Fired!

You are not going to believe this...

I was just FIRED from my Analyst position working in the Real Estate Private Equity Group of a large bank for.. get this.. having music files downloaded on my computer!!!

HR just showed up one day without warning, interrogated me about what files I have downloaded on the company's computer, and after I told them the truth (I had nothing to hide) they just let me go. No previous warning, nothing. And this was a few days after I received an EXCELLENT review from my manager. They said I violated 'corporate policy.' Whatever.

If you know anyone who needs a good real estate analyst just reply to this post. I can give you plenty of references to back up my story.

Anyone else have stories like this?

41 Comments
 

I am assuming that the songs were illegally downloaded. Then I can see it happening (not really, but kind of). Right?

"I'm not sure what the four 9's do, but the ace, I think, is pretty high."
 

My father works at UPS and he downloaded some music on his computer at work, and they threatened him with his job, and he is a regional manager. They do not mess around with that kind of stuff cause they can fines up the ass. That is unfortunate.

 

Is even iTunes against corporate policy? It's perfectly legal to buy songs from iTunes.

"We are lawyers! We sue people! Occasionally, we get aggressive and garnish wages, but WE DO NOT ABDUCT!" -Boston Legal-

"We are lawyers! We sue people! Occasionally, we get aggressive and garnish wages, but WE DO NOT ABDUCT!" -Boston Legal-
 

wow that really sucks. Must have been illegal downloading right? Did you try to apologize and say you weren't aware/ ask for that manager to vouch for you...

Oh well, lots of people got fucked this year. Seemed like a awesome job too...

 

Wow. Thanks for the heads-up at least, really sorry to hear about that. Good news is that a lot of RE PE shops (yeah, smaller ones but nice pay potential) seem to be hiring right now.

A friend of mine from a BB RE PE shop was recently fired and got another job about 3 weeks after, securing 5-8 interviews in just 2 days. He upped his base to a 100, with higher bonus prospects too. I believe he used basic professional sites, ie. monster etc.

Best of luck.

 

While I do feel terrible and do not believe you should have been fired over this without some sort of a warning ... What were you thinking? Illegally downloading music using a corporate computer? Not only that, but if you were doing so illegally then I assume you were using a standard downloading program like LimeWire. These sites are full of bogus files with viruses attached to them.

Again, I'm not saying the bank's action was justified, but I think you exercised some pretty poor judgment on this one.

CompBanker’s Career Guidance Services: https://www.rossettiadvisors.com/
 

Yep I used limewire, which was the main issue, but corporate network is secure so any confidential info was absolutely safe.

I did not know that downloading from P2P programs was illegal. I also mentioned to my managers that I had music files downloaded on my computer and they thought it was completely ok and gave me no caution to delete them (tons of people have music on their computers too).

HR identified me through a random search. They asked me if I knew that these files could contain viruses and encrypted files and I said absolutely not. When they came in to talk to me it was 2 people, in their mid or late 40's. These people didn't know about limewire, or have any clue about current technology. They don't know that every college kid in america downloads music. They totally out of touch with our generation, so when I explained everything to them they just didn't get it. They thought I was some sort of hacker and that limewire is some new crazy advanced hacking program. And like I said before, I received ZERO warning whatsoever.

Next step for me is to find another job. This one was ok, but working PE within a bank is not so cool, its much better to work within your own fund. I will definitely move on to something with less of a corporate-type culture. Moral of this story is that if this company is dumb enough to fire a good employee for something like this, then its not good company to work for.

 

[quote=REbanker]Yep I used limewire, which was the main issue, but corporate network is secure so any confidential info was absolutely safe.

I did not know that downloading from P2P programs was illegal.

You must be a complete retard. You had no idea that P2P programs were illegal but you can make the statement that the "corporate network is secure so any confidential info was absolutely safe."

Obviously, we did not get the full story and from you comments I highly doubt you had an excellent review. Even though you were "at-will" it sounds like the bank found an excuse to fire you will covering their own ass.

There is more bad news for you though...since you were fired for cause you can't even collect unemployment. What a moron.

 

That's extremely unfair, I'm really sorry to hear about what happened to you. If they had an issue with music downloading, the appropriate thing to do would be just giving you a warning.

Hope you find something soon.

 
Best Response
  1. Yes, everyone downloads ILLEGAL music on to their computers, but it is just that ILLEGAL. You did something illegal, where every other day in the news there is an article about fines, arrest, confiscations of property and what not for doing the same thing.

  2. To make things worse you did it on your work computer. Had you merely brought in music to work, this would be a little over kill.

  3. You can get viruses and whatnot through limewire if you aren't careful. And since you didn't know that half of the files on limewire and bearshare are crap, you probably weren't careful.

  4. At will employment. They could fire you because they don't like the way you dress today if they so felt. Probably not a good idea for them to do so since they might have to justify it, but possible.

  5. Technology training/waivers etc. Most jobs, schools, internet cafes make you sign a little thing that expressly prohibits things like downloading files. Heck, I know where I've worked that includes legal files, installing things on your computer, using computers for personal reasons, etc, etc. So basically you violated everything in the technology code.

  6. You wouldn't think they were out of order for firing you for sending a sensitive document outside the firm because you didn't know any better. Or on your first sexual harassment charge. Or whatever other policy that you can't believe they would fire you for.

Finally, think about this from the firm's point of view. You broke numerous rules, you broke numerous laws, exposed the firm to potential liabilities from a client management and monetary prospective, its a tough market where they probably were looking to downsize anyways. Sorry to come down so tough on you, but they fire people for watching youtube, or for personal calls, so this really doesn't surprise me.

--There are stupid questions, so think first.
 

They don't fire everyone who watches youtube at their desk, nor everyone who makes a personal call at their desk. But they do fire people who do so.

The point was they fire people for much more trivial things.

--There are stupid questions, so think first.
 

Powermonkey's got the right idea for the most part, if a little brutal on the whole. I'd say banks are a wee bit more liberal about the personal usage of computers that they let you get away with, since they restrict the accessible sites, the computers (usually) must always be on the network, and since you're in the office for most of the day. I'm talking about surfing the web, specifically.

I would think anyone with half a brain would have totally given up on limewire and even bitorrent for music and movies, though, especially with all the pre-lit settlement letters and such going around. Don't people realize that just about every "free" p2p network has been completely compromised by the RIAA and MPAA? A not insignificant portion of the files have been uploaded by just those groups so that they can track precisely who is downloading. Unless you really are computer savvy and know how to protect yourself, give up on getting the stuff for free until the next big thing hits and the watchdog groups are left with their d*&^s in their hands playing catch-up. Seriously, was even a few hundred dollars worth of music worth getting fired?

 

for some reason i don't have much sympathy for you. You aren't a kid anymore, I guess you lacked sense of professionalism for the real world. There's black and white policy against what you've done. Haven't you been told in your very first day at bank that what you've done is a big "no no"? i don't find this an overkill. It does seriously open up serious potential liability in terms of litigation against the firm. But worse yet, confidential data being leaked out of your computer.

The security system is as strong as its weakest link. In this case you were a pretty rusted link that jeapordize the whole link.

better luck next time buddy.

 

still i think he deserves sympathy b/c he just lost his job. i still remember when my uncle lost his job for some stupid reason and i remember his misery. Sorry to hear that REBanker. I hope you get an even better job with better prestige/pay/lifestyle/HR. Can you ask your firm for reconsidering their decision by really explaining that you meant no harm or were unaware and are deeply sorry for your actions, something of that nature? But don't be sad man, you'll probably look at this experience in 10/15 years as a joke to tell your kids.

 

REbanker: why not hire a lawyer?

did they actually fire you or was it more like they terminated your contract... (if its the latter, then I'm sure you would have gotten decent sev and your manager would put in a good word for you).

you can't go around terminating people for whatever reason. i doubt they put "LimeWire" in the contract... you can easily argue that you thought it was a legitimate use of technology (akin to listening to online radio, etc.) and the fact that other analysts had used it makes it legitimate.

 
nilesREbanker: why not hire a lawyer?

did they actually fire you or was it more like they terminated your contract... (if its the latter, then I'm sure you would have gotten decent sev and your manager would put in a good word for you).

you can't go around terminating people for whatever reason. i doubt they put "LimeWire" in the contract... you can easily argue that you thought it was a legitimate use of technology (akin to listening to online radio, etc.) and the fact that other analysts had used it makes it legitimate.

It's probably in the code of conduct somewhere specifically dealing with technology use. At my internship, I remember over the summer that there was an issue because we couldn't load a web based application on IE and needed Firefox. It wasn't a big deal but our MD warned us and was basically like "look just don't download anything or install anything or it could be grounds for expulsion".

Limewire is pretty blatant. You are basically letting any random person make a remote connection to your corporate terminal. The security issues with that are just endless.

 

You can fire someone for any reason you want.

As PowerMonkey said:

"[you are an] At will employment. They could fire you because they don't like the way you dress today if they so felt. Probably not a good idea for them to do so since they might have to justify it, but possible."

 

Of course you can fire at your will, but you may have to pay money.

There is an implied contract between an employer and an employee... when you break contracts, you have to pay expectation damages, etc.

If the employee breaks the contract (by using limewire contary to the terms of the contract), then the employer can fire the employee (and alos seek pecuniary damages, etc.)

it happens all the time especially with senior management. its not about "employee standards" its just common law.

though i agree with you.. in europe there are a lot of socialist type labour laws (something like a 35 hour work week?)

 

No, you're wrong. Companies use severances for good will tactics typically, and for lay offs that lack any cause. If there is ANY reason, they can fire you with absolutely no money.

My mother was in senior management at a fortune500 company and was flown to NY, walked into the room and was told that "they no longer feel her experience is capable of handling her responsibilities". Obviously the biggest BS reason I have ever heard, but after 14 years with the company, she did not get a penny.

 

There is absolutely no requirement to pay severance or damages unless it's stated in the contract - look at the terms of your offer contract. Did you see any damages or severance fee type clauses? No.

And Niles - damages arise only if the bank is in breach of contract. In this case, there is no breach of contract because it's employment at will. If so, the case for damages don't even arise.

 

I see... then its different down south eh?

sheesh, thats real bad pal. 14 years... terrible. But I guess its free markets right.

still, sometimes, doesn't hurt to go see a lawyer and see if he/she can help you out.

 

Quia distinctio non ad enim eos in eos qui. Et veniam ut veritatis dolorum est eos unde aut. Quis impedit esse qui vel illo.

 

Quam velit deleniti sed cumque repellat similique aut reiciendis. Molestiae omnis aperiam numquam in officia. Est molestiae pariatur quas et et sit nihil non. Soluta aut quos quisquam adipisci blanditiis sint.

Eligendi non placeat fugit ullam illum at et. Adipisci cumque inventore quas aliquid dolor consequatur voluptatum. Debitis voluptas aperiam optio magnam hic aut numquam.

Corporis qui hic libero cum nisi temporibus aspernatur. Ducimus aut fugiat perspiciatis rerum aliquam omnis maxime. Velit molestiae pariatur molestiae magni id eos quis.

Et aut eos itaque et. Consequatur possimus perferendis beatae a ipsum hic. Minima id pariatur modi est. Recusandae sed non id qui reprehenderit.

 

Occaecati sapiente accusamus dolorem at ut quia. Dolorem natus et non quae et. Aperiam corporis nulla maxime voluptatem qui voluptas repudiandae.

Impedit architecto et explicabo exercitationem deleniti qui voluptatem. Nesciunt ipsum reprehenderit sed quos voluptatem at. Sit et et est. Quisquam fugiat officia similique inventore quibusdam sint ratione tempore.

Commodi nisi est et. Est asperiores et quasi consequatur et. Unde earum in natus dolorem aperiam.

Career Advancement Opportunities

June 2026 Investment Banking

  • Evercore 01 99.4%
  • Moelis & Company 01 98.8%
  • JPMorgan 01 98.2%
  • Guggenheim Partners 01 97.7%
  • Morgan Stanley 07 97.1%

Overall Employee Satisfaction

June 2026 Investment Banking

  • Moelis & Company No 99.4%
  • Morgan Stanley 01 98.8%
  • Evercore 01 98.2%
  • BMO Capital Markets 12 97.6%
  • Banco Santander 01 97.1%

Professional Growth Opportunities

June 2026 Investment Banking

  • Moelis & Company No 99.4%
  • Evercore No 98.8%
  • Morgan Stanley 05 98.2%
  • JPMorgan No 97.7%
  • BMO Capital Markets 12 97.1%

Total Avg Compensation

June 2026 Investment Banking

  • Vice President (14) $434
  • Associates (43) $259
  • 3rd+ Year Analyst (8) $210
  • 2nd Year Analyst (22) $179
  • Intern/Summer Associate (13) $156
  • 1st Year Analyst (75) $151
  • Intern/Summer Analyst (67) $101
notes
16 IB Interviews Notes

“... there’s no excuse to not take advantage of the resources out there available to you. Best value for your $ are the...”

Leaderboard

1
redever's picture
redever
99.2
2
BankonBanking's picture
BankonBanking
99.0
3
kanon's picture
kanon
99.0
4
Secyh62's picture
Secyh62
99.0
5
CompBanker's picture
CompBanker
98.9
6
DrApeman's picture
DrApeman
98.9
7
dosk17's picture
dosk17
98.9
8
Betsy Massar's picture
Betsy Massar
98.9
9
GameTheory's picture
GameTheory
98.9
10
bolo up's picture
bolo up
98.8
success
From 10 rejections to 1 dream investment banking internship

“... I believe it was the single biggest reason why I ended up with an offer...”