Want to get a quick discussion here. I don’t have these offers but I’m genuinely curious as to what you guys would choose, and think it could help some people on this forum.
Let’s say you have two job offers from the same brokerage company (think HFF\JLL\CBRE) for :
A: One of the top broker teams in the country. Easily top ten more likely top five within their specialty (not retail)
B: Underwriting. You work with a number of teams, and aren’t specific to one team and one specialty.
What would you choose? Would you generalize and take the underwriting position? Or would you specialize with the team?
it seems like you wont be pigeonholed with either option here. I would with option A as you will likely meet more people and have the opportunity to form your own connections.
Sounds like we are thinking along the same lines. I think the connections from the broker team would be more abundant than the underwriting group. I was just unsure if specializing in that group could pigeonhole that analyst.
The 1st one. If you are at the Firm I think you are at, those Underwriting specialist jobs are typically a way to break in to eventually get onto someone's team. You can skip that step with the options you laid out here. The main thing you would be missing out on is not being on someone's team and potentially joining a team with a better fit.
Just my 2 cents.
I'm pretty sure with that distinction you know the firm that I am talking about. I see. I didn't know that people usually use the underwriting jobs to lateral to a broker team. Could you see the interviews being the same for the broker team vs underwriting? Or do you see the broker team using more of a modeling interview?
The Brokers team would definitely be more about fit/ Connections to their team.
I have seen people take these underwriting at a particular shop to lateral on Investment Sales teams (Rarely leave to PE) but not typically other types of brokerage because that is who would be using them the most. You will gain good exposure to Brokers, Deals, underwriting there and if you do good work you can pretty much let your work do the talking when you want to move onto a specific team.
But hey I also know of people who stayed in the underwriting/financial consulting side for a long time. They typically end up with pretty big salaries but they don't really feel any deal impact (Bonuses) on their take home pay but also aren't 1099 like brokers so they get retirement benefits ect.
Thank you for the overview. This is exactly what I was looking for. It seems as though you can’t go wrong with either job, but making it directly to a broker team is a plus for your network, and skips the step of having to network in from underwriting
Here is the breakdown for future job prospects.
Big Broker(I'm guessing C&W) you will be "pigeonholed" but you will interface directly with your counterparts at buy side shops, so when the time comes to switch you will already know people.
HFF/Underwriter - You will be in an analyst pool, but it is a great brand name to have to a lesser extend the same opportunities as above.
Corrupti id eum nulla ut harum consequatur iusto. Dolores consequatur vel id quia. Nihil ut omnis eos voluptas. Ea amet molestias vel numquam quos dolores.
Cum labore vero eligendi sunt nisi inventore ipsam nobis. Quis et nisi nisi eum. Sequi amet ut architecto aut voluptas vitae et minus. Praesentium voluptatem quis ad perferendis voluptas deserunt aut. Doloribus asperiores quod et mollitia. Voluptatem similique ullam eos consequatur nam ab tempora.
Ipsum debitis dolorem omnis id. Possimus quo labore totam corporis aut. Minus ab minus repellendus amet. Libero ullam quos eum beatae assumenda. Dicta quia quae qui eveniet odit. Quaerat corporis ea sunt soluta dolorem.
Ut rerum accusantium corrupti ducimus. Officia vero adipisci aut amet quas ut. Iste tempore tempora non consequatur. In ut similique porro. Sed odio libero veniam. Occaecati architecto illum sapiente ullam iure voluptatem.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...