ROI Concerns for International Students with U.S. MBAs Seeking MBB or Tech Roles
I am a student from Asia considering pursuing an MBA in the United States. My goal after graduation is to secure a business role at MBB (McKinsey, BCG, Bain) or in the tech industry, ideally outside of China. However, I am concerned about my chances of being hired at MBB or in a tech company in the U.S., given that my English skills aren't perfect.
Do you think the ROI on a U.S. MBA is achievable for students like me? I believe it would be challenging to achieve a good ROI unless I secure a job with MBB or in tech in the U.S. Even if I get a position with MBB in another country, it might be tough to justify the investment. I'm also uncertain if it's even possible for someone with a U.S. MBA to join MBB in an international office.
I would appreciate hearing your thoughts and experiences on this.
Based on the most helpful WSO content, here are some insights regarding ROI concerns for international students pursuing U.S. MBAs and aiming for roles at MBB or in the tech industry:
ROI Concerns and Job Prospects:
International Student Challenges:
MBA Program Selection:
ROI Calculation:
Alternative Paths:
Recommendations:
Conclusion:
While there are significant challenges, many international students have successfully navigated these obstacles and achieved high ROI from their U.S. MBAs. It is crucial to target the right programs, leverage networking opportunities, and consider financial aid options to enhance your chances of success.
Sources: Is my American Dream Over?, Applying for MBA as International Student (with privileged visa), Is an MBA worth it?, How are MBA Programs Outside the Top 14 Viewed?, Banking is hot again at top MBA programs
What do you mean by not perfect English?
Securing a role in MBB (or out of b-school generally for that matter) is about social skills and the ability to network. MBB or bust is not a good strategy especially for an international student. I would open your options up to any top consulting firm that sponsors, I believe EY-P still does.
Lastly, to your question on international MBB placements, you definitely can, you just need to again network and make a good business case for it, example why would you want to go to the Singapore McK office.
Thank you very much for your very valuable answer. I will keep it in mind.
By the way, were there any International Students (especially from non-English speaking countries) around you? How many of them were able to stay in the US?
Definitely. All top bschools take international students (I'm one of them) and ones from non-English speaking countries. All the classes are in English and recruiting is in English (for the US obviously). Not an obstacle for getting into a school (assuming your GMAT/GRE english score is up to snuff).
The staying in the US part is more tricky as I've heard that has changed (i.e. success rates have dropped in the recent past). I would reach out to past students from your country/region at your target schools to get specific insights.
Thank you for your advice. It is not easy to find them around, but I will try my best to find them.
If recruiting for MBB, it's also important to consider which MBA you actually get into. MBB recruits heavily from M7 and T15, and it's quite difficult to break in from a non-target school esp in this economic climate.
Thank you for your valuable advice. Yes, of course I am aiming for M7 or T15, and if not accepted, I will stay in the country.
You defnitely have a good chance with MBB if you're from M7/T15. I am an international student as well, went to a T15, got invites from MBB and IB during recruitment. Currently working full time in IB.
Don't ignore Tier 2 and boutique consulting firms. Many if them sponsor visas and their comps are not bad at all, slightly below MBB but defnitely still very good. You can read employment reports of top MBA programs - Higher compensation is MBB, median is tier 2. Some specialized shops such as AlixPartners do pay well.
Also, don't ignore MBB in other countries. If you get a role in Singapore for example, you have engagements across the whole Southeast Asia and even Hong Kong. Compensation and benefits are very good. If you factor tax in your calcualtions, you may come out even better than an MBB role in NY/SF.
Thought IBs don’t sponsor visas?
Most do. Some don't. Of the ~30 banks that I networked with, maybe 2 specifically stated that they did not sponsor.
Thanks for your reply. Your experience as an international student is very informative. I'm actually thinking of going to MBB as I think I need it to pay off my debts, not because I'm particular about MBB. Of course, the companies you mentioned are also options.
So do you know what percentage of the international students around you have been successful in finding work in the US? Perhaps some of them had to return to their home countries.
Et quae et consectetur dicta corporis debitis. Voluptates aut nihil voluptas magni. Corporis recusandae ut ipsa laudantium maxime. Dolores commodi blanditiis hic eos maiores.
Saepe quasi ut aliquid cumque ratione dolores. Asperiores quia temporibus officiis officiis illum id. Rerum odit id aut eius iusto. Amet eaque ut omnis vel et. Doloribus et hic sit et non dolor quae. Reprehenderit vero quo necessitatibus ut.
Sequi eius soluta culpa voluptatem perspiciatis provident necessitatibus nobis. Similique repellendus qui aut animi corrupti temporibus ea. Earum voluptatem numquam quam. Sed dolore explicabo harum aperiam quod nulla ad quae. Non qui nemo quisquam qui recusandae eligendi aut.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...