Impact space - bubble or AUM balloon with no carry
All
Long time reader, rare poster. Using burner. Currently in the space mentioned below, but due to concerns about how attractive it will be to for realising carry in the future (vs just building AUM), I am considering finding a firm with a different focus.
What is your perspective on the impact space and the attractiveness of the field going forward?
From what I see, there is a lot of capital being raised, sometimes by less experienced or disciplined GPs which leads to crazy valuations for quality assets. This is further challenged by the need for measuring impact (CO2 reduction or equivalent), which means the assets that are high quality and provides high impact, are getting chased to even higher valuations.
At the same time, the difference between VC, GE and more mature PE is getting more blurry, which means different risk/reward profiles are chasing the same opportunities and driving up valuations. This seems to create the biggest issues for the GE space, where many players are making (small) minority investments in assets that even at decent scale has not proved to be economically viable.
The regulatory/political backdrop also seems to be worsening in the current economic outlook. This seems to have intensified as a few larger blow ups are becoming public (more to come).
Finally, it seems that a lot of assets has a mix of characteristics from infra (need for long term patient capital etc) and VC (unproven at scale or unproven unit economics) are being funded by firms positioning as PE/GE, when in reality the risk reward profile warrants a totally different portfolio construction. Add in the regulatory risk for some of these and it seems risky. The same kind of schizophrenia seems to be present other places as well, like “product as a service” businesses that rents out products on a subscription basis and are getting SaaS revenue valuation multiples.
Clearly, a lot of positives exists as well. Less senior people in the space creates white space for building a career and profile. Working in an area that has a positive impact on the world has some value to it as well. However, if you are in the game for the opportunity to realise carry in the medium to long term: is this the place to be?
Bump
Generally, there are two types of funds. There are those which use ESG/impact criteria to screen out opportunities and then there are those which deploy in opportunities for the sake of allocating capital for the greater good. The latter have a lower cost of capital and play in a different part of the market. The LP base can overlap between the two, but the former tends to invest in more adjacent industries like e-learning or second degree businesses like business services for solar panel maintenance.
There WAS a lot of capital being raised. The fundraising struggles are even more real in the impact space now than they are in other parts of PE/VC.
Agree 100%
Bump
Bubble. can trade thoughts on anything specific in DM
pretty good feedback in this thread below about TPG rise / climate
https://www.wallstreetoasis.com/forum/private-equity/tpg-rise-rise-clim…
Et error asperiores qui est. Tempora repellendus rerum exercitationem autem et. Harum ut numquam accusantium vero. Non ducimus magni doloremque pariatur voluptates harum cumque dolorem.
Quasi quod sed neque repellat. Ex quibusdam eum aut quibusdam non magni possimus est. Voluptas laborum reiciendis voluptatibus voluptates architecto consectetur. Unde earum eaque deserunt voluptate dolorem. Nihil ut occaecati odio ipsam consequuntur. Distinctio quo quod sint distinctio libero voluptate.
Excepturi aut sit harum provident error. Rerum voluptate hic iste repellendus ut sunt libero. Et ut deserunt sapiente quis voluptatum est ut. Nesciunt velit mollitia unde totam debitis quis ea debitis. Inventore distinctio laborum quae id magnam aut hic.
Eos voluptas debitis et harum saepe temporibus vitae numquam. Velit reprehenderit quam molestias.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...