On-cycle as a second year
Will be a second year this July and was wondering how it looks to firms and headhunters doing on-cycle for 2026. Did not participate in 2025 on-cycle. Wanted to hear thoughts from people who have done it / if it lowers your chances. Thanks!
following
Bump
You’re actually better off (assuming you genuinely didn’t recruit as a first year). You’ll be notably more polished and have more experience to discuss than a first year weeks out of college (AKA you’ll be a differentiated candidate with potential to place better). Plus, ideally you’ll have a better sense of what you’re looking for having spent 12 months on the desk.
Good luck. I’d say you were smart to wait as it’s really hard for folks like me to discern the quality of a bunch of brand new first years.
Edit - if you dipped your toe in first year and just didn’t place, my feedback would be different as you may appear as more “damaged goods” but doesn’t sound like the case here.
For the “recruiting as a first year” point do you mean recruiting on-cycle or off cycle as a first year?
Doesn’t really matter (lines are blurring). I just mean as long as you didn’t strike out at a bunch of late stage interviews as an A1, you’re fine.
How would your advice change if someone didn't place as a first year?
In that case, I would be ready with a coherent story around why things didn't work out (e.g., wasn't adequately prepared, realized I'm looking for a different sector/geo/fund size, took a few first rounds but opted not to move forward, struggled with model tests but did XYZ to improve my skillset, etc.).
While you don't want to come off as defensive, you should expect that interviews may ask if you recruited previously, and it's best to be prepared with rationale on why you're still a strong candidate despite not previously placing.
Bump any additonal thoughts?
I know this is an old thread but in case anyone reads this, I wanted to confirm that it indeed is possible to pursue on-cycle as a 2nd yr and stay 1 additional year in banking?
I received some conflicting info over the past days that on-cycle is only for 1st yr analysts, so I was hoping to get some more color on the matter. Thank you!
Bump
Possimus dignissimos esse omnis dolor aut molestiae. Et beatae eveniet optio optio. Sint nemo quidem minus nesciunt quo vero maiores.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...