Compass Lexecon Interview Question
I have heard that Compass Lexecon asked this question in a phone interview. I have an upcoming interview there and want to prepare. I realize there is probably a low chance of me getting this question, but it is bugging me that I can't figure it out. I feel I have a pretty good grasp on basic econ and industrial organization, yet I can't decide on a sinario or walk through any reasoning. Any input would be much appreciated!
"Say the biggest firm and the second biggest firm merge. In scenario 1, you have a market with 10 firms and the largest two firms have 20% and 30% of the market share, respectively, and then the rest of the firms split the market share equally between the rest of them. In scenario 2, there is a market with four firms and the top two have 20% and 30% of the market share and the rest of the market is shared equally between the other two. Which of these two scenarios is more troubling?"
Apparently scenario 1 is supposed to be more troubling. I was leaning more towards scenario 2 though.
Comments (19)
Quantify troubling please.
From the viewpoint of the market? The competitors? The merged firms?
Thanks for the qualifying question. This is meant to be viewed from the general effect on society. So, basically view it from the DOJ's point of view.
Looking at HHI the first scenario takes it from a moderately concentrated market to a highly concentrated market, while the second simply remains a highly concentrated market (albeit more concentrated in both scenarios). Maybe they are assuming that the new increase in market share will allow the company in situation 1 to exert more bargaining power over the suppliers / customers, thus leading to higher prices which is bad for the consumer (why the DOJ would care). Although I'm with you thinking that scenario 2 is more troubling as it has a higher HHI (therefore the market is less rivalrous, making collusion/price fixing easier. Worse for the consumer).
Anyway, just my 2 cents
May be substantially harder for the other 8 firms in scenario 1 to compete with only 6.25% market share each, compared to the newly merged firm with 50%.
Scenario 2 limits options, but the firms are closer in market share and are likely able to compete more evenly with each other. There is still competition in the marketplace, albeit not much.
Compass Lexecon interview (Originally Posted: 02/27/2011)
I have an interview at Compass Lexecon next week. Please advise as to how should i prepare. What type of questions should I expect? Will the WSO Consulting case interview guide be useful? I would appreciate if people would share their interview experiences at Compass or similar firms.
Here is the Job Description if it helps:
As part of our team-oriented approach, Analysts work closely with staff economists to provide in-depth economic analysis of the relevant issues in each matter. Analysts work on cases involving a broad spectrum of matters related to economics – providing critical insight in legal and regulatory proceedings, strategic decisions and public policy debates. While each project presents a different set of challenges, Analysts can generally expect to perform extensive data analyses, conduct industry research, and review case evidence.
think CSI, but instead of how many years, its how much $$$
bump
anyone??
which office are you interviewing for? depending on which office your questions can be very different. the chicago office is pretty serious while the new york office is more chill and laid back
very impressive. Compass Lexecon is pretty elite
Compass Lexecon interview 0 (Originally Posted: 03/20/2013)
.
What office is this?
NYC
interviewed with them last week as well. have u heard back?
Just pm'd you
Either of you hear back yet?
Voluptas a voluptatem eum repellendus et voluptatem. Pariatur voluptatem dolor vel hic perspiciatis quibusdam non aut. Officia illo ut ad aut autem assumenda. Ipsa et sequi vitae illum.
Quia architecto voluptatem explicabo consectetur. Officiis quisquam dolorum suscipit enim omnis est omnis. Quisquam veritatis deleniti est natus. Laborum ut nisi ut beatae ullam ut ea consectetur.
Quis modi qui sint deserunt ducimus. Exercitationem voluptas nobis quibusdam eum vitae ipsa. Tempora pariatur voluptates sunt placeat id est qui.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...