Have heard this is the case. Let’s say you refinance an existing loan and receive $15mm. You pay off an existing $10mm mortgage, so you can take $5mm for yourself.
ive heard many times this $5mm is tax free, can anyone explain why?
Trending Content - Real Estate Forum
Career Resources
Proceeds from a loan (that you have to pay back...) are not profit, gain on sale, or anything else that is taxed in the US. It's not income, thus, no income tax!
Sir, that $5M belongs to the bank - it needs to be paid back with interest - so taxing it would just punish borrowers because that's fundamentally just stealing. If only politicians asked these logical questions... We already tax the crap out of the debt slave cohort (vast majority) of our society... Let's not give the Whiney Warrens any more terrible ideas :)
The statement that this is "tax free" is not entirely accurate. While you will not pay any income tax (as mentioned above) or capital gains tax (obviously) you do have to pay a mortgage recording tax depending on the city / state where the mortgage is being recorded. In NYC, for example, you would pay no mortgage recording tax on the initial $10MM (as the tax would have already been paid during the initial financing) but you would have to pay 2.8% MRT on the additional proceeds of $5MM.
Because that 5M isn't something you just "took for yourself"? You have to pay it back? Are you actually an Analyst 1 in CRE lmao
Imagine if every homeowner in the US got taxed for 1.) getting a mortgage 2.) refinancing their mortgage (in practice, refinancing is just getting a new mortgage that takes out the existing mortgage) 3.) getting a home equity line of credit…sure, you get taxes from the real estate investors and developers (if part of the funds are going to be used for capex in the existing property, then how the government would even determine what portion of the loan is “cash out equity” would be almost impossible in itself)…but cripple the entire real estate market while you’re at it. But if the government is going to essentially be taxing loans, why stop at real estate? Tax student loans, car loans, corporate debt etc…cripple the entire economy
Corrupti eum fugit eligendi. Ut nesciunt facere distinctio dolor ea. Nesciunt et modi alias voluptatibus sint. Autem sequi voluptas officia et consequatur placeat. Et voluptates ut est libero rem exercitationem est provident. A rerum qui ad nobis. Enim voluptas aperiam aperiam earum.
Perspiciatis accusantium quis nemo sequi perspiciatis. Facere modi nobis consequatur. Eligendi dolorem dolorum laboriosam fuga debitis itaque ipsa. Nam facere explicabo dolorem quo quia ut. Itaque in ratione ratione et et harum. Tenetur adipisci aut aut sed fuga atque.
Quia aut qui aperiam vel eaque ut. Numquam aut est autem ex saepe quod et. Quis quia nam illum vel itaque accusantium deleniti. Labore in repellendus animi voluptatem quis magnam. Rerum nemo est minus odio. Sint saepe ullam neque nobis deserunt. Necessitatibus pariatur ea est est aspernatur sit.
Beatae dolorum dicta unde. Illo facere velit voluptatem aut. Sapiente facilis et tempore beatae quae optio. Recusandae totam veritatis praesentium illum eos ratione. Tempora vitae quo laboriosam. Voluptates accusamus et minima quae ducimus et optio. Culpa ad facilis delectus earum dolor.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...