Hi guys, I recently got admitted to all 3 schools for econ as a junior undergrad transfer and was wondering where i should go? Cost is the same for both. I care more about the reputation (i.e “prestige”) of the school and their placements at the top consulting firms (MBB). Which school would place me better at MBB?
Thank you!
| +48 | A Reflection | What I learned from being “counseled out” of MBB after 1-year post-undergrad | 6 | 1h | |
| +26 | any advice for what to apply for if not consulting? | 11 | 2d | |
| +25 | College Freshman: Do you need to business/finance ECs to have a good shot at MBB? | 14 | 2d | |
| +20 | Cannot exit MBB | 8 | 2h | |
| +18 | Renege on FT offer | 3 | 4h | |
| +9 | MBB vs Big 4 | 2 | 3d | |
| +6 | Summer internship BCG, McKinsey | 7 | 1d | |
| +6 | MBB Singapore vs T2 London FT | 2 | 4d | |
| +6 | Big 4 Consulting versus Boutique IB | 1 | 2d | |
| +4 | BCG Chicago thoughts | 1 | 7h |
Career Resources
Get instant access to lessons taught by experienced private equity pros and bulge bracket investment bankers including financial statement modeling, DCF, M&A, LBO, Comps and Excel Modeling.
[EDIT: forgot to congratulate you on getting a transfer to all 3! Very nicely done! + corrections in red to incorporate some comments from other posters]
Was waiting a bit to see if some people here had some experience / better info. All I can contribute to your thinking is a cursory search on LinkedIn and some basic calcs. The figures look like:
So, in pure numbers, Berkeley wins by a substantial margin, while UCLA / USC seems to make little difference. Of course to calculate success rates you'd need to know how many applied and got in per year, but that would have to come from anecdotal reports of people sharing how they & their friends did.
As a weak triangulation point for "success rates", all 3 colleges seem to have about 45K students total, but around
So, UCLA might place a little
worsebetter(after correction) than USC if it churns out ~3.7x more~1.5x fewer econ & business grads but places about as many people in MBB (a LOT of assumptions go in this statement, e.g., only considering econ & business grads and assuming they all apply to MBB, or that no other group at these universities are more important for the recruitment, likebusiness/financemajors).Overall, it might look like Berkeley > UCLA > USC
> UCLA, if I had to go by some arbitrary metrics without inputs from current/former students or local MBB recruitment teams.Another quick take away is that they all place in MBB pretty well. I hope others chime in to add some real experiences / accounts.
Tons of caveat to these figures:
Wow, thank you sir! This was the most comprehensive advice I had so far! LinkedIn is definitely a good resource for this.
Since I’m an econ major, I wouldn’t be in haas, but that’s mainly bcoz I don’t wanna study business for undergrad. Are non-haas students in a significant disadvantage during recruiting?
UC Berkeley has an undergraduate business program which UCLA does not. A lot of students who want to get into business at UCLA do the econ major, with mixed results. But at Cal, students can get an actual undergraduate business degree.
So you'd need to take into account the number of business majors plus econ majors at UCB for that analysis above.
At Berkeley, the undergraduate business degree would provide both competition (during recruiting) and synergy (Haas management consulting clubs, on campus recruiting, etc.) Especially as a junior transfer, I imagine it would be too late for you yourself to transfer into Haas. I'm not sure to what degree non-Haas students benefit or not from that synergy. So that would be a differentiating factor. Only you can determine if its net favorable or not.
Also if recruiting is more regionally dominant, you're looking at LA (UCLA and USC) vs SF/Bay area (UCB). So location may play into your decision process. I think that a lot of people are losing jobs in the bay area right now. Did that adversely impact current grads in the area? Idk, but possibly something to research/think about. Might that impact your junior year internship? Of course, by the time that you graduate, that may have all turned on a dime and the economy may be firing on all cylinders.
Lastly, I get the sense that the Trojan alum spirit is fighting fierce. I'm guessing more so than the UC alum spirit. But I have no real data to back this up. Just a spidey sense.
Lots to think about.
Some good points in there! I changed my response to include business grads (in red, so we can see I missed it initially :) )
Hi sorry I’m new to recruiting, what do you mean by “the undergrad business degree would provide more competition during recruiting”? Do MBB firms have a quota of how many Berkeley students they take per year? Hence why more internal competition.
USC imo, it’s a strong private school with less people applying than the massive state schools of ucla and Berkeley, alums are more responsive since they get less requests, I have seen usc place into MBB NY annually, it’s also more selective to be at usc than ucla or berkeley
Id agree with with this. I’ll add USC alum network is extremely strong.
Idk whether or not MBB has a quota for Berkeley or not, but obviously your competition will consist of well-prepared Haas undergrads.
The synergy of the Haas undergrad business school will definitely help the Haas undergrads. Idk whether or not it will also benefit the L & S econ undergrads. I'd guess that that would largely depend on how you manage to leverage that synergy in your favor.
Ultimately MBB wants the most talented kids.
Go to USC and change your major to biz at Marshall. Might take an extra semester but USC isnt as hardass about semester caps.
Any reason why USC Marshall over berkeley non-haas?
Bc it's smaller, more mentorship, less people applying, more receptive alum, it'd a private school. Also non haas will be super tough as haas will have advantage over non haas due to alums. Usc>non haas for sure. You’ll be lost in the sea of applications from ucb non haas easier than usc
Neque excepturi deleniti recusandae. Vel vel eos qui nemo facilis. Ut nostrum dicta et perferendis consequatur.
Modi similique distinctio praesentium laborum veniam sed animi minus. Qui itaque quae alias id dolor. Voluptatem et vero alias sunt voluptas velit nesciunt. Voluptates accusamus unde quidem deleniti aut sequi.
Tempora sint voluptas sunt placeat ipsa voluptatem sit. Non nulla ea ea quia. Et consectetur aut dolore id autem et.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...