My team is comparing ROICs of three different companies in the same industry over a multi-year period (8-10 years). We have found a weaker correlation between the stocks’ returns and the average ROIC over the same period, where the company with the highest ROIC has actually performed the worst in the market. Beyond incorrect calculation, what are some of the potential reasons for this?
| +38 | Strategy to asset allocation | 10 | 3w |
| +36 | Q&A | Research Associate, Long-Only | (0 years in DCM/IB/consulting) | 12 | 3d |
| +17 | Working for Endowment? | 8 | 2w |
| +14 | Early career insurance AM - should I just thug it out? | 3 | 1w |
| +8 | Bridgepoint Acq Kayne Anderson RE | 2 | 2w |
| +7 | CPP Early Investor Program (Summer 2027) Check | 5 | 6d |
| +6 | Goldman Sachs Operations? | 1 | 2w |
| +6 | MBB to Banking Career | 1 | 2w |
| 0 | BlackRock increasing SA comp? | 3 | 1w |
Career Resources
Get instant access to lessons taught by experienced private equity pros and bulge bracket investment bankers including financial statement modeling, DCF, M&A, LBO, Comps and Excel Modeling.
My thoughts:
If you give more color on the ROIC components for each company other things might come to mind.
This is excellent. How would you compare ROIC to ROE and ROA? How should investors think about them and use them, and are some more important than others in certain scenarios?
ROIC is the gold standard & what you should be mainly using, and it also has the huge advantage that it pairs directly with WACC to tell you if a company is meeting its cost of capital. ROCE is a close variant you'll often see management team's using to benchmark their own performance but as an investor I would stick with ROIC.
ROE shouldn't be the main metric you rely on since it gets massively distorted by how much debt a company takes on (e.g. is this really a business that's creating more value than peers or just one that's levered itself up to its eyeballs?), but it doesn't hurt to use it alongside ROIC since a sensible amount of debt can indeed improve returns for the equity holders.
The only thing ROA has going for it is that it's standardized & easier to calculate (since both net income and total assets are reported numbers vs 'theoretical' values like NOPAT and IC that you won't find anywhere in an annual report). Maybe other people have a different view on this though.
Good points from the above poster. Also have a look at what pricing did (in addition to growth and any adj. necessary to calculate the right ROIC). A high ROIC company that was priced too high can show lower stock returns despite having a higher ROIC than the comp group just because it was trading too expensive.
Ut vitae saepe omnis saepe est. Minus rerum odio vitae est. Id dolorem quibusdam quasi est tempora est deleniti qui. Voluptas rerum nostrum aspernatur.
Et nesciunt animi possimus laborum amet earum et. Sit natus vero quidem architecto qui. Rerum aut modi molestiae. Quod illum unde quia dolor.
Molestias illum consectetur et quibusdam iure. Aut quae commodi voluptas animi sunt fuga. Et cupiditate dolorum rerum.
Nemo quos earum corporis natus quae officia voluptatem. Voluptates totam excepturi assumenda quia. Sit quaerat consequuntur fugiat et porro ipsa ut.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Distinctio sed pariatur debitis nemo ex officiis fugiat. Saepe adipisci perspiciatis enim quis. Iste et ut laborum laborum excepturi. Autem nisi amet ipsa aut recusandae harum. Debitis fugit id ipsam modi nostrum et ut. Illum dolor minus deleniti unde. Corrupti quam vel nam consequatur mollitia esse placeat.
Quam quis aperiam quo quia nostrum quibusdam. In vel odit sunt. Aspernatur sed illo rerum deserunt. Quae qui rerum vel officia.
Voluptatem et qui maxime enim. Animi sed adipisci a pariatur nobis pariatur.
Voluptatem error officiis quidem deleniti. Beatae qui tenetur itaque ipsam. Earum maxime tempora sed. Omnis et eligendi quia perferendis dolore ea. Et earum et impedit eveniet repellat enim. Et neque temporibus officiis praesentium dolorem aut. Blanditiis voluptatem nemo et vitae vel placeat.