Starting in Real Estate Development

Been reading threads on here for a while and am recently in a posistion where I would appreciate some guidance. Little background, I am in a 5 year MBA program and wrapping up this spring while I work for a value add developer in a northeast market. It is a decent size shop, more than 60 people and properties in five states. Unfortunately, I haven’t been doing much of the type of work I was hoping to do, such as underwriting and sourcing deals. My role is more of a development management role where I coordinate with attorneys, architects, engineers, and GCs. I have been there four months and this has been the extent of my work. The principal of the firm took me out to lunch today and told me he wants to know if I would like to stay on post graduation. He wants me to grow into a role where I am taking more work off of his desk and gn the road with him and the partners to check out deals. He told me being taken under the wing of a developer straight out of School is a great opportunity to learn a lot quickly.

My entire dilemma is I feel like I am skipping a step in the sense that I am not learning much underwriting or getting any Argus experience. Prior to working with the firm I was an intern at HFF where I did a lot more valuation work. I would like to become a deal guy down the road and feel like it is imperative to understand how to value assets. I have interviews lined up with HFF, Duff and Phelps, and Altus group this spring. Thoughts?

I feel like most people go into developement after starting in valuation, brokerage, or REPE. While I find it valuable to be taken under the wing of the principal and groomed, I feel like I am skipping a valuable step in the process. I am currently the youngest guy in the office by 10 years and feel there is opportunity to grow. If I did stay any thoughts on what to ask for salary.

Overall looking for career path advice. I know I’m all over the place here.

 
Best Response

I was in investment sales and I didn't learn much in the way of underwriting other than "standard" expense metrics for multifamily. This helps when underwriting the stabilized portion of a development but that's about it. I certainly didn't learn how to think about development deals.

What I've learned now that I'm pursuing development opportunities on my own and through speaking with seasoned developers (millions of SF+) is that the underwriting is pretty simple from a financial engineering perspective. For example, see the thread about cap rate spreads. That's what all most big developers underwrite to—including shops like Avalon. They'll have an analyst do the DCF for investors but, if you speak candidly with executives, they'll tell you that IRRs are meaningless. There are too many moving parts that affect timing throughout a multi-year development.

So it seems like you have an opportunity to learn how a successful developer thinks and manages the process. It also sounds like you'll be able to get pretty good at learning how to do cost projections, which is way more difficult than learning how to interpret rent comps. Most developers aren't financial wizards so don't feel like that's the only path to success. In fact, the wealthiest developers I know aren't finance savvy at all. They use very basic metrics based on a strong understanding of costs and the market.

Hope that helps.

 

Thanks for all the thought. Very good points. What’s are your thoughts on Duff and Phelps and valuation shops? I know the work sucks but I have heard it’s a great place to start. As I said I feel like I’m missing a vital piece of the puzzle by skipping some form of analyst role. I am the youngest guy in the office by 12 years and know that he is hoping I can grow into a role to replace his right hand man who is the oldest guy in the shop.

Also, why comp package do you think is fair being the youngest in the shop. I was going to ask for 60k with a bonus structure. Any suggestions?

 

I don't know much about comp structure since my career experience is either in investment sales or now being an entrepreneur on my own. Others will be able to help with that.

Regarding valuation shops: if you're a truly capable individual in a position to move up the ladder quickly then working at a valuation shop is a waste of time and potential.

I'm getting the vibe (and I hate the word vibe) that you're a box checker that thinks it's necessary to learn through working your way through specific positions—call them rungs on a ladder. If you want to learn how to underwrite, do the following:

  • Buy Roger Staiger's book and work through it line by line
  • Take a few ULI online courses taught by Roger
  • Download HFF Offering Memos for whatever product type you're in
  • Reverse engineer a dozen or so offerings I've worked through REFM, Breaking Into Wall Street, and all of Staiger's stuff and his is the most practical foundational work that you can continue to build off of. REFM is gratuitous. EDIT: I forgot to mention to buy Peiser's book: "Professional Real Estate Development" which is sold through ULI. This has tons of practical underwriting methodologies that are immediately applicable.

You now know the technical side of modeling better than 99.9% of brokers and first-year analysts.

Take the information you learn on the development management side of things—arguably the most important and applicable information out there—and use it to engineer a model for your firm's most recent acquisition. See if you can make sense of it. If you can't, discuss with the owner why he made the purchase and adjust your model accordingly. Do this a few times and you now know how the owner's thought process manifests itself in a spreadsheet.

You can then retire to a villa in the Mediterranean while only taking calls from Steve Ross when you feel like it.

 

Assuming you have a job now as this is over a year ago. Nonetheless, I did valuation at a small firm and I lasted about 3-4 months. I was impressed by the guys who worked there as they were all super intelligent, had CFAs or a JD, but it turned out to be mind numbingly dull and repetitive. The most fun I had at work was snooping on rich people's expenses, like seeing that some old lady spent $250k on landscaping a year. Would not recommend because you develop very niche skills which do not transfer anywhere, so instead of the guy that writes reports, once you get to the top, you get to read reports written by others & correct grammar all day.

 

Not sure how going to a Duff & Phelps doing basically institutional appraisal will advance your career and knowledge more than continuing to grow at your current firm.

Why not just stay if you like it there and love Development and try and get more exposure to the deal aspect at the firm? The best experience for Development is actually getting the hands on experience with a developer in which you are currently getting. I realize you want to learn more of the Finance aspect, but if you truly love Development, there is a lot more to it than just financial modeling.

 

Second this. Appraisal isn’t going to help. You’re already in development which is the goal of a lot of the kids at HFF, JLL, etc. Why take a step backwards?

If you want to learn about finance, valuation, and modelling, pull a Will Hunting and buy a textbook or two. A quick google search led me to “Foundations of Real Estate Modelling” by Roger Staiger. The description for the book is as follows:

“Foundations of Real Estate Financial Modelling is specifically designed to provide an overview of pro forma modelling for real estate projects. The book introduces students and professionals to the basics of real estate finance theory before providing a step-by-step guide for financial model construction using Excel. The idea that real estate is an asset with unique characteristics which can be transformed, both physically and financially, forms the basis of discussion.

Individual chapters are separated by functional unit and build upon themselves to include information on:

Amortization Single-Family Unit Multi-Family Unit Development/Construction Addition(s) Waterfall (Equity Bifurcation) Accounting Statements Additional Asset Classes

Further chapters are dedicated to risk quantification and include scenario, stochastic and Monte Carlo simulations, waterfalls and securitized products. This book is the ideal companion to core real estate finance textbooks and will boost students Excel modelling skills before they enter the workplace. The book provides individuals with a step-by-step instruction on how to construct a real estate financial model that is both scalable and modular.

A companion website provides the pro forma models to give readers a basic financial model for each asset class as well as methods to quantify performance and understand how and why each model is constructed and the best practices for repositioning these assets.”

I would much rather read that book on the weekends than leave development to go work for in a different part of the industry, and then try to get back into development.

The only thing that might be of benefit from working at HFF would be learning sales and how to raise capital.

 

Getting a development or acquisitions position in this market environment can be quite difficult. If this is a reputable, well-capitalized shop with good deal flow and a decent structure where you can get some mentorship, it is definitely worth considering sticking around. Personal opinion is:

1) Tell this guy up front that you are concerned about getting some of the valuation/front-end deal experience. Offer to spend extra time helping the acquisitions or capital markets teams. I'd be willing to bet almost anything he sees it as a positive for your overall development and reciprocates by including you in acq/dispo meetings, letting you look at models, etc. 2) If you are in a good shop, there is an incredible amount of information at your fingertips. For example, at my company when I have down time I just dig through the shared drive for other departments and read stuff to get educated. 99% you will be able to pull up acq models and dig through them/teach yourself, or come up with questions for other people at the company. Again, nobody will see this desire to learn as a negative. 3) Underwriting jockeys are a dime a dozen in this business. There are far, far fewer development guys that know how to put together a deal through entitlements/design/construction effectively than there are analysts with underwriting experience. It may be a great niche to develop, if it interests you.

 

With the understanding that people are different and have different goals, this is all very confusing to me.

JackyD:
Been reading threads on here for a while and am recently in a posistion where I would appreciate some guidance. Little background, I am in a 5 year MBA program and wrapping up this spring while I work for a value add developer in a northeast market. It is a decent size shop, more than 60 people and properties in five states. Unfortunately, I haven’t been doing much of the type of work I was hoping to do, such as underwriting and sourcing deals. My role is more of a development management role where I coordinate with attorneys, architects, engineers, and GCs. I have been there four months and this has been the extent of my work.

Being a development manager is what development is. Sourcing and underwriting deals takes up 5% of a developer's time? Maybe less?

JackyD:
The principal of the firm took me out to lunch today and told me he wants to know if I would like to stay on post graduation. He wants me to grow into a role where I am taking more work off of his desk and gn the road with him and the partners to check out deals. He told me being taken under the wing of a developer straight out of School is a great opportunity to learn a lot quickly.

It is, and more importantly, it sounds like you'll be progressing from managing deals to sourcing deals.

JackyD:
My entire dilemma is I feel like I am skipping a step in the sense that I am not learning much underwriting or getting any Argus experience. Prior to working with the firm I was an intern at HFF where I did a lot more valuation work. I would like to become a deal guy down the road and feel like it is imperative to understand how to value assets. I have interviews lined up with HFF, Duff and Phelps, and Altus group this spring. Thoughts?

NOI / Cap rate. That's how assets value. It's not rocket science.

JackyD:
I feel like most people go into developement after starting in valuation, brokerage, or REPE. While I find it valuable to be taken under the wing of the principal and groomed, I feel like I am skipping a valuable step in the process. I am currently the youngest guy in the office by 10 years and feel there is opportunity to grow. If I did stay any thoughts on what to ask for salary.

Overall looking for career path advice. I know I’m all over the place here.

I think you're dealing with not fully understanding the hierarchy in real estate while existing in a role that is not what you want to do. It sounds like you want to be in acquisitions, not development. Nothing wrong with that - it's just different.

Most people start in brokerage or whatnot because they have to - because 99% of the time developers and REPE firms don't take kids straight out of school. Your consternation about skipping a step is amusing in this sense because skipping a step would be a dream to most.

I don't mean to sound dick-ish, but as someone on the ownership side, and that refers to development and private equity, I would never in a million years go back to doing third party shit. It's both going backwards and down the ladder.

If you don't like development and want to be a "deal guy" - either try and find an acquisitions role with a REIT or ownership group or just tell your boss that is your goal, because it seems like that's where your boss wants you to trend anyhow.

Commercial Real Estate Developer
 

Yeah I think CRE is spot on here... You basically have an opportunity to skip one of the 'box checking' steps that most of us had to go through to get to the role that we really wanted. You can spend a few hours a week when you start learning how the underwriting works, and you can master excel in the process which is really all you would need to do on the MF side anyways. You may have a steep learning curve at first with respect to having to learn underwriting and the other parts of the role, but a crash course is probably the best way to learn.

"Who am I? I'm the guy that does his job. You must be the other guy."
 

One of those paths, could potentially set you up after 5-7 years to go out and do your own deals. Hint: Development. Have you heard of the 10,000 hours principle? Take the development job and work towards that 10,000 hours. Become a master early, because many of us wish we could have started earlier. Also, I agree with everything said above.

 

I worked for three years as a development associate at a similar shop, and now work in investment sales as an associate. I think you learn more about real estate as a whole in development than any other business line. However, development is very lumpy and dries up quickly when credit freezes. Development is also (obviously) very market/asset class sensitive unless the developer is truly geographically and asset class diversified . I would love to be with an active industrial developer right now, but would be very worried if in power center development.

My advice would be to go the HFF route if you get in with a big office with tons of deal flow or get in with a small office that has a shortage of analysts, where you will have a chance to quickly become the go-to support guy. You want to know who you will be working under - tie your wagon to a stud broker, especially one with a diversified book of debt/structured finance origination. This, IMO, is the best place to be because you are spread across many asset classes. If you know you will be in investment sales, try to get on a multifamily, industrial, or office (only office if under a big power broker) team. I would steer clear of retail, self storage, hotel, and land right now.

I can really walk you through this if you want to PM me.

 

There is definitely more turnover in brokerage, but less so at HFF than competitors. That said, I would not have made the move if I wasn't plugged in to support a big multifamily broker. Also - I left community/power center development where opportunity was drying up quickly.

Just my two cents, but I think we are nearing the end of the development cycle across most asset classes in large markets. As interest rates rise, thin YoC spreads over the debt constant will disappear and projects won't get funded. We are seeing quality core assets getting refinanced with long-term fixed rate debt; meanwhile, clients are realizing the bid/ask spread on non-core stuff is growing, and the window to dispose to lock in gains is narrowing.

 

Dude, nearly exact same boat here but smaller shop. $200M AUM and 6 people in the office however I am doing everything from acquisition/analyst to project management to development management. I feel for you cause we don't have enough equity to go check out deals every day so I have to deal with engineers, TI's (we buy office in SoCal),city permits, etc. Thanks for posting this question cause the responses made me feel much better. I still try to learn the waterfall, ARGUS, and underwriting on my own but our owner will help me out if something is wrong however he won't train me on how to do it.

If misery loves company, what does success love?
 

Enim et accusantium qui architecto perferendis sunt excepturi accusamus. Eligendi expedita libero qui possimus maxime non accusamus dolor. Fuga sed voluptatem suscipit facere. Ducimus qui in autem. Quia et vel eos voluptas et sunt non. Eos eveniet temporibus magni earum et est odio et. Ut dolorum et et expedita quasi illum.

Inventore occaecati voluptatibus eaque maiores voluptatum a. Fuga minima dolor distinctio voluptatem rem.

Reprehenderit rerum iusto quia perspiciatis nisi rerum aliquam repudiandae. Nihil laborum est sint iusto.

Odit et in consequatur assumenda et eum molestiae. Iusto maiores eligendi rerum molestias. Delectus voluptatem eos voluptatem nihil aliquam possimus placeat.

If misery loves company, what does success love?

Career Advancement Opportunities

March 2024 Investment Banking

  • Jefferies & Company 02 99.4%
  • Goldman Sachs 19 98.8%
  • Harris Williams & Co. (++) 98.3%
  • Lazard Freres 02 97.7%
  • JPMorgan Chase 03 97.1%

Overall Employee Satisfaction

March 2024 Investment Banking

  • Harris Williams & Co. 18 99.4%
  • JPMorgan Chase 10 98.8%
  • Lazard Freres 05 98.3%
  • Morgan Stanley 07 97.7%
  • William Blair 03 97.1%

Professional Growth Opportunities

March 2024 Investment Banking

  • Lazard Freres 01 99.4%
  • Jefferies & Company 02 98.8%
  • Goldman Sachs 17 98.3%
  • Moelis & Company 07 97.7%
  • JPMorgan Chase 05 97.1%

Total Avg Compensation

March 2024 Investment Banking

  • Director/MD (5) $648
  • Vice President (19) $385
  • Associates (86) $261
  • 3rd+ Year Analyst (13) $181
  • Intern/Summer Associate (33) $170
  • 2nd Year Analyst (66) $168
  • 1st Year Analyst (202) $159
  • Intern/Summer Analyst (144) $101
notes
16 IB Interviews Notes

“... there’s no excuse to not take advantage of the resources out there available to you. Best value for your $ are the...”

Leaderboard

1
redever's picture
redever
99.2
2
Secyh62's picture
Secyh62
99.0
3
BankonBanking's picture
BankonBanking
99.0
4
Betsy Massar's picture
Betsy Massar
99.0
5
kanon's picture
kanon
98.9
6
dosk17's picture
dosk17
98.9
7
GameTheory's picture
GameTheory
98.9
8
CompBanker's picture
CompBanker
98.9
9
DrApeman's picture
DrApeman
98.9
10
Jamoldo's picture
Jamoldo
98.8
success
From 10 rejections to 1 dream investment banking internship

“... I believe it was the single biggest reason why I ended up with an offer...”