Buy side perspective: MS>ER. GS tends to put out very high level research, even at the company level.
Disclaimer for the Kids: Any forward-looking statements are solely for informational purposes and cannot be taken as investment advice. Consult your moms before deciding where to invest.
I follow their energy research and think this. Our generalist value team here also thinks the same. I have a friend at a physical commodity shop (who presumably also follows their energy research) tell me the same thing the other day.
Disclaimer for the Kids: Any forward-looking statements are solely for informational purposes and cannot be taken as investment advice. Consult your moms before deciding where to invest.
Thanks for the quick response. Any groups within each firm that stands out as better than the counterpart? Aside from the traditional II rankings since GS doesn't participate there.
To be honest, I don't think it matters very much which firm you work for. The more important factor to consider is which analyst you would work with, his reputation, and how well you work with him and his style of running a team
"I do not think that there is any other quality so essential to success of any kind as the quality of perseverance. It overcomes almost everything, even nature."
"I do not think that there is any other quality so essential to success of any kind as the quality of perseverance. It overcomes almost everything, even nature."
"I do not think that there is any other quality so essential to success of any kind as the quality of perseverance. It overcomes almost everything, even nature."
"I do not think that there is any other quality so essential to success of any kind as the quality of perseverance. It overcomes almost everything, even nature."
it is about analyst that you work for, not some ranking dude...
sure, good global ranking helps, but it doesn't mean shit if you go deeper into sectors, analysts, etc.
if he can get a good analyst
and have a GS brand
he will go a long way, i am sure
"I do not think that there is any other quality so essential to success of any kind as the quality of perseverance. It overcomes almost everything, even nature."
I'll say it again cause I think it's being overlooked -- you gotta consider the analyst's personality and the way he runs his team as well. Most associates I knew would have easily given up a spot on a top II ranked team for a chance to work with certain analysts who treated their associate better, didn't go batshit insane at random things, allowed them to have more client exposure, or allowed them to have better work life balance.
There are many senior analysts out there who will work you to the bone updating models and doing mundane things without giving you a chance to move up.
I'll say it again cause I think it's being overlooked -- you gotta consider the analyst's personality and the way he runs his team as well. Most associates I knew would have easily given up a spot on a top II ranked team for a chance to work with certain analysts who treated their associate better, didn't go batshit insane at random things, allowed them to have more client exposure, or allowed them to have better work life balance.
There are many senior analysts out there who will work you to the bone updating models and doing mundane things without giving you a chance to move up.
It's difficult to do without making yourself look bad. In the interview, you can talk about how he runs his team, what the expectations are, etc.
An even better thing to do might be to ask some of the other associates on the floor on other teams. They are more likely to be honest, and won't be involved in the hiring decision. Obviously, you still have to be careful with how you word things since they might be good friends with people on the other team.
How you get in touch with them is another thing. While you're on the floor, you can ask which teams sit around where your team sits. If you can then get their research reports, the associates will be listed on there. Alternatively you can try to meet as many associates/assistants before/after the interview and ask them whether they'd recommend the team you're interviewing for (not sure if you'd get a chance to do this though)
At the two different banks I worked at, the other associates knew the reputation of the senior analyst and how he ran his team.
Offer Help: MS vs GS Equity Research (Originally Posted: 10/22/2011)
After a long recruiting season, I've ended up with two really good offers: Morgan Stanley Equity Research Associate and Goldman Sachs Equity Research Associate. I've done a bit of searching, and I noticed that most people say that the analyst matters more than the firm in equity research. But, neither of the offers are for a specific group. Does anyone have any advice?
Also, I've had quite a few second rounds for buyside ER at top long only shops. If I end up getting offers from them, should I take any of them over what I have now?
You're born, you take shit. You get out in the world, you take more shit. You climb a little higher, you take less shit. Till one day you're up in the rarefied atmosphere and you've forgotten what shit even looks like. Welcome to the layer cake, son.
No, I mean what are they offering you? Pay, bonus/benefits, etc.
You're born, you take shit. You get out in the world, you take more shit. You climb a little higher, you take less shit. Till one day you're up in the rarefied atmosphere and you've forgotten what shit even looks like. Welcome to the layer cake, son.
Aut autem ipsum vel aut aut sed modi quibusdam. Quibusdam molestiae quos enim asperiores velit dignissimos officia similique.
Amet sunt placeat aliquid quia. Quia vero delectus quis. Vel inventore reprehenderit dolorem est neque. Quos corrupti incidunt ex adipisci qui.
Doloribus expedita necessitatibus nihil ipsum vel iure illo. Et quasi est est sapiente. Dolorum et laborum qui est omnis nihil. At voluptas officia error ut natus quis.
Sit a explicabo doloribus soluta neque. Aliquam laboriosam voluptas repellendus dolore animi magni. Enim pariatur laboriosam autem. Non magni nostrum totam eum. Ut exercitationem vel ipsam nemo. Corporis sapiente fugiat asperiores eaque. Minus fugit et sed eum nostrum dolorem optio.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
Architecto ea aut sint voluptatum non minima. Est eveniet reiciendis quis maiores reprehenderit sunt. Eveniet est exercitationem atque consectetur quibusdam.
Rerum dolorem soluta sunt sunt tempore. Accusantium id officiis rerum voluptas. Sint dolores voluptatibus tempora ipsa. Ea assumenda nihil rerum in numquam velit quaerat. Recusandae molestias atque sed omnis iure ea veritatis.
Sorry, you need to login or sign up in order to vote. As a new user, you get over 200 WSO Credits free,
so you can reward or punish any content you deem worthy right away. See you on the other side!
Buy side perspective: MS>ER. GS tends to put out very high level research, even at the company level.
sorry i was doing 2 things at once, MS > GS
I follow their energy research and think this. Our generalist value team here also thinks the same. I have a friend at a physical commodity shop (who presumably also follows their energy research) tell me the same thing the other day.
To be honest, I don't think it matters very much which firm you work for. The more important factor to consider is which analyst you would work with, his reputation, and how well you work with him and his style of running a team
MS ER >> GS ER
MS is ranked top 3 in ER. GS is not even top 5.
you'd jizz your pants if you ever received an email from GS dude..
"not even top 5" are you kidding me... what a statement
http://www.institutionalinvestor.com/Article/3387688/research-and-ranki…
Let me know if you still have any question.
and ISI was acquired by Evercore.
I'll be surprised if GS ER is even in top 10.
you really don't get it, do you?
it is about analyst that you work for, not some ranking dude... sure, good global ranking helps, but it doesn't mean shit if you go deeper into sectors, analysts, etc.
if he can get a good analyst and have a GS brand he will go a long way, i am sure
ok
All depends on analyst, but seems like MS ER has a lot more II ranked analysts than GS ER...
Like I know MS ER has had the best Media & Telecom analyst for the past few years. Would give my first born for a chance to be his Associate.
I'll say it again cause I think it's being overlooked -- you gotta consider the analyst's personality and the way he runs his team as well. Most associates I knew would have easily given up a spot on a top II ranked team for a chance to work with certain analysts who treated their associate better, didn't go batshit insane at random things, allowed them to have more client exposure, or allowed them to have better work life balance.
There are many senior analysts out there who will work you to the bone updating models and doing mundane things without giving you a chance to move up.
@ cob5
what are some good way to assess fit both ways? any questions or conversations you suggest we steer interviews towards?
This is so true.
It's difficult to do without making yourself look bad. In the interview, you can talk about how he runs his team, what the expectations are, etc.
An even better thing to do might be to ask some of the other associates on the floor on other teams. They are more likely to be honest, and won't be involved in the hiring decision. Obviously, you still have to be careful with how you word things since they might be good friends with people on the other team.
How you get in touch with them is another thing. While you're on the floor, you can ask which teams sit around where your team sits. If you can then get their research reports, the associates will be listed on there. Alternatively you can try to meet as many associates/assistants before/after the interview and ask them whether they'd recommend the team you're interviewing for (not sure if you'd get a chance to do this though)
At the two different banks I worked at, the other associates knew the reputation of the senior analyst and how he ran his team.
Offer Help: MS vs GS Equity Research (Originally Posted: 10/22/2011)
After a long recruiting season, I've ended up with two really good offers: Morgan Stanley Equity Research Associate and Goldman Sachs Equity Research Associate. I've done a bit of searching, and I noticed that most people say that the analyst matters more than the firm in equity research. But, neither of the offers are for a specific group. Does anyone have any advice?
Also, I've had quite a few second rounds for buyside ER at top long only shops. If I end up getting offers from them, should I take any of them over what I have now?
What are the offers?
Morgan Stanley Equity Research and Goldman Sachs Equity Research. Both are full time, in New York, straight out of college.
Anyone? Even just general differences between the two firms would be great.
No, I mean what are they offering you? Pay, bonus/benefits, etc.
Aut autem ipsum vel aut aut sed modi quibusdam. Quibusdam molestiae quos enim asperiores velit dignissimos officia similique.
Amet sunt placeat aliquid quia. Quia vero delectus quis. Vel inventore reprehenderit dolorem est neque. Quos corrupti incidunt ex adipisci qui.
Doloribus expedita necessitatibus nihil ipsum vel iure illo. Et quasi est est sapiente. Dolorum et laborum qui est omnis nihil. At voluptas officia error ut natus quis.
Sit a explicabo doloribus soluta neque. Aliquam laboriosam voluptas repellendus dolore animi magni. Enim pariatur laboriosam autem. Non magni nostrum totam eum. Ut exercitationem vel ipsam nemo. Corporis sapiente fugiat asperiores eaque. Minus fugit et sed eum nostrum dolorem optio.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Architecto ea aut sint voluptatum non minima. Est eveniet reiciendis quis maiores reprehenderit sunt. Eveniet est exercitationem atque consectetur quibusdam.
Rerum dolorem soluta sunt sunt tempore. Accusantium id officiis rerum voluptas. Sint dolores voluptatibus tempora ipsa. Ea assumenda nihil rerum in numquam velit quaerat. Recusandae molestias atque sed omnis iure ea veritatis.