ROIC vs Returns

My team is comparing ROICs of three different companies in the same industry over a multi-year period (8-10 years). We have found a weaker correlation between the stocks’ returns and the average ROIC over the same period, where the company with the highest ROIC has actually performed the worst in the market. Beyond incorrect calculation, what are some of the potential reasons for this?

6 Comments
 
Most Helpful

My thoughts:

  1. ROIC is only half the story with growth being the other driver. You know that a high ROIC business with low growth gets only marginal benefits from further increasing its ROIC & should be focusing on growth, and vice versa for a high-growth business with a low ROIC. So the best spot for value creation is a goldilocks zone of good ROIC & good growth rather than one extreme. So if we're talking 2 companies with very good (say 25%) ROICs & good growth and one company with a very very good (30-35%+) ROIC but low growth, it might make sense the former are creating more value. 
  2. If you're looking only at historical ROIC it may be that investors have expectations that ROIC is going to inflect up for the lower ROIC businesses, or don't believe that the high ROIC business can sustain its edge. (or equally you might realize the names are under/overvalued based on their track record & the market isn't facing up to reality). I'm not a semis guy but an example I can think of is TSMC, to my uninitiated brain at least it screens as offering a pretty nice ROIC/structural growth profile for what it's trading on vs competitors but you have the unique risk of a Chinese invasion hanging over your 5-10 year investment horizon. 
  3. If you're taking adjusted profit to calculate NOPAT you could very well mistaking the company with the lowest earnings quality (e.g. most juiced by adjustments) as having the highest ROIC. Also make sure you punish them for share based comp in the NOPAT. I take reported operating profit & only 'exceptionals' I'll usually allow them are some components of PPA I think would be double charging.
  4. On the topic of adjustments, even if you take reported profit you may be allowing lower quality businesses to get away with it on the invested capital side by aggressively amortizing acquired intangibles or writing down their goodwill (which flies under everyone's radar since this usually gets removed from adjusted metrics). 

If you give more color on the ROIC components for each company other things might come to mind. 

 

ROIC is the gold standard & what you should be mainly using, and it also has the huge advantage that it pairs directly with WACC to tell you if a company is meeting its cost of capital. ROCE is a close variant you'll often see management team's using to benchmark their own performance but as an investor I would stick with ROIC. 
ROE shouldn't be the main metric you rely on since it gets massively distorted by how much debt a company takes on (e.g. is this really a business that's creating more value than peers or just one that's levered itself up to its eyeballs?), but it doesn't hurt to use it alongside ROIC since a sensible amount of debt can indeed improve returns for the equity holders. 

The only thing ROA has going for it is that it's standardized & easier to calculate (since both net income and total assets are reported numbers vs 'theoretical' values like NOPAT and IC that you won't find anywhere in an annual report). Maybe other people have a different view on this though. 

 

Good points from the above poster. Also have a look at what pricing did (in addition to growth and any adj. necessary to calculate the right ROIC). A high ROIC company that was priced too high can show lower stock returns despite having a higher ROIC than the comp group just because it was trading too expensive. 

 

Illo eos a omnis voluptatem harum facere. Qui porro sunt perferendis sint debitis. Cupiditate excepturi dignissimos blanditiis est delectus et qui. Sed sint sit qui magni molestias velit consequatur architecto. Minus est distinctio sit debitis. Iure odio numquam quia soluta provident commodi.

 

Consectetur eum consequatur beatae praesentium a possimus fugiat. Ut laborum sint nostrum voluptas voluptatem laborum temporibus eos. Velit numquam impedit distinctio excepturi quia sint aut eligendi.

Sunt doloribus eos tempora ab deserunt voluptatem tenetur. A corporis ratione blanditiis reiciendis iure totam aut. Voluptatibus totam repellendus non. Ut aut praesentium occaecati.

Career Advancement Opportunities

November 2026 Investment Banking

  • Evercore 01 99.5%
  • Moelis & Company 01 99.0%
  • JPMorgan 01 98.4%
  • Guggenheim Partners 02 97.9%
  • Morgan Stanley 06 97.4%

Overall Employee Satisfaction

November 2026 Investment Banking

  • Moelis & Company No 99.5%
  • Morgan Stanley 02 99.0%
  • Evercore 01 98.4%
  • Banco Santander 04 97.9%
  • BMO Capital Markets 13 97.4%

Professional Growth Opportunities

November 2026 Investment Banking

  • Evercore 01 99.5%
  • Moelis & Company 01 99.0%
  • Morgan Stanley 05 98.4%
  • Goldman Sachs 01 97.9%
  • JPMorgan No 97.4%

Total Avg Compensation

November 2026 Investment Banking

  • Vice President (17) $409
  • Associates (58) $261
  • 3rd+ Year Analyst (8) $210
  • 2nd Year Analyst (29) $183
  • Intern/Summer Associate (16) $161
  • 1st Year Analyst (84) $151
  • Intern/Summer Analyst (77) $101
notes
16 IB Interviews Notes

“... there’s no excuse to not take advantage of the resources out there available to you. Best value for your $ are the...”

Leaderboard

success
From 10 rejections to 1 dream investment banking internship

“... I believe it was the single biggest reason why I ended up with an offer...”