ROIC vs ROCE

What Is ROIC Vs ROCE?

Understanding financial metrics is important for investors to determine the profitability of an investment. A key metric is Return on Invested Capital which is net operating income divided by invested capital.

The ROCE, on the other hand, is the Return on Capital Employed. This metric is found by the operating result divided by the capital employed. The two ratios have identical numerators in their formulas, suggesting that the denominator is what differentiates their values.

ROIC uses invested capital as the denominator, while ROCE uses all employed capital as the denominator. Invested capital is the amount of capital circulating in the company, while employed capital is all of a firm's capital.

The invested capital is, therefore, a subset of the capital employed. Capital employed includes all aspects of the company's capital, such as debt and equity. Invested capital includes active capital in circulation and excludes idle assets, particularly those no longer in operation, such as securities held by other companies.

Finance professionals and investors can use a variety of measures to estimate the efficiency with which a company uses its invested capital to generate profits.

These two key profitability metrics use similar values ​​to provide unambiguous information about health. If you work in finance or investing, knowing these return metrics can help you understand how an investment works.

This article defines and explains the differences between the two financial measures.

What is ROIC?

ROIC is a rate of return that measures the returns investors get on the capital they have invested in a company. It shows how efficiently the company uses the funds provided by the investors to generate revenue.

Invested capital is a subset of employed capital and is the percentage of actively invested capital in the company. It is calculated by dividing net income after tax (Net Income Dividends) by invested capital.

Return on Invested Capital is a financial metric that relates a company's net operating income to invested capital to show the profitability of an investment in the company.

To calculate, divide the company's net operating income by the invested capital, which is the percent of the capital currently used to operate the company.

Because a company's invested capital can fluctuate over weeks or days, some investors average the company's invested capital on the first and last days of the year to get a single number that describes capital.

This is the formula:

(Net income after tax/invested capital) x 100,

For example, a small business may have $350,000 in net income in one year. If the company's average invested capital is $2 million, its ROIC is calculated as follows:

= (350,000 / 2,000,000) x 100

= 0.175 x 100 = 17.5%

This company has a return of 17.5%. In general, the higher the return percentage, the more profitable the investment since the relatively high percentage shows that the company's use of the invested capital can generate dividends for the investors.

Components of ROIC

Some components of the ROIC are:

1. Net Operating Profit After Tax

Net operating profit is an after-tax cash amount generated from a company's use of resources, available to all investors, shareholders, and creditors.With every appraisal or monetary appraisal among the helpful tools that investors use, companies often manage their bottom line with this value.

Net income is essential, but it can no longer consistently reflect the actual ordinary overall performance of a company's operations or the effectiveness of its managers.

A better title is NOPAT, which standardizes the scale because it's the profit a company makes when it has no debt and no financial assets.

You can better examine organizations with different debt percentages and different asset bases by using NOPAT when selecting net income. NOPAT is an example of the income a company would have if there were no taxes.

It is a more authentic statement of a company's profits as the mileage driven multiplied by the correct amount of cash generated. Using operating profit instead of interest and tax (EBIT) gives you a biased kind of money because EBIT is calculated on an accrual basis.

2. Invested Capital

Invested capital is the investment made in a unit of an industrial organization during its useful life with the useful funds of shareholders and debtors. Shareholders invest in the organization's shares, while debtors invest money in short-term or long-term debt, including bonds.

Invested capital is the main driver of the business organization: it finances the daily operations. Also, it enables the business organization to carry out investment planning projects, including acquiring and acquiring important current assets.

How to Calculate the ROIC

Here are the steps to calculate using an example: ABC Corporation reports an EBIT of $60,000 on its income statement, and its marginal tax rate is 25%. In addition, the agency has $45,000 in short and long-term debt and $75,000 in equity financing.

Someone has $2,500 in retained earnings, $2,000 in cash for funding, and $3,000 in cash for investments, interest, and taxes (EBIT).

Adjust EBIT – For use within the NOPAT formula, the EBIT must be adjusted for taxes. First, you need to understand the agency's marginal tax rate.

The marginal tax rate is the tax rate that the agency pays on your final dollar earnings. Multiply EBIT by useful resource to use [1 marginal tax rate (t)]

Formula for ROIC numerator:  

= EBIT(1-t) 

where

• t = company's marginal tax rate

Calculation: 

$45,000 = $60,000 (1-0.25)

Now we'll calculate invested capital: 

1. Balance Sheet and Cash Flow Statement 
   To calculate the denominator of the equation, you need access to the company's balance sheet and cash flow statement.
2. Consider Debt Financing 
   Calculate the total amount of debt the company owes. This calculation includes current liabilities plus long-term liabilities on the balance sheet.
3. Consider equity financing
   Calculate the total amount of equity financing of the company, which includes the common stock and retained earnings accounts on the balance sheet.
4. Look at the cash flows. 
   Add the investing cash flows and the financing cash flows from the cash flow statement.
5. Formula for ROIC Denominator
   Invested Capital = Current Debt + Long-Term Debt + Common Stock + Retained Earnings + Funding Resources + Investment Funds.
6. Calculation 
   $127,500 = $45,000 + $75,000 + $2,500 + $2,000 + $3,000
   ROIC = Net Operating Profit After Tax / Invested Capital 
   = $45,000 / $127,500 = 0.35

What is ROCE?

ROCE stands for Return on Capital Employed. A profitability indicator calculates a company's profit on its employed capital. It is calculated by dividing earnings before interest and taxes (EBIT) by capital employed.

When a company's return on capital employed is higher than its cost of capital, it means the company has used capital efficiently to generate profits. 

Companies should aim to generate progressively higher returns over the years as it can indicate the company is stable and an attractive investment option for investors.

Return on Capital Employed relates a company's net operating income to its capital employed and can also provide insight into return on investment by showing the company's overall financial health.

To calculate, divide a company's net operating income by its capital employed, i.e., the total amount of money a company has at its disposal.

Capital employed includes all assets of a company and fewer current liabilities, which are financial obligations that the company could repay before the end of the year. Here is the formula to calculate ROCE:

(Net Operating Income Before Taxes/Capital Employed) x 100

Example: A company with employed capital of $6 million could have an annual pre-tax income of $800,000. x 100,

= 0.133 x 100 = 13.3%

This company has a ROCE of 13.3%. Investors generally prefer companies whose ROCE percentage is higher than the interest rate they borrow.

A relatively high ROCE can show that the company is making a profit on every dollar borrowed. If a company's ROCE is above the industry average, that could also be a sign of stability.

Return on capital employed is generally considered a better indicator than the return on equity, as the former looks at profitability relative to equity and debt. As a result, it is often used to compare companies in the same industry and on a similar scale.

rOIC VS. ROCE

The scope of ROCE is broader than ROIC, as the former considers total capital employed, i.e., the sum of debt and equity financing with fewer current liabilities.

ROIC is refined and calculates a company's performance based on the capital actively circulating. A company is considered profitable or effective when its return on capital employed is greater than its cost.

The ROIC of a company can be said to be profitable if the ROIC value is greater than zero. On the other hand, if the ROCE is below the cost of capital or if the ROIC is negative, the company needs to use the invested capital effectively.

Both metrics can help an investor predict the return on investment, but the two measures focus on a company's profitability.

1. Role of intangible assets

These two profitability measures relate differently to intangible assets that cannot be quantified, such as Customer value, intellectual property, or patents. 

Since intangible assets have no defined financial value, they may not be included in the ROIC calculation. Intangible assets can affect cash flow and other capital components employed, thus the ROCE calculation.

2. Impact of Cash Holdings

Companies with large cash holdings can have a much lower ROCE than ROIC, making it difficult for investors to predict dividends.

When investors calculate ROIC, they don't consider cash as part of investment capital because it currently has no investment purpose.

Because cash on hand can reflect a company's overall security, this amount is included in a company's employed capital.

Investors can use additional scores and information about a company's typical cash balances and dividends to help decide on an investment strategy. For a well-financed company.

3. Tax implications

These two financial measures treat government taxes differently in their calculations. ROCE evaluates a company's total assets before taxes, while the other reflects invested capital and taxable amounts of money.

From a business perspective, ROCE could offer a more accurate view of the company's overall health as it focuses on profitability.

4. Measures were taken into account.

ROCE considers the company's operating result, i.e., earnings before interest and taxes (EBIT). Others consider the company's total net income that remains after all taxes and dividends have been paid.

5. Percentage of Capital Employed

Return on Capital Employed considers the total capital a company employs in its industry. This includes stocks and other long-term debt obligations like loans and bonds that a company would have used to further its business.

ROCE also considers the capital that the company uses for activities other than income generation. As a result, the return on invested capital takes into account only the capital invested and actively used by the company in producing goods and services.

This is the main reason why return on invested capital only considers a company's fixed assets, intangible assets, and working capital, as these represent the company's investments to generate revenue.

6. Perspective

ROCE is a key profitability metric used to look at things from a company's perspective. It is more useful for the company than for an investor. ROIC, as a financial metric, is used to see things from an investor's perspective.

It is extremely useful for investors as it allows them to determine their expected returns on the invested capital.

7. Reported Ratio

Return on Capital Employed is a good indicator of a company's management ability to generate revenue. In addition, the return on invested capital is a good indicator of the productivity of the company's working capital.

It is extremely useful for investors as it allows them to determine their expected returns on the invested capital.

Researched and Authored by Kaustubh Bhamare

Free Resources

To continue learning and advancing your career, check out these additional helpful WSO resources:

• Amalgamation
• Budget Variance
• Carry Benefits
• Near Money
• Operating Profit Margin