Is RE cooked for the medium term? Feels like it
Capital allocations are down massively to the sector. Nobody has cleared a pref since 2021, and leverage basically isn’t accretive on anything you’d actually want to own. Development risk feels enormous given lack of viability of costs and the environment you’ll be delivering in. The bid ask was narrowing in Q1, but the Iran conflict has totally derailed what felt like the start of a recovery. Op funds are deploying in DC/ without any real conviction on liquidity mechanisms / next buyer (feels like a bubble). Office and retail as investable sectors are a fraction as big as they were 7 yrs ago. Are we all just expected to buy sheds and price in 3% rental growth forever? It feels like it’s become a game of AUM aggregation - but the reality is, some of the largest managers are running funds that are currently marked at inside 5% / 1.1x. Where is the light at the end of the tunnel?!
Welcome to the cycle! Could be 1 year. Could be 5. Just gotta ride it out. I wouldn’t be surprised for it to be slow until 2028-2030. Need to work thru the low cost debt of 2020-early 2022.
I think this one is going to be long. I used to recruit and do interviews at my old University. I remember in 2014 when I interviewed candidates, the business school was about 50% of the kids going to a Big 4, 25% in corporate finance, and remainder in IB. Very little to non-existent in CRE. Maybe like a 1% but barely heard of anyone doing it. I went again in 2016 for another recruiting event, ratios changed, it was at least 2 in 10 kids that were getting in CRE or wanted to do it. Then I did it one last time in 2019 because I left the firm shortly after. It was atleast 30% that were getting offers in CRE or wanted to do something CRE related. Too much saturation, too much capital, too many new firms all due to cheap debt. Everyone is thinking those days will come back, but frankly if we are being true to ourselves, this industry needs to be gutted by atleast 30-40%. We need less players in the market to get to a more balanced world. Its not ideal and its a tough pill to swallow.
Hi I graduated a few years ago. What's a cycle?
Steroids are pretty unsafe to begin with. If you just blast the entire time, you're putting your body at even more risk than you already are.
I think it’s going to take some LP’s to literally threaten GP’s to sell and crystallize liquidity / turn off the fee clock.
The sector needs a clearing out in terms of talent as well. Everyone hopped in ~2013 because they saw the money being made via “buy low, and sell high.”
Thematic bets don’t seem relevant anymore. You need to find situational distress - but that’s proving to be far more difficult than anyone ever imagined.
There is an entire vintage of guys 35-42, who had meaningful carry pre 22, and now are coming to terms with the fact that it’s now a legitimate zero. Gone. As those at the right age between 2012-22, couldn’t help but make money. Rents go up, and yields go down. Brain dead.
**LP’s threaten to sue GP’s - to force sales…
No, the industry is fine.
What isn't fine is the old playbook of using cheap debt and equity to buy the same shitty deals everyone else was bidding on, executing on the same crappy business plan, and hoping the same crop of suckers would come in 3 years later and take it off your hands.
If you actually have some expertise or skill or anything resembling a competitive advantage, you're fine.
This is how it should be. Too many people on this site think that the 2012-22 period was "normal" from a historical perspective. It wasn't. This isn't supposed to be an industry where you make oodles of money just by being a herd animal. The whole point of real estate is that there is real risk involved, that you get paid for taking that risk, and a paradigm where cap stacks were dirt cheap and people would throw money at any idiotic thing and let the GP fee themselves out of the deal upfront is not how it should work.
Don’t disagree that returns were being manufactured by cheap money. Think we all know that. I think the point is, thematic bets don’t stack as well as they did - as you are waiting for capital to rotate out of an out of favor sector (secondary office), and into sheds / living - it’s betting on a herd mentality, as you rightfully point out.
The issue is, loans aren’t being called for assets that are operationally sound, but have just seen value distraction because of outward pressure on cap rates.
The balance sheet lenders that finally came off the sideline only had an appetite to lend to two sectors (living + sheds), and maybe some hospitality (DC’s being their own beast).
Point is - you have a huge part of the investable universe that can no longer be capitalized, so massive amounts of equity and debt capital are targeting a narrowing pool of opportunities and inadvertently underpinning market paralysis.
That + GP stakes have become red hot, as managers (the founders), realize they can make more money selling the fee stream than they ever could on a hypothetical promote.
Get your facts and logic out of here.
If I’m not mistaken you own your own affordable dev business. Would you be able to give some background on how you went about building your competitive advantage?
Have you encountered anything in the market housing business that you’ve seen as a good example of building a competitive edge? Seems like most institutions in this space more or less operate as the herd you describe and more or less are just building an aum/fee business.
I've done some small deals myself, and I've participated as a (very) minority partner in some with more established players. I'm honest enough with myself to know it isn't the same thing!
I worked, and work, for a really good affordable housing developer. I learned everything I could and understood early on that while a technical grounding was important and necessary, the thing that sets the really great developers in this space apart from the so-so is how they/we/I interface with tenants and elected officials. Listen more than you talk. Even when complaints or asks are unreasonable, always do your best to accommodate them. The credit always goes to someone else, the spotlight always goes to someone else, and the blame and the bad press and the shit? That you always volunteer to take. Make yourself someone others are eager to do business with. Having no ego, or at least in that sense, is a huge plus (since anyone who know me knows "no ego" does not describe me well lol). A deep understanding of the regulatory, legislative, and programmatic aspects of the business is necessary.
That may sound fairly generic, but almost no one actually seems to live by it. I find that most people, especially most younger people, are interested in the exact opposite. They care about doing the financing, talking to lenders, deploying equity. They're interested in showing up at the conference circuit and talking about the deals they're doing or hoping to do or pretending to do. If they actually walk the walk, it is in service of being able to talk, and not the other way around.
What do your tenants want? What does the local alderman or city councilor want? Reading headlines it can be easy to forget that a lot of politics is hyper-local. Why haven't those needs/asks been met already? How do you give it to them, and not only give them the credit but make them feel like they're the ones who actually deserve it?
Some of them do, I suppose. A lot of them get into trouble. There are a couple extremely high profile implosions occurring in the affordable housing space right now, which to my knowledge are happening because the people running the firm(s) in question never bothered to challenge their own assumptions, lost sight of the original causes for their success, and took a lot of same way risk bets. Or in some cases simply didn't understand the industry well enough, did too much, and collapsed under the weight of it. Some of the people I've met in this industry are fucking geniuses, though. Extremely clever and creative in manufacturing value for themselves by grokking an often arcane and misunderstood industry.
Maybe this is simply the conceit of all young(ish!) people who always seem themselves as the vanguard of something new, but it does seem to me that there is a bit of a generational change in the affordable housing industry. A lot of the people who figured all this out and built the scaffolding for the entire industry post-86 are gone or on their way out, and relatively younger people coming in. NYC is increasingly full of affordable housing firms run by people who have either entered the business, started their own business, or in some cases inherited a business in the last decade or so. Simultaneously the last 10-15 years have seen an increasing focus on the space, with an increasing degree of professionalization and sophistication on the part of housing agencies, issuing agencies, local and state governments, etc etc. There are more resources available, though they're being spread more thinly. Margins are being squeezed across the board. To relate it to the original question, the people and firms and business models which did well until, say, the mid-2010s now need to adapt or start declining. That means having an intimate knowledge of the new policies and preferences coming out, which in turn means being tuned in politically to what decision-makers are looking for. It seems facile to say that a competitive edge means constantly questioning and challenging what you know to be true and why, but it's something almost no one does, and that goes beyond affordable housing. Again, I focus on NYC because I know it best, but if all you knew how to do was 4% LIHTC rehab deals, then you found yourself totally out business in the space of a few years when the city stopped doing 4% rehabs back in the mid-2010s.
That was a very long winded post that I think veered way off your question. Sorry... I tend to get carried away!
I think the next few years will be more about balance sheet repair than recovery. Higher rates and refinancing costs are exposing overleveraged owners, particularly in office. There will be opportunities in distressed assets, but the old playbook of cheap debt and cap rate compression is unlikely to return.
medium term as in 2 years?
You gotta ask yourself who saw this many rate hikes this year coming?
Most experts were calling for real estate to decline years ago.
With all the volatility and steady employment rates, if rates fall 25 to 50 bps, I suspect it will pick back up in certain markets. San Francisco is still strong.
There were plenty of people predicting rates going higher, just not real estate folks. The writing has been on the wall but real estate folks just tend to hear what they want to hear and bury their heads (which worked for decades as rates always eventually did come down). Over the past 5 years I've never once heard a real estate person make a case for higher rates. When rates go up it's ALWAYS that it's a buying opportunity because rates will come down, as if that's fact.
You have to ask yourself what would actually cause rates to come down. And I'm not talking about short term relief by a war ending, etc. We are $40 trillion in debt and pumping. The supply of treasuries is only going to increase over time. If you think rates are coming down over a meaningful period of time, you're predicting that demand for treasuries is going to rise even more than the supply of them. Why would demand for treasuries increase dramatically when our financial situation as a country is deteriorating with the only way out being either printing our way out of it?
In short, yes real estate is cooked for the next 2-5 years. So many underwater deals to count.
Unless you have 10+ yr horizon and can acquire with majority equity, yes it’s cooked
Couldn’t agree more. The winners are family offices with more money than they know what to do with and are buying and holding so their great grandchildren in 2126 can own all these trophies
Can confirm, I work at a family office and we're still transacting pretty heavily. Especially in Canada, super underrated MF market.
"Where is the light at the end of the tunnel?!"
It is at when the AI bubble bursts. There will be a large correction, and then there will be new opportunities.
Would you suggest juniors doing more Data Centers deal so that gain exposure for that future correction? Many thanks for your insights!
If the junior wants to be doing these types of deals for their career than yes. The AI bubble popping is going to have a system-wide impact in RE. You don't just need to be in DCs to get the "benefit" of the post-implosion opportunities.
The beatings will continue until morale improves
For multifamily development, we need to see real income growth, at least for the top quatrile of renters. The pool of people who can income-qualify for a new construction apartment isn’t growing in step with the number of units delivered or currently under construction. With construction slowing, limited new supply over the next five years should put upward pressure on rents, but not if incomes stay flat and groceries keep getting more expensive. I bet we start seeing co-living and rent-by-the-bedroom roommate-style leasing soon.
Boomers have all the money so I'd bet on Senior Housing and Medial Office to be the winners for a while.
Agreed, and would add retail in wealthy suburbs.
Have you multi guys ever tried… I don’t know… raising the rents?
I posted this in another thread but figure it's helpful here too.
As a GP, you sell a product.
You have certain levels of product market fit depending on what is going on in the world.
Depending on what is going on in the world, a very dumb person can look brilliant...or a smart person can look very stupid.
You need to be aware of what these factors are and how they impact your core product. Does it improve PMF + returns or hurt?
How can you adjust the product, etc.
Obviously this is easier said than done, especially in real estate where timing really matters and it's tougher to pivot your core investment style...
Feels exactly like that. The bid-ask spread is still a nightmare, and with debt maturities coming up, it's hard to see the light at the end of the tunnel.
Thanks, Claude
If you can't handle the heat, get out of the kitchen.
I can't even get back into the kitchen rn lmfao
A lot of people will say stuff like this is a cycle or whatever.
The answer is yes, CRE is cooked. Medium term, possibly long term. Several reasons.
1) Loans are becoming too expensive. I’ve worked on both sides of the equation. Lenders require debt yield, in-place cash flow, lower LTV preferably 50-60% LTV, and want juicy spreads to try and make a profit. Sponsors can’t make their structures work under those terms and rates are only going to rise until inflation comes down.
2) Comp is down industry wide. This isn’t 1999 anymore. The reality has set in and the industry as a whole has reset comp to a point where unless you have some sort of carried interest / promote interest, good luck. The reality is there are shmucks on WSO working for Deloitte with less experience, making more than you.
3) Investor interest has softened, and stayed soft for years now across multiple CRE sectors. Have any of you guys working for a GP tried to raise capital with family offices or institutional LPs recently? Investment committees at LPs are demanding wild returns that aren’t realistic and they want no risk. They’re living in boomer fantasy land.
4) AI is evolving and here to stay. The reality is nobody really knows what the future holds, but we can all agree that this AI race is going faster than expected. The advancements of AI are going to change the landscape many industries operate in. This ultimately means less jobs. The ramifications of less jobs for the normie workforce naturally affects all sectors of CRE.
5) Covid wasn’t a “cycle”. The 2008 GFC was a cycle. It was an abnormality, fluke instance that wasn’t rooted in worldwide, global cultural shifts. Covid has fundamentally changed the way society interacts with all sectors of CRE and those changes are permanent.
If we boil it down and use our thinking caps, the real two permanent factors are post covid implications and AI developing to a point where work is becoming more and more obsolete across every industry. The temporary factor is the current interest rate and inflationary environment.
Life is not following your Cornell “textbooks” about CRE cycles right now. It’s changed forever. None of us have a crystal ball to know what will or won’t recover. However the reality is the pandemic and the AI boom occurring just as the pandemic ended is like living in a primitive simple caveman world and then the plague and the invention of fire occur within 5 years of each other.
Medium term yes. The pullback will create the recovery but I don’t think the window for shovels in the ground is until 2030.
The market is a complete mess. It’s just a fact.
I have had $210M of deals fall apart in 5 days. One of the deals had a contract fully negotiated and all technical diligence done. Had incurred huge deal costs. Two LP’s - neither with governance and one refused to close without a 10% price chip. Vendor (rightfully), told us to fuck right off.
Awarded a deal with another household named capital party. Term sheet gets issued and money starts to fumble and move the goal posts. Broker pulls the deal.
Point being - there is so much paralysis by analysis in this sector at the moment. MD’s and sector heads are legitimately terrified to even take on modest deal costs, in the event a deal falls over for some arbitrary reason and they look stupid.
People are literally falling over very basic real estate analysis. It’s remarkable to see in real time. It’s straight job preservation mode. Bid on a deal to appear busy, but nobody actually wants to be awarded it, and take the risk of going to IC.
In 45 days, I've seen the goal shift from "finding new sites" to "don't spend money until 2027"
On several occasions, I have considered leaving the industry. I may just do it now tbh
Where would you go?
Yeah probably
The recent articles in the WSJ (BX) and GreenStreet “Tons of people are looking for jobs. The sector is fucked. Especially equity,” - says a lot.
So much value has been wiped, and even for those who want liquidity, few have the cash to provide it. The most favorable sectors (bar industrial) now come with huge policy risk (multi, SFR, DC’s) - it’s absurd.
If I was younger, I’d pivot to infra. Simple cash flows and can finance all day. Often times with a decent balance sheet, you don’t even need third party equity as the cap stacks are so efficient.
can you paste the article? didnt see it
What are some of the big infra players? I’m woefully ignorant of the infra world.
Agreed
Ut nisi et aspernatur repellendus. Ut velit impedit modi. Inventore sit consequatur quo. Repudiandae qui exercitationem rem totam labore voluptas. Aspernatur qui deserunt ab ullam saepe.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Ea qui fugiat rerum corrupti nam nam assumenda. Rerum sunt et animi voluptas. Quod sint ducimus incidunt magni.
Praesentium dignissimos et alias a inventore quae. Et voluptatem error asperiores mollitia earum quis iure. Eligendi consequuntur quasi facilis suscipit molestias rem sed. Ratione accusantium repellendus recusandae non. Dolorum expedita est voluptatem et tempora nemo quam. Inventore sed eos nobis recusandae ea. Dicta nam delectus sunt quo.
Alias consequatur provident nobis sed distinctio nemo tenetur. Corporis distinctio dicta qui neque quos modi. Quia assumenda voluptates aut voluptas. Optio pariatur ut placeat quae nisi voluptas quam sit. Voluptatem qui omnis magni est quas.