Ghosted after 7 interviews at Morgan Stanley
I understand if I am not the right person for the role, but don't understand the disgusting lack of professional courtesy.
These types of practices need to end.
I will never apply to a role with them or respond to a recruiter who is shilling them ever again.
This happened to me. 8 interviews lol A buddy of mine also went through a process at MS and ended up getting the role only after reaching out to HR a month later and telling them he got another offer and will accept it unless they give him an offer that same day.
Unless your mate was bluffing, why would he turn down a role from a firm that seemed to value him to go with a firm that only responded due to said threat. Seems like a bad choice to me
prob cause its MS, no matter how much we pretend we don't care about clout we'd all take MS over a bank like citi without a second thought
Sorry to hear. A bit unprofessional but pretty common.
“I will forever blackball MS”
Yes, I won't fuck around with MS ever again. I flew to NYC twice, and used 5 days of vacation.I was told I would have an offer and started planning for a relocation.
I am sure you think that line is funny, but I don't, I will never pursue anything with MS again.
hey man very fair. that line's more ballsy than laughable imo
blackball ms and more power to you
I think you should have mentioned in your original post that you were essentially given a verbal offer. That changes things a lot.
I feel you man. I'm currently blackballing JPM.
Wrote a post about this a while back, "Ghosted? You will have the last laugh"
You had 7 interviews at MS. So I presume that you're a pretty qualified candidate who will be working in the industry under a different bank or firm very soon. Really dumb of them to behave this way simply out of self-interest as it's pretty likely that your paths will cross again.
Thank you, it is just so frustrating and shortsighted.
I honestly wouldn’t have minded if they said, “we are going on another direction” or “sorry we found a more qualified candidate”, but to say they are preparing an offer then disappear for two months and find out from a friend the role was filled; that hurts and is low class.
It feels a lot like dating in SF
Same after 8 interviews with a middle market bank. Terrible experience. I’m sorry
I never understood why it was a trademark of IB recruiting to ghost their candidates instead of sending a courtesy rejection via email or a quick HR phone call. This recruiting process demands so much respect and courtesy from their candidates. How unreasonable is it to expect the banks to show a smidge of their own?
MS tries to be like Goldman but they will never be able to fill their shoes.
Happened to me with MS as well. Gave me a verbal offer than retracted 1 month later.
HR are the bouncers of the corporate world. They're not too bright and are used mostly for low value-add tasks but get an inflated sense of self-worth because they essentially serve as gatekeepers.
How involved HR actually is though for laterals?
Fully agreed for internships, they can do whatever tf they want...
It's unfortunately quite common across finance in general. Best advice is to not dwell on it / take it personally. Make your decision on not pursuing future roles with them but don't let it impact your mood or take up time in your mind.
Morgan Stanley S&T has hella hot white bitches though
half of em from Duke
One time I had five interviews at Goldman. After the fifth they said I was put through to the final round which I would have to fly to London for in person. Didn't hear back for weeks despite multiple follow ups with HR and interviewers. Six months later after I got another position I received an automated rejection email. It's an unfortunate hallmark of the industry that these companies feel so entitled that they have no professional courtesy.
One time I had an interview with at Citadel. Two days before my interview I got a concussion and immediately requested to push the interview two days out. They said ok rescheduled and then never joined the call and filled the role with someone else. Some firms suck.
Same experience with MS. 5 interviews and then completely ghosted
Your responses have given me some peace, thank you WSO community!
These guys think they’re so great despite the industry bleeding talent left and right. Definition of delusions of grandeur.
Make it to the top and tell them to kick rocks when they try to recruit or pitch their worthless services to you in the future.
Happens.
Was ghosted after 8 at GS. Later found out they hired my colleague, one year my senior.
This has happened numerous times, the worst was I took a day off to interview for a super day. Turns out got through a 60% of the interviews and found out the back half of my schedule couldn't make my interview so wanted to reschedule another half day the next day. I was very annoyed that I took a day of PTO then had to make up another excuse as to why I was out the day after as well.
All this and then got ghosted, I emailed the HR then called and actually got my HR rep on the phone - I think I caught her off guard and she said she would call me back. To my surprise she never did.
Have a bud who went through ~15 interviews with MS and they gave him the offer after he said he was going somewhere else...
Same at MS, got AC for Summer Internship then got ghosted..
Little Off Topic but I need help :(
After final round, status updated to "Additional Interviews" but I still have to receive the mail from HR. (one week)
What does it mean? (this is for EMEA)
Summer or FT?
summer
Do I get why people are mad about this, yes.
Is it appropriate, no.
Is it smart, yes; therefore, I never get why people complain, they know whats going on. Its like dating, "ghosting" the girl/guy whose your second choice instead of if your first choice doesn't work out. Candidate 1 might be who MS wants, but Candidate 1 might want JPM or GS; MS doesn't want to be caught with their pants down. Whats easier for them, telling you no then coming back begging you to take the role, or knowing there's a high probability you'll be waiting in the wings and they can give you a "sorry, been crazy over here, we want to offer..."
Would be nice to just say you're tentative.
I applied for a role at Citi over 6 months ago and just now got a rejection email lol
Why would you go from PE to citi? Seems like most people would go the other direction...
Didn’t have the PE gig then.
large corporate bureaucracy, but as they go with the candidate of their choice, followed by an estimate 2 weeks of negotiations/winning candidate weighing and accepting the offer, followed by an additional 2 weeks of background check/ followed by the candidate joining the firm 2-3 weeks later. That is a 1.5-2 months ghost period. Firms unfortunately have to be 100% certain that their candidate of choice does join the firm before they can inform you of their decision not to move forward with you. In the event that something happens with their original candidate of choice, it would be a huge set back for them to have already declined all their other candidates.
Happened to me with CS after reaching the final round interviews. Got a generic automated rejection email 6 weeks later though.
Can confirm. never heard back after going through multiple rounds with them.
I recently went through a similar experience for a mid-level position at a name brand HF and was baffled. Completed eight interviews, including with senior management, and passed a very detailed case study somewhere in the middle of the process. Throughout it all received timely and encouraging feedback from the HH running the process on how much they liked me, thought good fit, etc. Process was very well ran and I was never waiting around for more than a day or two to hear about the next round. At the conclusion of the last interview was told they wanted to complete background and reference checks before extending an offer. I received notice the background check had cleared, but after over a week none of my references had been contacted yet. HH hadn't heard anything. After 2 weeks I reached out to the fund's HR who I had also been in touch with and didn't hear back, but the next day got a call from the HH who told me the fund had basically "changed my mind" and cited some obscure concern about my case study that I had never heard until that point, which was surprising given the positive feedback from the team on it.
Absolutely baffling and extremely inappropriate in my opinion. But such is life
Raymond James has been known to ghost candidates as well - it has happened quite a few times to my close friends and network. I don't think the blame is entirely on HR; instead, I think that at least one of the members of the team that interviewed a candidate can at least spend 5-minutes drafting a kind rejection email as opposed to leaving a candidate in the dark who likely spent hours preparing.
7 rounds of interviews leading to getting ghosted is insane. I feel for you!
Not like this means anything but I do think that the world works in mysterious ways and hopefully something positive comes to you in return for this in the near future!
Same experience but with Q. Shits whack but ig it shows how much competition there is.
Same experience but with Q. Shits whack but ig it shows how much competition there is.
Same experience but with Q. Shits whack but ig it shows how much competition there is.
Eius laudantium ipsum quibusdam dolor ut sint dolores. Libero sapiente enim molestiae aut aut dolorem similique. Unde suscipit ullam numquam quibusdam alias earum.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Tempora eum itaque id officia. Sint doloremque aperiam eum blanditiis eaque vitae eum.
Cumque quasi tenetur quia ipsa illum veritatis ut. Laudantium et necessitatibus possimus voluptatem cupiditate ipsum. Ut commodi sed et vel quasi.
Tenetur quidem optio aut voluptas. Exercitationem repudiandae consequatur blanditiis eos odio id. Fugit minus aliquid dolor nihil consequatur. Labore corporis unde repudiandae iusto.
Aperiam repudiandae pariatur aspernatur adipisci ullam dignissimos ad. Asperiores quia et praesentium praesentium incidunt. In illo iure autem quia quae. Error id et perspiciatis non neque incidunt.
Dolore velit optio a dolorem quia. Sed possimus temporibus ea. Id minus nihil et ut qui aut nesciunt.