.4%
  • McKinsey and Co 98.9%
  • Boston Consulting Group (BCG) 98.3%
  • Oliver Wyman 97.7%
  • LEK Consulting 97.2%

Overall Employee Satisfaction

March 2024 Consulting

  • Bain & Company 99.4%
  • Cornerstone Research 98.9%
  • Boston Consulting Group (BCG) 98.3%
  • McKinsey and Co 97.7%
  • Oliver Wyman 97.2%

Professional Growth Opportunities

March 2024 Consulting

  • Bain & Company 99.4%
  • McKinsey and Co 98.9%
  • Boston Consulting Group (BCG) 98.3%
  • Oliver Wyman 97.7%
  • LEK Consulting 97.2%

Total Avg Compensation

March 2024 Consulting

  • Partner (4) $368
  • Principal (25) $277
  • Director/MD (55) $270
  • Vice President (47) $246
  • Engagement Manager (99) $225
  • Manager (152) $170
  • 2nd Year Associate (158) $140
  • 3rd+ Year Associate (108) $130
  • Senior Consultant (329) $130
  • Consultant (586) $119
  • 1st Year Associate (538) $119
  • NA (15) $119
  • 3rd+ Year Analyst (145) $115
  • Engineer (6) $114
  • 2nd Year Analyst (342) $102
  • Associate Consultant (166) $98
  • 1st Year Analyst (1046) $87
  • Intern/Summer Associate (188) $84
  • Intern/Summer Analyst (547) $67
notes
16 IB Interviews Notes

“... there’s no excuse to not take advantage of the resources out there available to you. Best value for your $ are the...”

Leaderboard

1
redever's picture
redever
99.2
2
BankonBanking's picture
BankonBanking
99.0
3
Betsy Massar's picture
Betsy Massar
99.0
4
Secyh62's picture
Secyh62
99.0
5
kanon's picture
kanon
98.9
6
DrApeman's picture
DrApeman
98.9
7
dosk17's picture
dosk17
98.9
8
GameTheory's picture
GameTheory
98.9
9
CompBanker's picture
CompBanker
98.9
10
Jamoldo's picture
Jamoldo
98.8
success
From 10 rejections to 1 dream investment banking internship

“... I believe it was the single biggest reason why I ended up with an offer...”