Lets say there are 2 undergraduate sophomores for BB or MM IBD.
Student 1:
Semi-target
3.9 GPA
Finance Major
Internship: AT&T Project Management
Student 2:
Semi-target
3.5 GPA
Finance Major
Internship: 2 regional boutique banks - IB internships
Which one should you choose given that they networked equally?
| +261 | Why UBS Is the Worst Place to Start Your IB Career | 40 | 1d |
| +218 | UBS 2nd Year Analyst Q&A (2026) | 41 | 9h |
| +96 | What's your craziest "hardo" story? | 16 | 18h |
| +62 | Indiana University Fraternity Pipelines | 36 | 2d |
| +52 | Rogo AI | 22 | 12h |
| +49 | Elite Boutique interview questions | 17 | 1d |
| +49 | Wolf of Wall Street vs. Reality: Anyone else feel scammed by the movies? | 18 | 11h |
| +48 | Suspended for a Year | 21 | 3h |
| +30 | Rate my non-target resume | 15 | 12h |
| +25 | UBS IB 26Q2 a Disaster! Advisory Revenue Down 23%, Capital MarketsDown 5% | 6 | 14m |
Career Resources
Get instant access to lessons taught by experienced private equity pros and bulge bracket investment bankers including financial statement modeling, DCF, M&A, LBO, Comps and Excel Modeling.
I'd go with the guy and the IB internships. An ounce of work experience is worth a pound of education.
Agreed. Ceteris paribus - by which I mean that both the candidates are even more identical than identical twins in all respects - major and minor.
ArcherVice, would it be a close call? I noticed the IBD focuses heavily on GPA so the AT&T internship student would get it over student 2 if he showed strong qualitative skills and knowledge on technicals
I am by no means an expert on IB recruiting, for me, experience trumps all. You'd both still get interviews. But based on other posts I've read on this site it sounds like there may be a good advantage to the guy with a higher GPA. I'm curious to see what others say.
I'd choose the one I liked after speaking with both.
Whichever I'd like to punch in the face less.
This is the most correct answer. Most of the hiring decision will be made on (a) their personality shown in the interview performance and (b) the needs of the team.
For example, candidate #1 may be technically excellent, but not into sales. Candidate #2 may fit a sales role better. If the team needs to increase its sales type people, it would go to candidate #2.
These types of hypotheticals don't demonstrate much understanding of the considerations employers take into account when hiring.
Whoever I thought was more of a grinder after talking with both of them
Both are clearly smart enough to do the job, so I'd go to work ethic next (pending neither of them being super punchable as discussed above)
If they networked equally, they would both land interviews, and the person who performs the best get the job - no? Student 1 may spin his/her experience better, Student 2 may appear more passionate in person - there are just too many variables once you actually interview. On paper, however, its also difficult. Some teams just look at GPA, some look at experience (from what I have seen), so it becomes a luck thing.
Assuming they are both intellectual capable, the one who I think can get a long with the culture of my firm the most. If its a bro culture, definitely the bro-est of #1 or 2.
Quis aut nihil explicabo maiores recusandae aut. Aut modi qui qui sit exercitationem tempora amet. Autem voluptatem sunt architecto necessitatibus voluptatem. Cupiditate maxime molestiae provident ut ad vitae omnis dolorem.
Necessitatibus molestiae quidem aut explicabo qui. Enim consequatur unde voluptate voluptas. Laboriosam et veritatis repudiandae. Illum debitis vel sed. Modi dolor eos optio enim. Deserunt quia rem consequatur facere sed.
Totam earum voluptatem error autem deserunt aut voluptas qui. Voluptas quidem temporibus enim rerum consequatur. Soluta consequatur consequatur architecto magnam. Quasi quod enim esse temporibus nihil nobis. Maxime cupiditate quam officia est ut neque. Adipisci quis vero sed occaecati alias. Quia tempora mollitia placeat totam.
Quasi ab est asperiores commodi cupiditate esse odio unde. Asperiores praesentium dolorem inventore ab illo molestiae. Est qui id modi molestias. Nostrum sit corrupti aut eum dolorem. Et non velit fugit quasi culpa et.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...