Are financial models even important?
As George Soros once said in his book The Alchemy of Finance, "It is better to use no model than a faulty model". Lets face it, most models are wrong and their projections are usually off. Especially in the multi manager model which is short-term and speculative, how does building financial models even help there. In the short term stocks are based off of what the market participants think the company is going to do in the future so what is even the point of building financial models in this type of role, wouldn't it be much better to use your time trying to figure out what other people in the market are going to do next?
bump
bump
bump
To feed the PM's thirst for false precision and numbers.
But wasn't the PM an analyst once too who worked his way up to being where he is, so doesn't he understand that financial models do not help?
Your initial point was very good that why wouldn't they just focus on what other participants are thinking, and they do. But it's also single name stock trading, so need to put together numbers out to know what's priced in and what's not.
Also shorter-term funds hire ppl from IB/PE background so it's naturally part of their DNA to model the crap out of things as part of the thought process.
PM's PM thinks in numbers too, so I wouldn't expect a PM to be changing the process until he/she changes dramatically to become a long-term wide-moat concentrated investor where a lot more time devoted on the business and the softer stuff.
Building a model forces you to research the company and industry. That way you might not get accurate numbers, but you’ll still find out whether or not the company is trash or if it looks good.
Couldn't agree more. I would have to find the data again, but a survey of analyst models showed most had serious errors. Understanding the drivers and movements in the cost base is more valuable and helps to get up the curve quicker.
You still use fundamentals at a MM...yes you have to think more about positioning and so forth but its not just what other people are going to do...
Can’t you focus your strategy around predicting what others are going to do next? After all that is what the theory of reflexivity says
So if everyone else is using financial models to predict the stock price, shouldn't you also be modeling to understand why the stock is moving? Firms seriously trading TSLA or GME I hope are not using financial models but rather flows and technicals to make their decisions. Different stocks different reasons.
Wait did you read Soros or something?
Ratione quos voluptatem aspernatur consectetur nihil magnam. Quaerat quo magni accusamus non et consequatur. Et sapiente sed ratione harum atque modi ab.
Omnis sit dignissimos sint fugiat. Nihil molestiae laborum laudantium. Omnis et non et amet consequatur. Aut eaque nihil dolor itaque corporis aut. Suscipit iusto magnam omnis deleniti soluta et.
Consequatur ut nisi quo aliquam. Dolores sed repudiandae aperiam dolorum est commodi. Voluptas voluptates error rerum voluptates incidunt. Amet quia aut voluptatem id.
Voluptatem rerum nemo eveniet id. Facere cupiditate reiciendis harum soluta. Beatae nisi tenetur aut. Enim alias deserunt vero iusto quis. Qui dolores ea magnam libero adipisci veniam quis.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...