GS Healthcare vs. MS M&A
thoughts?
Trending Content - Investment Banking Forum
| +379 | Evercore Intern Seizure | 56 | 1h |
| +74 | JPM M&A is Gone??? Purely Coverage Banking??? | 33 | 1h |
| +62 | Is DCM actually underrated ? | 26 | 23m |
| +53 | How do I understand vs. just memorizing? | 9 | 2h |
| +48 | Losing my personality in Banking | 9 | 1d |
| +47 | Are all Tech / TMT groups sweaty? | 38 | 1d |
| +42 | Associate & Above IB exits | 16 | 4d |
| +33 | Incoming IB Analyst: Best Ways to Prepare? | 11 | 8h |
| +27 | Which groups are ideal for laterals? | 12 | 1d |
| +24 | Thoughts on PEI Global Partners? | 4 | 2d |
Career Resources
Are these on the west coast or NYC?
Get an offer first.
And both are good and have their own strengths depending on what you want to do. There is no one size fits all. Otherwise, we would have already taken that job.
If you have both of those offers in hand, congratulations... that's great work! As far as deciding between the two, I am assuming that both are in NYC. There is really no wrong decision here, so I would make a call based on culture. Set up some phone calls with people in both groups and here them out. You can let them know your situation (just don't sound like an ass) and hopefully will see a clear difference between group culture.
Just remember you are going to be spending every living hour with the people you work with for at least a year or two... make the decision based on feel, because honestly there isn't a choice that will make or break you between the two.
Morgan M&A.
Goldman >>>> all
Only college kids salivate over GS.
Agree. Quite pathetic.
Morgan M&A
I'm far from a college kid and I salivate over GS... They are the best bank on the street, by far. No comparison.
That being said, if you just want to do PE, I'd probably pick MS M&A over GS healthcare. Both are really good groups, though. You have a champagne problem if you have to choose between the two.
Honestly, I like MS a LOT, I'd take an MS offer over a Goldman one, but since I'll probably never have to make that decision you might want to take my response with a grain of salt ;)
MS M&A.
MS M&A > GS FIG, TMT Its more technical , never ever do company profiles and work on real life deals rather pitches. BX,TPG,KKR will choose MS M&A over GS FIG/TMT provided both candidates are equal elsewhise.
stupid comparison. candidates are never equal elsewhere. bx,tpg,kkr will take whoever interviews better and any of those groups will position you well to get an interview provided you aren't terrible at your job
No. Wtf are you talking about? You're in college...
TPG took half their '10 associate class from GS TMT
Well, factors in my book: - PR (America hates Goldman, there's this huge ongoing mess with the SEC, and they probably have the biggest stigma in the whole Wall St. v Main St. argument) - exit opps (MS M&A > = GS TMT, the two have long been considered the best groups on the street) - subjective appeal (some people want to do different things. i.e. while consumer technology has long and always been a passion of mine, I don't know that I want to do pitches as much as technical work)
Plus the fact that I went through superdays in December with both banks and got a far better vibe from one firm than the other and committed to one as a sophomore, you can probably begin to figure out why I'm leaning the way I am.
America hating GS is really irrelevant, banks work for Companies not the American public. The issue is that GS is still by far, the best bank on Wall Street from the perspective of clients (which is really what I'm sure they care about).
MS M&A is a top group absolutely so no argument there.
You are going to pitch, if you don't want to pitch then don't bank. But top groups like GS HC and MS M&A, pitch less.
And I'm going to guess that your better vibe came because MS gave you a job and GS didn't. Most people will say GS has a by far better culture than MS (which people often find stuffy). And I think the future of MS is much shakier than any bank not named UBS. People are unhappy at the senior level and that only makes it infinitely harder at the junior level. I would place JPM ahead of them if comparing what 5 years from now could look like.
I say pick the one you felt better about during interviews. Both are top notch, so no wrong decision.
True go for it, not everybody can walk through the doors of 200 West Street...
MS M&A all the way, though GS HC is still a stellar group... but I still think GS TMT is THE top group on the street along with BX Restructuring...
Overall, GS > MS
however,
MS M&A > At least half of the groups at GS
Omg! The number of college kids giving their pathetic responses here is unbelievable. WORK BEFORE YOU GIVE YOUR OPINIONS!
//www.wallstreetoasis.com/forums/former-ms-ma-kkr-here-to-field-questions…
GS TMT >> MS M&A according to someone who FUCKING WORKS at KKR. Lesson? Work before you state your opinions on employers.
Disclaimer: I am a senior. Thus I am going to make no +ve or -ve comment regarding i-banks.
Seeing as the vast majority of you are still in college and have never so much as attended PE associate interview, you are doing the OP a disservice by acting like you are the authority on firm reputation and group exit opps. Both are great firms, and in those two groups, if you do well, you will be courted by every handsome buyout shop out there. MS M&A gives you a fantastic technical skill set and will allow you to work on very high profile transactions across most industry groups. GS Healthcare has also been getting on great mandates and performing well on the leagues. With that said, healthcare is actually considered one of the "relatively" weaker groups at our firm (along with real estate) and tends to have worse exit opps when compared to CR, Natural Resources, etc.
Goldman is great but at the end of the day, your experience is going to be similar give or take at almost any BB firm. I can't even count the number of company profiles I've done over the last year. Take what you read on these boards with a pound of salt.
Really voltaire? I thought HC was one of the best groups at GS and NR one of the weaker ones.
Actually HC is very strong at GS and NR is a very weak group. machinegunfunk you are right.
But OP here I would say MS M&A if you felt good about both places and both groups. If not, pick whichever one you enjoyed
KB you have no idea what the fuck you are talking about. NatRes has a small analyst class of 10 and sends roughly half to either well-known buyside firms or PIA. Don't give advice to someone making a career decision based on hearsay. For the record, I am not in NR.
Not sure why you're getting so angry but yes, analyst class of 10 and no half are not going to buyside. The last 2nd year class had 3 people stay as associates, and 2 left to MM PE firms, 1 to PIA, 1 to a HF and not sure what the others are doing. That's certainly not bad placement in fact its good placement but GS NR is not a top group and is one of GS's weaker groups.
And my advice is not wrong or hearsay, in fact I'm speaking from experience.
Voltaire, how would you compare the boutiques to GS?
this is a ridiculous thread come back with an offer. also everyone saying GS> over everything just wants to blow lloyd. Do some research better yet get some first hand experience before you start handing out advice.
Direct quote from the Director of commodities trading at a BB..."Take fit over name or perceived prestige"
Please don't tell me my better vibe came from one giving me an offer while the other didn't.
.
MS M & A if you liked the people. Otherwise I would go with GS even if its HC.
Amet impedit voluptas amet sunt neque rerum. Natus necessitatibus voluptas consequatur doloremque et molestias. Consequatur quia iure doloribus.
Ipsam voluptatum quidem eos id nihil atque magnam. Dolorem molestias quaerat velit quae nihil eaque.
Repellat quibusdam velit tempore incidunt consequatur praesentium praesentium. Fugiat expedita repudiandae iusto. Ut rerum blanditiis et error.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Exercitationem voluptate ut et veniam voluptas sit. Voluptatem quia et omnis ullam qui eligendi rerum. Quia natus sequi ut praesentium et quae. Aspernatur deleniti voluptate a facere asperiores. Consequatur voluptatem ducimus inventore ut.