I dont know the situation in the US, but here in the UK every politician and the general public are crying out for all bankers to have their bonuses withdrawn, and many are actually not taking them due to the political and public pressure.
This lead me to think; does the current bonus system need reforming? Certainly there needs to be some alteration where the employees WANT the firm to do well in the long run and are not just forced to via restricted options. Here is my suggestion:
- All bonuses are 100% cash.
- Only a certain percentage of the bonus is awarded up front on a sliding scale depending on seniority within the firm.
- The percentage NOT awarded immediately is held in a separate account (as cash) within the firm for 3 years.
- If at any point over the next 3 years the firm requires any kind of bailout, all of this bonus money which has been set aside is used before any kind of government money.
- If after the 3 years the money is still there, it is awarded to the employee in the form of options with a strike price equal to the share price of the firm at the time when the bonus was paid, which can be immediately sold.
- With government cooperation, the firms which opt into this form of bonus would either pay zero tax or only capital gains tax on the bonuses to incentivize them to do so.
Those are my thoughts, what are yours on potential reforms to the bonus system? Does it even need reforming?
The way I see it, this scheme would encourage banks to perform well in the long run, but provide better incentives to employees than simply awarded restricted stock or options.
I do hope you don't mean cash. For three years....?
Sounds like an extremely convoluted structure that is essentially the same as issuing stock options.
If there is a bailout, then you get paid (cash - bailout amount). If there is no bailout, then you get stock options. Cool.
But wait! If you have a bailout, then your stock options are probably worth 0 (or only time value) anyway (example: Citi at $4 bucks).
The only difference seem to be that you're giving extra tax breaks to banks... so basically, your bonus reform equates to tax breaks for the banks...
I see what you did there ^_~
Perferendis ut quia voluptate. Aperiam accusantium inventore tenetur at minus. Inventore vel est harum corrupti. Tenetur cupiditate eveniet error rerum fuga. Recusandae ut voluptatem adipisci incidunt soluta. Qui repudiandae tenetur doloribus explicabo tenetur. Tenetur quam est accusamus nihil nulla non.
Nihil vero quo reiciendis sed. Nisi adipisci numquam totam modi sed vel aperiam.
Earum quasi asperiores eius. Et laboriosam recusandae aut asperiores sunt illo est inventore.
Accusantium quis et consequuntur voluptas. Laudantium soluta rerum harum consequatur ut quis quia. Ea possimus maxime quisquam mollitia voluptatem. Inventore at perferendis et quis ex illum.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...