Which IBD summer offer to take (converted springs) and why?
Don't know teams yet as team allocations will only be done next year (after all summer spots are filled through recruiting).
For London of course.
| +133 | Americas M&A League Table Q2 Updated | 62 | 1h |
| +132 | New Article: Dramatic Slide as UBS #22 (US) & New Leadership Desperately Needed | 25 | 1d |
| +64 | A COMPLETE GUIDE TO SUMMER INTERNSHIP RECRUITING | 12 | 1h |
| +49 | Boutique firm wants access to my LinkedIn? | 40 | 1h |
| +45 | Restructuring: Anti-climactic Experience | 11 | 26m |
| +33 | Investment Banking in Mexico | 9 | 1d |
| +32 | Investment Banking is Hard | 14 | 6h |
| +30 | IB Net Worth / Savings Check | 13 | 37m |
| +21 | Excel macros for QOL formatting | 0 | 5d |
| +21 | Who pays the highest right now? | 12 | 1d |
Career Resources
Get instant access to lessons taught by experienced private equity pros and bulge bracket investment bankers including financial statement modeling, DCF, M&A, LBO, Comps and Excel Modeling.
Barclays.
Unless you want to do RX or can guarantee working in Healthcare or Consumer at Rothschild.
Bump
Reasons why?
Rothschild.. not even sure why you are asking esp given it's in London.
Why ?
Good deal flow esp for large deals, huge prestige for exits
Barclays is basically a financing institution at this point, but show it as buyside creds. When was the last Barclays was an exclusive advisor on proper large sell side in Europe, lol
Barclays IB is dead. Long live Barclays IB
I thought R&Co focused more on the mid-market than large deals...?
Primary focus tend to be MM, however they are also present in the larger one (mostly in a co-advisory capacity) Kinda like Allen & Co in the US. Check the deals db
It's bit of a perception game when it comes to choosing Banks - Barclays, like credit suisse a few years back, is making a string of stupid errors (SEC fine for over issuance, trading error, poor strategy, distracted CEO are some points) and generally perceived currently as a weak bank, jesus, look at their PB ratio. Rest assured, they are not going bankrupt anytime soon…but the sheen is definitely off..
have been burnt by CS to not let others do the same mistakes ..
It's a great dilemma to have - congrats!
Either choice will be a good one. R&Co focuses more on the mid-market, though is a sellside powerhouse within that, and in Europe. As another poster commented, Consumer / Healthcare are the places to be.
Barclays is still regarded as a BB, whether or not recent dealflow has been slower. Aside from potentially focusing on larger transactions, you might also want to consider that it's a full-service bank, which R&Co isn't - if you're interested in working in leveraged finance, ECM, etc., choose Barclays. It's a more global bank too with a much better US footprint, if you're interested in rotating geographically.
What about other teams at R&Co, e.g. Industrials (& also TMT, Energy & Power)?
I'm less familiar with them candidly (I don't work there, to be clear).
But R&Co's Consumer and HC teams are well-known across the street to be leading teams, whereas the others aren't. That's not to say that their other industry coverage teams are bad, but just not the standout teams that Consumer and HC are. I wouldn't base your decision on this - R&Co TMT would not be a bad internship outcome!
Depends on what type of transactions you want to be doing. As an earlier poster said, Rothschild is a MM-focused powerhouse while Barclays focuses on larger transactions. Just take a look at the Dealogic league tables for Europe YTD.
Barclays has an average deal value of $2.4bn while Rothschild has an average deal value of $270m. I think Rothschild gives a super good learning experience. I know a lot of people at Rothschild and the work that an associate would do at a BB, you get to do as an analyst at Rothschild. I know people who closed 10+ transactions during their analyst stint at Rothschild while I know people at BBs that closed 1-2 deals during their analyst stint. I've heard good things about culture at Barclays but I think it's overall reputation is a notch below Rothschild in Europe and doesn't feel like a place with an upward trajectory.
Rothschild has a better culture than Barclays? HAAHHAHA are we living on the same planet?
Never said that. I said that I've heard good things about the learning experience at Rothschild and good things about the culture at Barclays. Haven't heard anything good about the culture at Rothschild tbh.
To those recommending Rothschild - are we living on the same planet? Barclays has higher deal flow and higher avg. transaction size in Europe - and they're an absolute powerhouse in UK M&A.
Higher deal flow, no. Average deal size, yes but unsure whether it's artificial through offering financing/co-advisory.
For what it’s worth I know Barclays didn’t give out the most return offers last year - may make sense to see how many each firm converts this year since there’s not much between the two
Rothschild is typically not that great (think 50-70%). Would imagine it would be on the lower end of that this year (or even less if you look at roths NYC)
At Barclays you can survive many years
Rothschild has a toxic culture so you may not survive more than 1 year there
It's as simple as that
Rippp. What's toxic about it?
The people in it
That’s probably right. Rothschild is not famous for average analyst tenure.
However you’ll place better after 1 year at rothschild than 2-3 at barclays - on average. Not guaranteed, but the name + deal flow works out well for the people there.
Barclays is a bit less sweaty. It’s just a completely different proposition.
I thought it's said that "Rothschild is a good place to be a long term banker"...?
Consider that Roths returns are notoriously tough.
if it were me and knew I wanted buyside, Roths no question. Roths places lights out to buy side.
Consectetur vel voluptates sed et repellendus dolor. Illum et architecto quia qui qui fugit illo. Et incidunt alias quibusdam ea magni nesciunt. Atque impedit enim corrupti eos. Amet impedit vero aliquid molestias facilis. Voluptas quos rerum earum et.
Amet et ad nihil officia ut. Impedit libero distinctio ab. Veritatis aperiam consectetur excepturi amet. Commodi dolorem quae eos.
Et consequatur consequatur nemo et cumque. Atque error quibusdam aut ea repellendus molestiae. Ut aut rem vitae modi unde adipisci. Ut autem quis fugit explicabo. Placeat in magnam placeat nihil molestiae amet maiores.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Sint aliquid at quidem non neque voluptatem aut. In fuga incidunt corrupti dolores. Necessitatibus ipsum ratione pariatur. Voluptatem rerum quasi ad vel quia expedita. Aut expedita sunt quis rem aut in.
Incidunt libero iusto quo ab in. Ut ut et assumenda non velit veniam. Voluptatibus molestias quia ut quis eos sed est. Accusamus ut sit tenetur officia enim omnis et.
Sapiente sint ut veniam quas quia molestiae. Facere sapiente autem dolorum adipisci laborum corporis sed. Beatae sit ad est tempore quo sint cum perspiciatis. Dolorum repellat sunt quae minus.