Picking between 2 offers in different industries
Hello monkeys... I'm in a predicament.
Thankfully I've had the opportunity to land 2 offers for Summer 2025 and still have pending interviews as well. It's been a journey for sure. But I'm not sure which offers to choose from as they are both great! My biggest goal is to go IB, but these are not IB roles which is okay but I want to make sure I get the best experience possible to position myself for IB full-time.
First Offer: This is a bank (think Capital One or Ally) that has a Middle Market Banking Arm solely focused on providing debt solutions to PE Firms and PE backed mid-sized companies. They are in growth mode and looking to continue growing, the outlook is great and they also have a great culture and opportunities. I would have the chance to work on securitizations, warehousing and portfolio management for asset managers and PE backed firms. This opportunity is in Washington DC and will be paying in the $25-$35 range with a nice relocation stipend.
Second Offer: This is at a Consulting firm (think FTI, Alix, A&M). I'd be working on the Financial Due Diligence team within M&A Transactions practice. This is a consulting firm with a great reputation, WLB, and good culture. This opportunity is in New York (my dream city I want to live in). This will be paying in the $35-$45 range with no stipends at all.
I'm not sure where to go, but I'm grateful to be in this position and just want to make sure I position myself for future success. Any help would be awesome. Thank you!
Based on the most helpful WSO content, here are some key points to consider when choosing between your two offers:
First Offer: Middle Market Banking Arm
Second Offer: Consulting Firm
Considerations for Future IB Positioning:
Relevance to IB:
Location:
Compensation and Benefits:
Company Growth and Culture:
Decision-Making Tips:
Ultimately, both offers have their merits. If proximity to IB firms and living in your dream city are top priorities, the consulting firm in New York might be the better choice. However, if you value the specific experience in debt solutions and the growth potential of the bank, the Middle Market Banking Arm in Washington DC could be more advantageous.
Sources: Received offers from all three MBB firms and don't know what to do, Advice on career and the switch into investment banking, Advice From an Advisor to Senior Wall Streeters, 30 and a bit lost in career - Advice Appreciated, Rising Junior Losing Hope and In Need of Advice
Take Offer 2
Why is that?
Porro aut hic sapiente sit. Aut et nobis atque dignissimos dolorum explicabo accusantium.
Qui numquam ex qui dolores porro culpa assumenda. Eum sed aut veniam labore iste.
Beatae aliquam et velit et aut sed dolorem. Reiciendis et dolorem atque ut. Numquam enim similique dolores officia voluptate tempore. Delectus voluptate pariatur exercitationem. Commodi atque qui deserunt est porro est.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...