Due Diligence Report

High-profile transactions these days often dominate headlines, but behind every deal is a far less visible process that ultimately shapes the outcome, which is an in-depth evaluation of the target business. 

This evaluation goes beyond surface-level financials and management presentations to assess whether the target truly fits the acquirer’s strategic, operational, and financial objectives. A due diligence report is a pivotal tool for conducting the target company's analysis.

What is a due diligence report?

A due diligence report is a detailed, confidential document prepared to support important corporate decisions such as mergers, acquisitions, and buyouts. 

Its purpose is not just to compile information but to validate management's claims and uncover risks that may not be immediately apparent from headline financials.

It goes well beyond basic financial statements. It typically begins with an executive summary that highlights pivotal findings, followed by an in-depth analysis of assets and liabilities, regulatory and legal compliance, intellectual property, workforce structure, and the target company’s competitive position within its market. 

Together, these sections help decision-makers assess both downside risks and the transaction's strategic fit.

Significance of due diligence reports

Investors rely on it as an input for financial forecasting and valuation, using the findings to estimate a company’s intrinsic value and compare it against the proposed transaction price. While this process may appear straightforward on paper, in reality, it is highly subjective. 

Building forecasts from due diligence reports requires experience, as analysts often need to adjust historical data, normalize earnings, and make informed assumptions about future performance. 

The quality of a due diligence report and the skill of the professional interpreting it significantly influence valuation reliability, alongside market and strategic factors.

Impact of Due Diligence on Deal Outcomes

The purpose of due diligence is to help management validate or challenge their perspective of the target company by identifying risks and verifying assumptions.

However, there can be a few extreme cases that can lead to the following outcomes:

• Purchase price adjustments: If revenue is overstated or aggressive revenue recognition policies are used, the buying firm may need to renegotiate the purchase price
• Earn-out structures: In the event of disagreement about prospective performance, part of the deal can be structured as a performance-based consideration, contingent on meeting certain targets. For instance, the buyer would pay additional consideration in case the acquired company meets an adjusted EBITDA margin of over 10% for the next 3 years.
• Finding indemnities: An in-depth due diligence process can help the buyer identify any risks arising from tax, legal, or regulatory concerns. This reduces the likelihood of surprises post-deal closure.
• Deal walkouts: In some cases, where legal issues can cause concerns for the buyer, they have the option to walk out of the deal process

The importance of the report lies in the influence its findings have on deal structure, pricing, risk mitigation, and post-deal planning. A well-prepared report, combined with informed judgment, can materially impact pricing, deal structure, and even the decision to walk away.

Users and providers of the due diligence report

Analyzing a due diligence report is not a task for a single professional. It is done through collaboration among multiple teams and is relied upon by a wide range of decision-makers. 

Understanding who prepares these reports and who ultimately depends on them provides insight into how central this analysis is to the transaction ecosystem.

The following are the providers and users of due diligence reports:

Providers

Providers are usually the sell-side firms that analyze financial, legal, and operational risks in a transaction. Some of these firms are as follows:

• Investment Banks: They coordinate the transaction process and provide valuation and structuring advice, while independent financial due diligence is often conducted by accounting or advisory firms. (e.g.: Goldman Sachs, JP Morgan, etc.)
• Accounting firms: These handle financial and tax due diligence. They focus on analyzing earnings quality, working capital trends, and potential accounting risks. They are frequently used in mid-market transactions. They are cost-efficient and have technical expertise. (e.g.: KPMG, PwC, EY, Deloitte, etc.)
• Boutique transaction advisory firms: Boutique advisors provide specialized, sector-focused expertise. They are often engaged for independent, conflict-free advice. They are common in strategic or niche transactions requiring tailored analysis. (e.g.: Evercore, Lazard, etc.)
• Legal firms: Law firms conduct legal due diligence. They do it by reviewing contracts and regulatory compliance. They identify litigation exposure and corporate governance matters. Their role is critical in identifying legal liabilities that affect deal structure or pricing. (e.g., Kirkland & Ellis, Latham & Watkins, etc.)
• Industry specialists: Industry consultants provide operational and commercial due diligence. They assess the company's market positioning. They are particularly useful in unfamiliar or specific sectors.

Users

These reports are primarily relied upon by buy-side firms who use the findings to assess risk, validate valuation, and determine whether to proceed with the deal. Some of these firms are as follows:

• Private Equity firms: They rely on due diligence to confirm their investment analysis. It also helps them identify value-creation opportunities. This process is necessary before making investments in a company. (e.g.: KKR, OMERS, etc.)
• Corporate acquirers: They use due diligence to assess acquisition risks. This helps them to decide if the business is a strategic fit
• Venture capital funds: VCs focus on growth potential and market scalability. This is important where historical data is limited. (e.g.: Sequoia Capital, Andreessen Horowitz, etc.)
• Credit investors & lenders: Lenders assess cash flow stability, covenant risks, and downside protection. This helps them in analyzing the impact of credit extension
• Board members & Investment Committees: They use these findings to conclude their investment decision

Risks in Due Diligence Reports

Due diligence reports carry limitations. These reports are based on accessible information, management reports, and time-sensitive analysis. It means that certain risks may not be properly visible. Hence, reliance on these reports requires judgment and an understanding of their drawbacks.
Let’s understand a few risks below:

• Time Bias: These are prepared at a particular point in time. Events occurring after the report date may not be reflected unless updated through subsequent diligence or contractual protections
• Miscommunication across teams: This process requires involvement from diverse teams, including finance, legal, tax, and operations. Communication gaps across these teams may compromise the quality of the report
• Dependence on provided information: This report is strictly constrained by the data made available by the target company. It cannot gauge the corporate governance issues, human capital quality, and other qualitative factors that are useful
• Lack of interpretive expertise: Inability of the professional to interpret due diligence reports with reasonable accuracy may cause the investor to overlook certain risks or misinterpret the impacts of those risks
• Historical bias: It includes historical analysis but may rely heavily on past data when forming forward-looking assessments. Overreliance on historical data can lead to forecasting errors.

Conclusion

Due diligence reports are pivotal tools in the deal process, helping decision-makers evaluate the target company and provide a basis for proceeding with the deal. It helps them form an opinion that would not otherwise be possible using publicly available information.

Hence, caution should be taken, not just by maintaining confidentiality but also by analyzing the report prudently. Specialized teams prepare these reports, which are used by varied stakeholders. They also carry certain risks that the investor must be careful about.

Free Resources

To continue learning and advancing your career, check out these additional helpful WSO resources:

• Comparable Company Analysis
• Discounted Cash Flow (DCF)
• Enterprise Value vs Equity Value
• Market Approach Valuation
• Valuation Methods