Would be interested to get people’s take on this. Digging into analyst expectations for companies in the S&P 500, estimates have been cut by only 8.4% since year end, and are still 6.2% higher than LTM earnings, despite the complete shutdown of the economy. Stripping out Airlines and Energy (the two sectors where estimates have been slashed since analysts can’t ignore $25/barrel oil and a 90%+ reduction in air travel), estimates are only 5.7% lower than at year end, and 9.2% higher than LTM EPS. These estimates remain even though Goldman Sachs just estimated that GDP will fall 6.2% for the year, and operating leverage will push earnings down far more than 6.2%. Unemployment could hit 15%+, and we announced the lockdown-type environment shall remain at least the end of April, resulting in near zero revenues for a swath of businesses that employ millions, including airline, hotels, restaurants, and retail.
Admitting this is EXTREMELY basic way of looking at it, but roll with me here. At a 30,000 foot level, if you assume that revenues fall by 6% in 2020 (Goldman’s recent GDP estimate) and apply the S&P 500’s average 2019 gross margin and earnings margin, operating leverage hurts results, and EPS will fall by approximately 18% in 2020 – a far cry from the current 6% estimated earnings growth. This would imply a 1,975 level on the S&P 500 using the average multiple on the index since 2008. At one standard deviation lower than the average (13.7x), we’re at 1,720. At an all-time low multiple of 10.0x from 2008, we’re at 1,248. I am not saying I think we get there (I don’t), I am simply showing these levels to hopefully illustrate just how inflated valuations still may be.
Thoughts?
First off, the value of that first year is the most important, and changing that number has the biggest impact. You're also assuming that if a Company was going from EPS of 10 in 2019 to 12 in 2020 to 15 in 2021, that now you're going to go from 10 in 2019 to 5 in 2020 and then all the way back to 15 in 2021, which is an absurd assumptions for the vast majority of companies.
I specifically said I did not think we were going to get to that all time low multiple, but given where GDP expectations are, and where unemployment is going, I don't think that using the historical average multiple, or one standard deviation lower than the average multiple is out of the question. Interest rates being as low as they are won't get someone who was living paycheck to paycheck and is now unemployed off the couch and buying a new iphone/car/home anytime in the near future, and unless the fed is going to push rates negative (I guess its possible at this point), they now have used all their ammunition before the recession has even started.
A full stop of the economy is unprecedented, and is more like a depression than a recession. I think people are missing the forest through the trees, and as was said in The Big Short, "People hate to think about bad things happening so they always underestimate their likelihood."
Accusamus similique dolores accusamus voluptas. Corrupti voluptates dolorem nostrum veritatis ut maiores officia. Ut possimus tenetur libero possimus nobis quo. Aut iusto similique mollitia officia in. Soluta ut et voluptates ut. Culpa est possimus dolorum non et sit at consequatur.
Sequi distinctio et optio. Qui omnis quaerat est autem ut. Adipisci perspiciatis qui ratione eveniet.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Est corrupti est quas eos dicta eveniet. Aperiam voluptas perferendis omnis tempore nihil. Totam ut ut aut suscipit. Sapiente non debitis debitis maiores. Et consequatur sed dolores eum. Aut doloremque dicta nihil eaque qui nihil ut repellat.
Eum sapiente quae esse ut labore. Dolores facere sint esse in. Accusamus earum et esse magni quia.
Consectetur qui unde dolor exercitationem. Ut officia aut quia modi itaque quae tempora.
Est similique molestiae molestiae quos doloremque. Laudantium quo facilis non unde et voluptas voluptatem. Fugit omnis quo recusandae sit.
Deleniti voluptatem odit et voluptas. Adipisci reprehenderit enim qui aliquid. Ab nemo tempora non pariatur quidem corporis. Nam in voluptatem et nisi expedita. Qui ratione fugiat tempora est quia.
Voluptatem odio omnis repellendus voluptatem qui aspernatur. Molestiae sit impedit autem ab est quas qui.
Quo quia praesentium fugit placeat aut facere id. Vitae inventore doloribus necessitatibus voluptas qui sit soluta fuga. Praesentium quis non veniam aut earum nulla non incidunt. Natus asperiores quidem earum quia sint.
Dolorem ut perspiciatis provident nihil quasi eos et dolores. Rerum ut et molestiae.