Supercar and an associate?
Love cars so much. I told myself I was going to wait until at least As4+ (Am currently An3), but I found a great Porsche 911 deal from a school alum. It’s barely used and would run around $200k. I got a special rate from my bank for 4% financing vs like 4.6% I think?
I have about $100k in savings and really want this car. I’m in RX and feel like it may look bad if I wanna stay long term (as I do) as I am making a potentially financially poor decision as a person wanting to advice CEOs who made financially poor decisions. Please talk me into doing it
might have to RX your assets when the car bubble pops
100k in savings. 200k car. Can't see how this wouldn't be a great decision.
Recession is coming. This RX bro is about to slay.
technically:
Assets: $100k cash
Equity: $100k
Subsequently:
Assets: $200k car
Liability: $100k debt
Equity: $100k
THEN we can start modelling out the impact on the 3 statements of the increased maintenance costs, the depreciation, the interest costs, the potential impact from loss of clients etc.
Gotta say, were going to be looking at a good RX situation. should be fun!
Not enough savings to justify the vehicle at this time.
Even if that wasnt that case: I’d look at it this way, auction prices(car & watches) have been falling/slowing for the past 6 months, so this ‘deal’ may not look like that great of a deal in 6 more months. You may be able to get it at a better price. If its a long term collectible in your mind, I think its important to think whats really going to be a long term collectible in the Porsche market, they’re not exactly rare. To say nothing of the costs of insuring, storing, maintaining a car to collector standards.
No one knows what the future holds but I’m also holding off on my next watch and car purchase for a while. Many of us have been had modest losses in the market the past 7 months.. lots of cars and watches may start showing up if the market/economy/supply chain shits itself in the coming quarters.
I feel like top ICE (internal combustion engine) cars are going to become a long-term collectible over the next 20 years more so than any time in history prior given that major manufacturers including great brands like Mercades Benz have announced all electric by 2030. Many brands like Porsche are trying to get exemptions to the European Union’s 2035 ICE ban. Porsche probably can I would think. I guarantee you by 2035, electric vehicles will outperform ICE vehicles, but the driving experience might not be the same. Porsche specifically wants the 911 to continue as ICE because they can’t achieve the same weight distribution right now with the current electric technology. I think that could change by 2035, but I’m not an engineer. Regardless, I think a lot of ICE cars will become collectible.
I'd do only if my parents were loaded and my inheritance juicy. If you need to build substantial wealth on your own not a good idea at all to lock most of your networth in a depreciating asset. Also what 911 is this? 200k must be a turbo S lmao. That's crazy.
Has to be a turbo s.
Yeah that has to be a turbo s. Why not settle for a c8 or 911 carerra (4)s to settle the itch? Even an r8. Save 60-100k and still have a supercar.
Agreed. The only way I would say do it if it was like 3/2rs or smth like a 22 touring otherwise ur money is better spent somewhere else. That’s also assuming you would flip right away and get the 60-70k after tax. But then again no one is offering those sorts of cars at that price point, not even turbo s unless it’s an allocation which u could also sell.
C8 and Carerra 4S dont hold a candle to the Tubro S. Source: been in all three
A new turbo s is going for far far more than 200k. Like 75% more (and over list). 200k will get you into a well specced 992 carrera gts at the moment (which is also over msrp). but the market is saturated and prices are coming down now across the board for sports cars
You could easily get a new turbo s under $275
OP didn't say it was a new model year Porsche. Also the Turbo S has notoriously bad depreciation especially compared to the GT3. Vintage 911s are the closest to being "investable"
As1 here with a .1 GT3RS. The answer here is very dependent on what car you’re buying here. Is it a 992 GT3, 991.2 GT3RS, or a 992 Turbo S? Any one of these three is a great buy at that price and you should totally do it. Your interest rates seem a little high but I got mine back in Jan of this year and so I’m paying half that. Try a credit union and see if you can get lower.
I had a bit more savings than you do now when I bought mine, but you can actually comfortably afford a car of this level if you are smart about it. I bought mine low (relative to the market), put down $50K and took the rest out on a loan in the mid 2’s. The car will never depreciate below what I have already put down. I drive it solely on weekends which minimizes added mileage. The monthly payment does not matter because I have enough cash to cover the loan remainder already, I just invest the rest of my savings. Insurance and maintenance have also been surprisingly low. My only regret is not having gotten a car like this sooner. I’ve always been a car guy and a huge motivator for me to work hard and get a great job has always so I can afford a nice ride. With the ICE being a dying breed, I wanted to have no regrets 10-20 years down the road if I’ve never had the chance to own my dream car. If this resonates with you, by all means I would jump to buy it.
That's awesome to be able to afford your dream car just 4-5 years out of college! Do you drive it to the office or save it for weekends, and do you know if you plan to keep it in the long run or upgrade later?
It really is! I do not drive it into the office. The GT3RS isn't a great daily car - it's loud, there's very little sound deadening, even with the front axle lift it sits very low. We're WFH 2 days a week and with a short commute, I just drive a cheap beater although I could probably get away with only Uber.
In regards to upgrading, I love mine and I don't have any plans at the moment to change cars. I've been keeping my eye out for a 992 GT3 but current valuations are still too inflated. I will likely stay with Porsche GT products. They suit my personal preferences being a little more driver-focused/engaging and slightly less flashy than your typical Italian competitor. Although the cool thing about buying an expensive car with low depreciation is you can keep trading it for other expensive cars and only pay tax on the trade-in difference. So you could actually switch into a new supercar every year at a pretty reasonable cost.
One other thing I might add is the car has opened a completely new world of friends and opportunities for me. With it I've met many similarly minded and successful folks in the car community in a wide range of professions. It's an utter joy to hang out, eat lunch, and go drive around town with buddies in their supercars.
I daily a 991.2, bought as an As2. Absolutely go for it, it's been an incredible amount of fun. Im out most weekends to hit the mountains or some PCA meetups/tours, truly exhilarating experiences and I'm so thankful I pulled the trigger on the purchase.
I've personally gone light on housing (studio) and my fixed expenses are at or below other associates who have more typical cars but more living space. I just get more enjoyment from the car than I would from an extra wall or two in an apartment. This isn't really necessary (you can do both and it won't really matter that much) but just some background on how I've thought through it.
OR:
1. Invest the 100k in a dead index-fund
2. Gain an average of 8% returns
3. At year 50, your 100k is worth roughly 4.6 million.
Alternative cost is brutal when you can't afford it in the first place. EDIT: this is basically buying a depreciation thing WHILE paying interest expenses vs earning potentially millions.
Well gee people must be idiots for spending hundreds of dollars on fine dining--everything turns into shit anyways so might as well just eat grass and invest that money into a "dead index-fund" especially since food depreciates in a matter of seconds
Better yet, why bother renting a condo in the city when you could just live out of a shopping cart and have a 5 minute commute to work--you could take your savings of thousands every month to buy bitcoin and become a trillionaire in a thousand years!
This guy has single handedly cracked the secret to life--take ALL your money and just put it in index funds and let it accumulate until the end of time
Everyone dies - people quickly point out the immense compounded returns you'll have at 40, 50, 60, 70, etc. There is value in being able to spend or experience some of these things when you're young and in your prime years for travel and experiences. Being able to go to a track with my dad (a huge reason I'm a car guy) in a 911.2 and experience something with him that I might not be able to in 30-35 years when he's dead and gone is valuable to me.
Why do people spend hundreds on dinners or thousands on vacations, etc.? They could just be investing everything, and at 60-70, they'll have millions of dollars, right? It's because at some point actually having these experiences when you're young with people you love who might not be there down the line, whether that be a girlfriend who at the time you love who you break up with or a family member who's always wanted to do X who might pass away by the time you reach your fortune.
If this person is a car guy who spends most of his free time on a track, at car meets, or watching car videos just dreaming about the day he will be able to drive one of these cars, that is the kind of person who should be thinking about this decision. If there is a chef who's spent 5-6 years mastering his craft, hoping one day to learn from the master's and has the opportunity to travel to Japan to learn from a master sushi chef for two months and he highly values this experience, having it a few to dozens of years earlier is valuable; there is more to it than just a $ amount for some people. Just always be aware of the opportunity cost but don't let people telling you to put 100K away and let it sit in a fund for 40 years make you sound stupid for wanting to experience your dreams.
I'd say 75% of car guys would advocate for this while 25% would be more cautious, but 95% of non-car guys will be more cautious - it just isn't worth it to them. Is it worth it to you given the opportunity cost?
As an HF analyst, I'm pretty frugal in general but when it comes to things like vacations I'm not one to be cheap. My dad always wanted to go to an F1 race in Europe so I took him there few weeks ago. He's getting older and I'm not sure he'll be here any longer so worth the sum I spent.
old boss was a Founder/MD with a net worth in excess of 10m, he drove a 10+ year old honda because depreciation lmao. Personally though for OP, if the car is a life long dream then go for it. Gotta risk it for the biscuit
Ngl while OP is making a terrible financial decision, I wouldn't want to wait until 50 to buy a car like this as someone else who loves cars. I really want a Tesla Roadster. Got to launch a Model S at a track, and it was the coolest thing ever.
Do it. You won’t even care about or eventually remember the money you spent/opportunity cost. YOLO, and as other people have pointed out, EV mandates are coming. As someone who had an E55 AMG and X5 M in their twenties with minimal savings, and years later still whipping the vintage mustang that’s been in my family for close to 60 years, you will wish you had done it sooner. Others noted it but if you’re smart with maintenance, mileage, and generally take care of the car, annual cost doesn’t have to be insane. It doesn’t make sense for me right now with kids but I will have a 911 (tbd on which one) once I can get away with less seats. If regulations really get out of control and it’s all EV sooner than people expect, there will be a rush for these vehicles. Guess I’ll be installing lifts in the garage.
I’ll loan you the money for 3.8% interest and a 4% origination fee
User name checks out . . .
Dude you are talking about having 200% of your net worth in a fucking car—are you nuts?
I'm a huge car and specifically Porsche guy myself; in my opinion having a car that's 20%, never mind 200%, of your net worth is aggressive
Yeah, 20% of annual income is a general rule of thumb lol
Am not a car guy at all (even if I admire nice cars).
Honestly, in your shoes, if I were passionate about this, I would do it. Your savings right now don't matter that much. What matters is that you are on a solid career path and that you make sure you keep motivated so your value can increase exponentially over next years. It's important to have fun outside of work and it's great to be able to afford "childhood dreams". You have one life, go live it champ!
It’s “advise.”
Fuck it man
Just live in the office and ball out w/ the whip
Thoughts @ GoingToBeAnMD?
Once. You buy it, I shall see you on the roadstr app.
Yeah and post pics here guys please - I love super cars too.
Sadly, this app makes it difficult to post car pics.
YOLO. You're going to be making more money in the future and this purchase will just be a blip to you, assuming things work out. You should go ahead a buy that car.
LTPHKT
Listen
To
Pizz
He
Knows
Things
Damn, now I don’t feel so bad about springing for premium economy for my flight to Barcelona last month
lol
thebrofessor
Curious to hear your thoughts on OP’s situation.
My answer to all of these questions is a question: does it take away from your other financial goals? If yes, then pause. If no, then ask if you want it versus other available alternatives, and if yes buy it and don't look back. If you're unsure because you don't have goals, fix that first.
I've toyed with the idea of a Porsche because I love the engineering but practically speaking I'd be driving it in traffic only and on weekends, a better opportunity for a joyride in theory, I like to go to the beach and there's no room for surfboards there, so I've instead favored driving experiences. Plus, I'm a big believer in keeping fixed costs low and paying for experiences
Same
Do what you want. I bought an R8 as an Associate. Daily drove it for 2 years. To the office, on road trips, went on car rallies. Put 35k miles on it. It was great.
I'd say if $100k is all you have in savings, wait until you get into PE or something after IB (out of the city) and then spend the $. Prices are crazy right now, it's not worth it. I would not buy a car in this market (used or new). See how you feel in a year. And by then, you might be able to get something better than a Porsche. Or you might not want one at all.
I'm all for the "you're only young once" which is why I got mine. But a lot of things fell right for me to justify it - it's not just "I have $100k and want an exotic car". You have to get parking. Insurance, tolls are a bitch (if you're in NYC) not to mention the traffic - that takes a lot of the fun out of it. With a loan, you're looking at $1,500 - $2,000 / month just in parking / payments. It's like having two apartments. I was single too, so that helped. But it wears off, quick too. It does pay to wait. But do what you want.
V8 or V10 R8?
AN2 here - Was fortunate enough to have padded enough savings young to chase and buy a 718 Spyder. I’m not sure at $200k it would be good choice right now to go for 992 (assuming this is either a highly highly optioned C4S or GTS) but could be worth holding off here a bit. Maybe go for a CS? I was previously in market for a 992 C4S given commute and car enthusiast needs but settled for an albeit “cheaper” Spyder that is equally as fun and daily driveable as a 991. However, with the path the ICE is headed I wouldn’t blame you if you jumped the gun here for a good time…if it bothers you enough to worry about what the office feels, client sees and probably how your wallet will react definitely reconsider/wait.
I will say though…no car quite feels the same after getting into and driving a Porsche sports car…if you do go for it I’d be happy for ya!
Lease something
Lol wtf is this a troll post? 100k savings and wants to buy a 200k car?? Jesus…
Even with my username this amount of expenditure on a car versus your net worth makes me a little nervous. No doubt the car will hold value and even potentially appreciate, but it would still make me stressed about my financial situation. You never know what could happen to you one day and you not be able to work or generate income. I suppose if you come from a wealthy family or have a safety net then that's a moot point.
Fuck it go all out, buy a few chains, rent some bitches, and buy out the bar. You only live once. Send your MD some hoes too, if he likes it you're in good with him for life, if not then it will make a good story.
I’m kinda in the same boat but a few years younger. I’ve set the same target for a Ferrari F430. I’ve loved the car as long as I’ve been into cars. I cover automotive and I just love cars. To me they’re art. I’d say go for it if you can afford it. However, make sure you’ll use it and can afford maintenance, insurance, etc. If I can lease hack an apartment in the next year or so, then I will do it as my costs will be lower and I could put my rent money into the car payment.
Thoughts on a recently minted second year analyst buying a BMW M3 F80 or G80? Should be getting first year bonus soon...
"You can live in your car, but you can't drive your house."
-Aristotle
$200k is completely ludicrous in your situation, IMO. If the car was $50k... even $70k... which you can definitely find a used 911 at that price point... I would say fine, do it if that's your one splurge. Wiping out your entire savings AND having a $100k car loan with 4% interest is not a good idea
People generally don't care about what cars you drive, you won't get a second glance showing up in a 2022 regular Porsche, but a $200k car is ridiculous unless you're a successful D/MD and people will question you a bit
Get a used model and revisit this when you have the entire purchase price liquid and aren't RXing yourself to afford the monthly payment
Dude 200K for a 911, as others have plentifully covered as to why it's so absurd, is absolutely asinine. A good friend of mine just ordered a 2022 911 like last week which he has to wait 12-18 months for but was able to pay MSRP instead of inflated dealership prices, only paid 120K and that too because it was so spec'd out. Your buy-in price is absolutely ridiculous and unless (again as stated above but I gotta chime in) it's a GT3 or a Turbo / any of the Turbo variations, there is no reason you should be paying 200K for a 911 ever.
Just buy a 996 Turbo, or 997 turbo, or even cooler 964 Turbo. Save you a lot of money, and will actually appreciate in the short term.
Fast forward 6-9 months and OP will have a new thread asking if anyone has put their car up for rent on Turo.
Right now I am struggling to decide between a 991.2 and a 992.1 4S or turbo s. This is a difficult decision to make. 992, offerings for the interior not much in the offering. Axel lift good, colors not much....
Repudiandae qui corporis placeat repellendus facere placeat. Repudiandae molestias ut amet aspernatur. Quo velit quis similique reiciendis illo aspernatur facere. Aspernatur modi animi ut fugit. Sed et delectus qui natus et.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Accusamus voluptatum labore corporis occaecati qui dicta nobis quo. Culpa dolorum vel qui nobis fugiat. Esse consequatur molestiae adipisci sit illum.
Fugiat et voluptas voluptas. Molestiae reiciendis blanditiis voluptatum delectus non. Illum modi adipisci dignissimos.
Necessitatibus quae sunt itaque dolorem et quaerat. Et iste est eligendi qui quis et nihil. Qui rerum eos dignissimos quae quo.
Cupiditate et quia sint commodi. At molestiae dolore qui. Vel velit explicabo velit dolore facere.
Aliquam rerum qui voluptatem minima. Quia fuga sapiente delectus autem.
Reprehenderit quis illo consectetur. Atque vel repellendus assumenda beatae optio. Repudiandae velit recusandae officia rerum et.
Tenetur sapiente et corrupti itaque est laborum molestiae laudantium. Eveniet quam quia placeat aut. Enim laborum omnis a.
Ducimus tempora deserunt aut hic. Qui ea rerum temporibus odit et. Architecto et omnis voluptate. Dolores necessitatibus tempora incidunt magnam consequatur.
Accusamus itaque voluptatem facilis magni ipsum est. Sed tenetur qui dolores eligendi non sit. Voluptatem quibusdam modi quia accusamus nobis. Porro ea fuga sed enim consequuntur voluptatem.