Good school, poor placement

Hey guys, just wondering what you think are the major reasons why "good" schools end up having poor recruiting at BB's. I'm wondering about Washington University in particular. The biggest reason I can think of is location, but plenty of other top companies fly their interviewers out to Missouri, and I can't imagine time is that much more valuable at the BBs. In addition, does anyone know how to open up an OCR relationship with these companies?

 

Oh dear. Allow me to fill you in. Nobody in the bulge bracket wants to hire you. Why? Because you come from a Tier 2, possibly Tier 3, school. This might be a little out of your league, but think of it like this. The bank is investing in human capital (assets). Graduating Ivy means the College Board and our Venerable Institutions have given us Triple A ratings, so to speak. We are safe to hire, and look good on the balance sheet to investors.

However, if our banks were to put somebody like yourself on payroll, we would just be bleeding prestige. Kind of like buying BBB-, not only is it not recommended, it just simply should not be done.

As my Managing Director likes to say, "If it is not Ivy, do not hire it."

Try commercial banking. I hear they're hiring tellers in Nebraska.

 
buysideforlife:
Oh dear. Allow me to fill you in. Nobody in the bulge bracket wants to hire you. Why? Because you come from a Tier 2, possibly Tier 3, school. This might be a little out of your league, but think of it like this. The bank is investing in human capital (assets). Graduating Ivy means the College Board and our Venerable Institutions have given us Triple A ratings, so to speak. We are safe to hire, and look good on the balance sheet to investors.

However, if our banks were to put somebody like yourself on payroll, we would just be bleeding prestige. Kind of like buying BBB-, not only is it not recommended, it just simply should not be done.

As my Managing Director likes to say, "If it is not Ivy, do not hire it."

Try commercial banking. I hear they're hiring tellers in Nebraska.

Wow.

 
Best Response
buysideforlife:
Oh dear. Allow me to fill you in. Nobody in the bulge bracket wants to hire you. Why? Because you come from a Tier 2, possibly Tier 3, school. This might be a little out of your league, but think of it like this. The bank is investing in human capital (assets). Graduating Ivy means the College Board and our Venerable Institutions have given us Triple A ratings, so to speak. We are safe to hire, and look good on the balance sheet to investors.

However, if our banks were to put somebody like yourself on payroll, we would just be bleeding prestige. Kind of like buying BBB-, not only is it not recommended, it just simply should not be done.

As my Managing Director likes to say, "If it is not Ivy, do not hire it."

Try commercial banking. I hear they're hiring tellers in Nebraska.

HAHA! Douche much?

Fuckin' prick.

 

buysideforlife is just angry about the fact that he's getting his NYU behind kicked by Midwestern school kids at work. Or maybe he doesn't have a job yet and is getting nervous that "his MD" is now some kid from Baruch's MD. Don't worry about him.

Wash. U is a great school and gets great placements on the street. One of the problems is that it's not as easy to get to as a 15 minute cab ride to Columbia. Were Columbia moved to Columbia, MO, Wash U would be kicking Columbia's butt in placements.

In all honesty, there's a higher bar for calling kids back for on-site interviews from the Midwest and many schools on the West coast. It's a long, $700 trip that is expensive for the firm. Where you'd get a callback from Columbia or NYU pretty easy because it's a $10 cab ride, the firm is going to be a lot pickier about on-site interviews. For a few schools out west, they will sometimes send higher ranking folks out to interview who'd normally be second-round interviewers.

Look, worst comes to worst, you've got a lot of trading firms in Chicago and Edward Jones in St. Louis. I wouldn't worry all that much. In the long run, if you're smart enough to get into Wash U, you're smart enough to get into most of the Ivies. Wash U might be setting you back a year or two if you REALLY want to work for an investment bank, but in the long-run, it really doesn't matter all that much. Go get a job at Citadel and laugh at all of us suckers stuck here in NYC. :D

Also, WashU is too far from major U.S. financial cities. Chicago hires out of NU, UC, Notre Dame, Michigan, Illinois, and IU. Network hard, man
Regardless, Wash U has a reputation on par with the University of Chicago throughout most of the Midwest. It's a five-hour drive. In the phone or on-site interviews, I'd recommend mentioning that you have a car and friends in Chicago (AKA, you either have friends there or are willing to pay for a hotel room) if you can casually work it in.

Start submitting your resumes at EJ, Getco, Citadel, Northern Trust, Jump, Sun, BP, and the Chicago branches of the banks (as well as doing an app to the NYC banks). Somebody will want to take you.

 

The above post is ridiculous.

But to answer your question, even at top schools (e.g. ivy league) it is PRETTY DAMN HARD to get a BB offer. Even if you do manage the semi-firm 3.5 cutoff, you're still only have about a 1 in 20 chance of getting any particular FO BB offer. Of course you will apply to them all- after which I would say you have maybe a 25% chance of getting any FO BB offer.

I went to Penn, which has huge OCR BB presence- but even there there are plenty of good kids that dont get BB offers. Just too many people want it and everybody's major (in theory) qualifies.

The average student at Penn however has a GPA around 3.2. And if you take all the people at Penn who are interested in BB offers- I would say less than 10% actually have one by the time they graduate.

 

if you're good enough, you can make it any where. those kids at ivy's who didn't manage a bb gig weren't good enough in comparison to their peers.

people who have bb gigs and have low self esteem may wanna think like buysideforlife...

it's really all about how you perform in comparison to your peers. i've seen kids from random colleges in wyoming at gs ibd.

in all honesty, don't see alotta wash u kids on the street. but it doesn't mean you can't make it. fuck what they say, and just shoot for the sky

 
LeggoMyGekko:
fuck what they say, and just shoot for the sky
correct correct correct correct correct correct correct correct correct correct correct correct correct
 

what's with all the wash u hate. i think it's a good school. very small, selective undergrad. shouldn't be a problem getting a good gig if you put in the work, even if you don't see many people on the street from this school.

 
WUnderful:
does anyone know how to open up an OCR relationship with these companies?

very interested in this as well. i'm assuming OP meant establishing the OCR relationship with these companies on the school's behalf...

 

I'm not gonna lie I hate it when people say you have a "1 in 20" or "1 in 100" or whatever chance. You don't have a 1 in whatever chance. You most likely are going to be 1 of 10 people accepted out of 200 or 1,000 or whatever applicants, so you have to be out a couple hundred, or in some cases 990 other people.

Sorry, just had to throw in my .02 bout that.

"You stop being an asshole when it sucks to be you." -IlliniProgrammer "Your grammar made me wish I'd been aborted." -happypantsmcgee
 

As the graduate of a completely regional private school nowhere near as good as WashU, I can say that I knew about 10 kids my year that got BB offers, which proportionate to its size is very strong. Then again, it is located in a much more economically prominent city (v. St Louis.)...and state.

Oh, and buysideforlife, just a tip junior, what with all this "my MD" and "our banks" talk... IB is the sell side. Just thought you should know. Have a super summer buddy!

 
  • buysideforlife, get with it. IF you have an MD and IF he's an ivy league grad, there's a) no way he'd ever utter such garbage ('it'?) and b) he'd hate on every school that wasn't his IVY, not just the non-Ivies. So GFY jerkoff.

  • There are plenty of WUSL grads around. There are more IVY grads, for sure, but that WUSL guys get there from time to time. As you said, the distance doesn't help and the fact there there are fewer alums at BBs means fewer people willing to make the trip.

 

wash u is a great school but it is not ivy level/duke level/stanford level, yes US news inflates its rankings so people think its as good as cornell/columbia but it is more on the level of emory, vanderbilt. still a great school with fun kids

 

As you will hear EVERYONE else on hear tell you, the key to getting an internship or FT offer (if you weren't an SA) is NETWORKING. Whether you are from an ivy or WUSTL, networking will play a huge role. Yes, WashU is in St. Louis, and yes, it is not a "target", but networking and perseverance will more than make up for this, especially with a good GPA and genuine interest. You cannot solely count on WUSTL's career center, especially with its relatively poor track record of placement into IB. You most definitely can break into whatever you want from the school, it is just going to take a lot of hard work and networking. When it all comes down to it, what YOU need to do isn't that much different from what you'd need to do were you to graduate from the Ivies or Stanford etc..., work your ass off and network. The difference is that for you, it all comes down to and starts with TAKING INITIATIVE, since OCR is pretty much a joke.

 
drexelalum11:
WUSL is not seen as particularly good outside of the insular world of college guides, but that doesn't mean you can't get a decent job out of there. You'll definitely have alumni on the street; use them. Crank out a 4.0 every semester, get some relevant work experience, learn to smile, and you'll be fine.

Really? Wash U OCR that bad? I always thought it was a decent school. Never visited there and only know one guy who went there. I know they have a stellar Medical Program and I had believed a decent Undergrad B-school program.

How well does it place in Consulting, F500, etc.? What is the school good for and why does it have such high US News Rankings? What about placement into Southern regional IB/Consulting locations? Is it because it's in St. Louis, Missouri?

----------------------------------------------------------------- Hug It Out
 
Ari_Gold:
drexelalum11:
WUSL is not seen as particularly good outside of the insular world of college guides, but that doesn't mean you can't get a decent job out of there. You'll definitely have alumni on the street; use them. Crank out a 4.0 every semester, get some relevant work experience, learn to smile, and you'll be fine.

Really? Wash U OCR that bad? I always thought it was a decent school. Never visited there and only know one guy who went there. I know they have a stellar Medical Program and I had believed a decent Undergrad B-school program.

How well does it place in Consulting, F500, etc.? What is the school good for and why does it have such high US News Rankings? What about placement into Southern regional IB/Consulting locations? Is it because it's in St. Louis, Missouri?

I have no idea what WUSL OCR is like. I'd imagine it's not that great, mostly because of its location, but that's been touched on above. I was speaking to what I know of its general reputation and quality; its good, but not nearly as good as college guides would suggest. I remember when I was looking at colleges, there were guides that put it on par with Amherst & Pomona, which it isn't. I suppose I should've been clearer - I'm not saying WUSL isn't a good school, I'm just saying it's not as great as the hype might imply.

 

No offense, but I don't consider WashU to be a target school for banking. I remember interviewing for a summer associate position with an accounting firm, and the guy who sat next to me was a WashU MBA interviewing for the same internship. I'm an undergrad btw...

Also, WashU is too far from major U.S. financial cities. Chicago hires out of NU, UC, Notre Dame, Michigan, Illinois, and IU. Network hard, man

 

LMAO that was great. I could grow to like this troll.

"You stop being an asshole when it sucks to be you." -IlliniProgrammer "Your grammar made me wish I'd been aborted." -happypantsmcgee
 

WashU is a pretty good school, especially for medicine as someone mentioned earlier. There has been some strong research coming out of there as well. However, I have never seen anyone from there on the street, so placements must be pretty weak. My thoughts would be that someone at that school would have to do a lot of hustling themselves (especially considering that there isn't much of an alumni base to draw upon) but they would still have a leg up on other non-target kids.

 

" In the long run, if you're smart enough to get into Wash U, you're smart enough to get into most of the Ivies."

I like Wash U. A lot of my friends go there and they're smart but they did not get into Ivy league schools. It is overranked by US News (it should be 20-30) but it is still a good school, but to compare it to Ivies, Williams/Amherst or UChicago is unfair

 
ricochetX:
" In the long run, if you're smart enough to get into Wash U, you're smart enough to get into most of the Ivies."

I like Wash U. A lot of my friends go there and they're smart but they did not get into Ivy league schools. It is overranked by US News (it should be 20-30) but it is still a good school, but to compare it to Ivies, Williams/Amherst or UChicago is unfair

I dunno. The WashU kids where I worked for my first two years were pretty smart guys. One of them made it onto a team of quants- 80% of them having partial or complete PhDs- straight out of undergrad. Wash U has a strong reputation in Chicago, and the people I know from Wash U were as smart- or maybe even a little smarter than the kids I knew from the Ivies.

This sort of reinforced my view that Wash U was just as good as the East Coast target schools but recruiters set a higher bar for candidates from schools that are harder to get to.

 

Ok, so Wash U is the classic non-target with a few smart alumni on the street to network with. But how do non-targets become targets? Assuming that Wash U is smart enough (maybe not valid, but I'm making it), is the location enough of a deterrent that BBs won't ever recruit here? Certainly there is some point where the students become smart enough to justify the travel costs. Anyway, thanks for all of your advice. Sadly, though the trolls take it too far, their points are semi-valid. I believe that top students at Wash U can compete with the top students from any school, but sadly Wash U lacks the prestige, as well as the high-caliber general population of other schools.

 

Eum quia maxime est pariatur nam autem. Voluptatem et unde rerum ut et et dicta. Tempora eveniet cupiditate adipisci aut. Incidunt dignissimos et accusamus eaque.

Sapiente modi dolore est. Incidunt ut corporis sint quos ea at. Rerum occaecati et qui rem sit occaecati sit facere. Sapiente soluta quos beatae. Occaecati assumenda et ipsam. Dolor explicabo iusto dolores. Reprehenderit mollitia cumque fuga ut a quia possimus dolorum.

Career Advancement Opportunities

May 2024 Investment Banking

  • Jefferies & Company 02 99.4%
  • Goldman Sachs 19 98.8%
  • Harris Williams & Co. New 98.3%
  • Lazard Freres 02 97.7%
  • JPMorgan Chase 04 97.1%

Overall Employee Satisfaction

May 2024 Investment Banking

  • Harris Williams & Co. 18 99.4%
  • JPMorgan Chase 10 98.8%
  • Lazard Freres 05 98.3%
  • Morgan Stanley 07 97.7%
  • William Blair 03 97.1%

Professional Growth Opportunities

May 2024 Investment Banking

  • Lazard Freres 01 99.4%
  • Jefferies & Company 02 98.8%
  • Goldman Sachs 17 98.3%
  • Moelis & Company 07 97.7%
  • JPMorgan Chase 05 97.1%

Total Avg Compensation

May 2024 Investment Banking

  • Director/MD (5) $648
  • Vice President (20) $385
  • Associates (89) $259
  • 3rd+ Year Analyst (14) $181
  • Intern/Summer Associate (33) $170
  • 2nd Year Analyst (67) $168
  • 1st Year Analyst (205) $159
  • Intern/Summer Analyst (146) $101
notes
16 IB Interviews Notes

“... there’s no excuse to not take advantage of the resources out there available to you. Best value for your $ are the...”

Leaderboard

1
redever's picture
redever
99.2
2
Betsy Massar's picture
Betsy Massar
99.0
3
Secyh62's picture
Secyh62
99.0
4
BankonBanking's picture
BankonBanking
99.0
5
dosk17's picture
dosk17
98.9
6
GameTheory's picture
GameTheory
98.9
7
kanon's picture
kanon
98.9
8
CompBanker's picture
CompBanker
98.9
9
bolo up's picture
bolo up
98.8
10
numi's picture
numi
98.8
success
From 10 rejections to 1 dream investment banking internship

“... I believe it was the single biggest reason why I ended up with an offer...”