Are target prospects getting dumber?
AN1 at a MS/JPM/GS SF/Menlo as per the title. I’m helping funnel interns and have unfortunately had to chat with a bunch of prospects. One thing I’ve noticed is the discrepancy between target and non-target prospects. Target prospects seem to get less and less sociable as recruiting drags on, and chatting with them is, quite frankly miserable. They don’t understand the industry dynamics, have a terrible "why SF" answer, are horrifically stiff, and many of them seem really entitled. So my question to you guys is: what’s been your experience with targets vs. non-targets? Do you think non-targets are becoming increasingly competitive, or are the targets losing their competitive edge?
Our non targets are all solid dudes I’d go to happy hour with every time, but the quality of work ranges from dogshit to top bucket
As a dogshit non-target, I do love a good happy hour.
Over the last 10 years the Ivy League has admitted people who don’t belong there. With them all finally returning to test required and DEI-blind, there should be some return to normalcy.
Except they aren’t. Latest classes of ivies still hover from 6-10% black, when they should be near the 1% mark.
Probably a bit of both. I'd like to think that the internet has slowly democratized the access to being intelligent, but to quote Freakanomics, admittance to Ivy league schools is generally a pretty good signal that someone is bright, regardless of policy.
I would say across the board there is just more stratification. The lazy kids are definitely lazier (using AI without checking, low interest, just going through motions, etc.), but I think the students who would have been strong before are able to strengthen themselves really well. I came from a non-target, and we always played the "grit" angle, and I've noticed the bad kids are really bad and the good kids are really good. Not just a target thing, but an everyone thing.
Target school just means you tried in highschool that’s all it guarantees.
It probably realistically means that you came from a well off family and sure there is probably some correlation between your parents doing well and you being smarter, or more prepared, but generally ivy admissions have greatly favored those who come from rich families.
Source: Article
Aso1 from a target - saw too many classmates go to higher octane jobs out of college with much less volume to IB. Have a feeling there is a selection bias where top Ivys place well into EBs and outside of that the rest recruit straight to buyside or other roles entirely.
Use the abbreviation Aso1 not Ass1, my man 😂
my bad 😂
im ass2
At a target school - can I change your mind
No thanks
70% of the target kids are retarded nowadays.
Not sure if it’s 1) due to DEI or 2) adverse selection as only retards do IB nowadays.
as a non-target who placed - please continue thinking that targets are getting dumber thanks
adverse selection
The difference at my firm is night and day between target and non target across the multiple groups/teams I’ve interacted with
Think it comes down to, from what I’ve seen, being able to critically think through something vs follow a process or instructions.
Non targets are great at following a process and doing what they’re told. Watching them try to critically think through something ( i.e., more efficient way to do something) is p rough, or they just lack any capacity to even attempt it. If they do produce quality product it takes them forever leading to burn out or hours complaints.
Have noticed little difference in social aspects. Would probably lean targets as they on average get their work done faster and have capacity to go out.
Interesting. What type of bank/industry do you work at? The work I've done as an IB analyst has required little to no mental firepower. Banking is just storytelling, basic math, and pptx work lol
Critical thinking? Really? Critically thinking about size 8 or 9 font?
If you think basic banking work requires critical thinking, you’re probably just bad at your job lmao
It’s kinda like hot and ugly chicks, one had to put an effort working on personality and the other can get away with a lot
What a fun description
I think as a general matter (in life as in banking), the top 10% of people who get hired are better than ever. They know how to integrate intelligence, personality and commercial instincts with the incredible information and productivity tools that exist. The remaining 90% are worse than ever because they are unthinking and uncritical. This is true of targets and non-targets (I tend to value academic excellence more than most when I hire so your random business school hardo won’t fly with me).
Anecdotally, my analyst classes are the best they ever have been over the course of my career (but I spend a lot of time trying to hire the top 10% of those who go into banking).
Any anecdotes of amazing analysts?
These are exceptional examples but really a lot of it is understanding what needs to be done, proactively managing transactions, making the associate redundant and doing this consistently. You hire smart people, you should give them the responsibility to be exceptional.
That's because the smart kids at target alr went to P72/CAP
I think as more NTs have gotten into the industry and proven themselves (carry a perpetual chip on their shoulder their entire career, so they never “let down”) people are more openly critical of Ts.
The T label probably goes farther at firms with fewer NTs, and Ts are probably educated in an environment that cultivates the idea that they’ll be fine because they go to X school, so they get lazy, and firms that are school agnostic just see a less prepared candidate.
I can’t explain it but something about pedigreed schools have just lost their lustre. Beyond the typical explanation of DEI allowing in worse students (which is true). Maybe as a NT myself in these spaces I realize these guys aren’t that much smarter than me, but yea for some reason they just don’t stand out.
That being said, the cream of the crop of T schools probably aren’t even going into finance anymore.
You are seeing the top 1% of non targets and the middle 30% of targets (the top go to labs, quant trading, PE/HF) so it’s hard to compare them
No Ivy League kids really want to go to SF to do banking … hopefully that explains your query. Hopefully it was your first choice!
it’s true that many students at top universities aren’t necessarily choosing investment banking anymore.
Right, there are other choices actually
crazy
crazy
bump
crazy
hahahahahahahhah
bump
wowww
I've noticed this too, but I think it's less about targets getting 'dumber' and more about a shift in incentives. Many target kids now treat networking as a checkbox—they've been coached to death by career services and prep courses, so they sound robotic. Non-targets, on the other hand, often have to fight harder and genuinely research the bank, the group, and the city, which makes them more compelling to talk to. The 'why SF' answer is a great filter—if they can't articulate why they want to be in tech/SF specifically, that's a red flag. It's less about pedigree now and more about genuine curiosity and hustle.
DEL
Where you come from matters less than how curious you are and how hard you’re willing to work.
Without OCR, anyone who makes it deep into funnel got there by grinding through dozens of coffee chats. they have deeper industry knowledge, more genuine motivation, lower egos, and faster follow-through.
bump
Bump
BUMP
bump
Why the hell are so many bots bumping my post
Prob agency people trying to hide the leaking question thread lol
I think you are most likely just lacking self-awareness.
At my previous bank, I would say that target-school students from top-tier investment clubs generally performed better than non-target students. However, non-target students tended to outperform target-school students who weren’t involved in those clubs.
Obviously, this is a generalization, but based on my experience, the hierarchy looked something like this:
Target-school students in top-tier investment clubs > Non-target students > Target-school students outside those clubs
At my bank the “target list” changes every year and at this point it’s all non-ivies and mostly business programs that are “targets” i.e., today’s target are yesterday’s non-targets so the distinction is meaningless
But on the ivy / non-ivy topic - non-ivy business / finance majors have been my best analysts by a significant margin TBH
Bump
Because recruiting started so early this year bruh
Literally no one is ready
You had the whole summer lol. The truly competitive people will win and everyone else is cooked
every generation says this about the next one
Aut ipsum et est unde magni eius voluptatem. Neque illum atque et nihil error. Dolore pariatur assumenda aut est consequatur sunt et nesciunt.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Commodi fugiat sed tenetur neque quidem earum sunt eveniet. Laudantium tempora sed hic cumque sed.
Amet veritatis blanditiis porro omnis. Ut dolorum voluptas in voluptatem modi exercitationem in. Ad esse saepe qui ipsum in repellendus ratione et.
Illo soluta qui et modi sint voluptates. Nemo voluptate eos eos illo ut. Quas recusandae consequatur soluta hic voluptatem possimus aut. Atque ea qui quia.
Inventore aliquam qui qui beatae. Repellendus vel accusamus expedita sint minus nesciunt non. Distinctio dignissimos est praesentium rerum fuga quia quis. Pariatur eum alias fuga non repudiandae ex repellendus. Exercitationem perspiciatis optio voluptate dolor sint ea.
Quod iusto eius eveniet odio delectus maxime. Nobis unde aliquid facere. Voluptates excepturi atque soluta deleniti. Qui in iusto neque sed sunt. Minus et atque perspiciatis et.
Sit ducimus similique similique alias. Sunt consequatur impedit ut ducimus vel rem. Alias quae voluptatem dolorum fuga. Dolorum et et eligendi praesentium minus. Placeat non est dolor possimus sequi.
Et consectetur vitae reiciendis provident enim debitis. Nihil voluptatem corrupti odit omnis dolorem. Facere et quos dignissimos voluptas minus. Laborum exercitationem harum facilis qui consectetur sapiente.
Voluptatem sint et sit aliquid non qui. Aut et voluptates cum. Quae earum fugit numquam aut sed temporibus sunt. Rerum temporibus ea et molestiae quia. Sit fugiat facere quo tempore doloremque pariatur corrupti quidem. Aliquid porro sed qui et et dolor.
Nemo quod consequatur dicta quibusdam. Incidunt ut quas non et. Et aut earum blanditiis nemo et. Fugiat corporis eius neque. Dolores nobis odio eveniet et.
Autem et autem error. Quia deleniti quos hic iure. Esse sit qui consequuntur aut tempore similique. Fugit facere qui animi nobis quasi eos eos harum. Hic modi excepturi voluptas repellat.
Corporis aut adipisci labore inventore nihil. Possimus autem cupiditate accusantium et mollitia libero. Cum aut molestias blanditiis rerum commodi. Magnam dolorem error unde nostrum pariatur placeat quia possimus. Omnis consequatur eaque odio qui et similique laborum.