Hi, I have a few job offers I'm entertaining, but I've narrowed it down to two and I'm having a difficult time deciding so would love perspectives.
New employer: higher title, salary $750K, potential bonus $800k. The bonus is performance dependent and is majority based off the entire company's effort, less individual effort. The last 3 years the bonus has been closer to $140k, but it's been higher in the past. The pay is obviously tilted towards stability and I would not expect there to be much meaningful growth, if any, in total comp any time soon. Work life balance they profess to be good and weekends are protected.
Current employer: They are rebidding me in hopes of me staying. Current base is $300k, bonus they are offering is $800k. They will not promote me now, and will not guarantee I will receive one, but I'm told I'm at the top of my group's list to be submitted for this year. If I do in fact get promoted, I would assume my salary moves to $400k. Bonus is based on subjective individual effort and they could easily cut my total comp in future years. One manager told me comp tends to stay +/- 10% year over year. That probably feels right, but I've seen it take larger hits, down 17-18%. Even down 20%, that would put my all-in comp in line with the new job on bad years.
The main difference is the work life balance is stupid, think 16-18 hours a day, and 5 to 7 days a week, indefinitely. And this pace likely will not let up for years to come. But there is the potential to keep growing total comp. Next step function would be closer to $1.5m, then $2m, and $5m. It would take years to get there, but there's at least a path to keep growing. I have a great relationship with my manager and team, and generally have built up a good reputation already.
Sorry for the tldr, but I'd really love to know what others' perspectives are.
This is a classic dilemma of short-term stability versus long-term growth potential, and the decision ultimately depends on your priorities and tolerance for risk. Here's a breakdown based on the most helpful WSO content:
New Employer: Stability and Balance
Current Employer: Growth and Upside
Key Considerations:
Work-Life Balance: If you value time outside of work or are concerned about burnout, the new employer offers a much more sustainable lifestyle. The current employer's pace could lead to health or personal sacrifices that may not be worth the financial upside.
Risk Tolerance: The current employer offers a higher ceiling but comes with more volatility and uncertainty. If you're comfortable with the risk and willing to endure the grind, the potential rewards are significant. However, the new employer provides a more stable and predictable path.
Long-Term Goals: Consider your ultimate career and life goals. If you're aiming for financial independence as quickly as possible and are willing to sacrifice balance, staying with your current employer might make sense. If you're looking for a more balanced life with solid earnings, the new employer is the better choice.
Health and Personal Life: The current employer's demands could take a toll on your physical and mental health, as well as your relationships. If these are important to you, the new employer's work-life balance might outweigh the financial upside of staying.
WSO Wisdom:
Many WSO threads emphasize that while chasing higher comp is tempting, the trade-offs in health, relationships, and personal happiness can be significant. As one user put it, "You can always make more money, but you can't buy back time or health." Another common sentiment is that a sustainable career path often leads to better long-term outcomes, even if the short-term comp is lower.
Recommendation:
If you're early in your career and willing to grind for a few more years to maximize earnings, staying with your current employer could make sense. However, if you're already feeling the strain or value balance and stability, the new employer offers a strong package with less risk and a healthier lifestyle.
Ultimately, the decision comes down to what you value most: stability and balance or growth and upside.
Sources: Work/Life Balance - Hours, https://www.wallstreetoasis.com/forum/consulting/just-got-promoted-how-to-negotiate-salary?customgpt=1, Job offers which would you choose?, Who is happy & satisfied with their current role?, Fired as 1st year analyst?
Amet recusandae itaque et sit. Eligendi ab id ullam nemo magni excepturi. Ut quisquam id necessitatibus. Tempora dolor dolore sunt reprehenderit nesciunt voluptatum.
Alias omnis ipsa exercitationem doloribus eligendi saepe odio. Non est officiis expedita doloribus. Qui nihil eum fugiat optio maxime est officia. Eum repellendus quo ullam perferendis.
Ullam aut sit porro modi voluptatem est illo. Maiores distinctio nobis rerum dolorem sint sunt quae.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...