Positive PE Experiences?
I’m heading into a career in PE and this forum has me massively doubting my choices. I was well aware that PE would not be a “2x salary 0.5x hours job” as some imagine it to be, but some of the stories here just seem downright horrifying.
Like many, I enjoy Finance a ton. It’s stimulating and I’ve enjoyed reading about it my entire life. Since college, I thought PE was the job for me, and I’ve always wanted to feel like I am exposed to / investing in different businesses. However, post-IB, I was hoping have some non-negotiables, including spending time with a s/o and aging parents (I don’t intend on a perfect social/party life).
My ultimate question is: Has anyone had a GOOD PE experience? Professionally is one thing, but culturally? If you ultimately exited, where to? Is there a better career option out there that still fits a finance bro’s interests (e.g., VC, HF)?
Pe is more like a 1.5x the hours for .75x the salary job with option value if you are able to not get pushed out for 15 years until you make partner (extremely rare)
It’s been horrible for every aspect of my life outside of learning, professional development and comp (but still would likely make more short term in IB).
Has it been worth it for the development/comp?
There’s already another thread on this same topic. If you actually did your diligence on firm culture and investment process vs just picking based on brand name, you may be fortunate. Otherwise, I imagine it can be just as bad as people are saying. Take a step back and remember this is an online forum. The majority of people with good experiences don’t spend their time posting on this website. They’re living their life. It’s largely people coming to vent about hating their life looking for advice or college kids begging to break in without even knowing what they’re getting into.
I am curious since I am interested in Growth Equity. Some say it's closer to VC environment than normal PE , is that true?
no
My 2 cents:
PE gave me skills at a junction in my career where it paved the way for my next steps which was stepping into an independent advisor/operator role. LMM so more operationally focused than what folks are experiencing up-market. It also provided amazing relationships and experiences in holding responsibility that I wouldn’t trade
That being said, I find career stability very low, with little tolerance for deviation from the path. I find that way too rough and unnecessary and the industry is probably wasting a ton of human capital with its inflexibility and set in stone ways.
many a day I wish I had gone the harder skill route, either engineering or applied science. Despite lower pay, those skillsets are less commoditized and its way easier to learn deals especially as you develop muscle memory in business and get reps, at least in my experience.
Was a former CS major when it was sexy and contrarian to study computer science or engineering but sadly this skill set is also commoditized and likely over saturated from a human capital standpoint. Rough hiring market based on what I hear from my friends and introduction of LLMs made things even more interesting
Comsi/coding and broader engineering are separate things. You can’t really participate in developing new hard or soft-tech just with your PE experience. Even if some software jobs are becoming redundant, I view an engineering skillset as broader and more applicable to technology and systems across all sorts of industries.
What made you switch?
In UMM/large cap fund. I am based in EU but we have offices in the US. Pay at the fund is very good, and above IB (bonuses are better than IB, carry has been materialising for people). In terms of hours, I saw a net improvement in my WLB, social life, sport life, hobbies since I started. People in our US offices I would argue have a better life than in EU offices (hours & pay). Their hours are very good. It might be a bit tougher during deal sprints but these are limited in time (I.e. you won’t have another Phase II directly after finishing one generally) and tend to still be better vs IB hours. In deal sprint you can sometimes (but rarely) finishing ultra late (3am), sometimes goes to 1/2am but you’ll never have to pull an all-nighter, it would just be equal to mismanagement of the work streams which tend to not happen at all as people want to be efficient / don’t waste time. In Phase I deals or whenever there is no Phase II hours are great (not like a 9-5 but still very good especially considering level of pay).
Experience will vary a ton from fund to fund, hence just wanted to share a firm-specific datapoint. Firm is not a MF / ultra prestigious but has a good reputation in the finance world, you just won’t see articles on it every week.
Could you PM me?
If you could PM me too that would be awesome
Same could you pm?
Feels like there's a thread on this every day... It 100% depends on the culture of the firm you're going to. Some will be better than banking, some will be worse... Asking for anecdotal experiences isn't going to help you lol but yes I've had good PE experience, so you've got at least one to count on
My experience in PE was at a old UMM PE fund. My random thoughts below:
- I worked under a VP that was just a bad person (narcissist/pathological liar) and really made my life/job pretty difficult on a day-to-day basis to the point I thought about leaving early all the time. One of the Principals I worked with was the opposite and I would have taken a paycut to work under him for my 3-yrs at that firm.
- People were generally less abrasive than banking but somehow came off as worse although there are good people and you have to seek them out. I learned a lot about corporate politics / how to handle a bad apple (or a bad apple tree)
I would say this:
1) It depends entirely on the firm / person at the firm you work with although PE generally leans sharp elbowed / everyone out for themselves given how hard progression is and how much is reliant on others not progressing
2) It is a great job at its core. You are paid to learn about businesses and industries. Yes its intense and there is a high bar for the quality of work but I found myself more engaged with the day to day of the job than I did in banking although I miss the culture/people at my old banking group
3) Regardless of what you want to do with your life I would recommend it. Money rules the world and you are in the center of that in PE. Also for some reason, it makes you think big picture. In IB exits are PE, Corp Fin / Strategy, HF, AM, etc in PE, people feel like the world is their oyster
Are you no longer in PE? What are you up to now?
Lateral recruiting unfortunately. Contracted ended
Very good, because the whiners or people who couldn't last are already washed out, so all those who made it to VP+ have been very positive.
A lot of people I know who grinded hard for PE are not from rich families as well so their greed for money is real so they definitely work hard to chase them.
.
I had both great experiences and poor experiences. The difference is the team. No news there. But I found the variance in PE to be even greater than in IBD / other parts of finance.
I’m in BD (banker coverage) at an MM fund, and this is probably the closest thing to a dream job that I’ll find. I get comped very similarly to the execution team to hang out with people and talk about deals. It’s surreal.
How does hours compare? How do you like it vs IB
Hours are great. If I’m not on the road (which admittedly is anywhere from 1-3x a month), I’m home for dinner with my family almost every day. I’ll answer emails until I go to bed but I’m not cranking on memos or models or anything like that.
Can’t really compare it to banking, though I guess a few relationship-based sponsors group are somewhat similar.
Making it to VP does not mean you are going to last in PE. It is a STEEP climb, often the climb to Partner will not be available to you.
"I joined KKR because it was KKR. I didn't realize it just wanted to be buyside goldman sachs and now I'm getting killed for no Carry, help!"
Honestly for apparently intelligent people coming from top educations and sellside institutions I do wonder why people ever recruit for MF PE.
Part of me is glad because I wouldn't have as many clients as I do without them.
Would you prefer the career as a banker/public investor rather than PE? Many thanks!
Exercitationem et eaque asperiores totam fuga non doloremque. Porro illo ut maxime fugit vitae iusto quibusdam. Repellendus numquam dolorem labore ut expedita eveniet est.
Voluptates esse rerum neque delectus est. Exercitationem voluptas et minus molestiae laborum veritatis rerum. Perferendis ipsam nulla sunt dignissimos consequatur autem. Maxime voluptatibus enim quam.
Aspernatur esse nobis numquam dolor ut eos ducimus. Aspernatur eum occaecati voluptates porro omnis. Aspernatur dolores pariatur non corrupti sint culpa voluptatem velit. Dolorum quidem sit voluptas aut aliquam.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Ad velit tempore repellat iste rem sit beatae cupiditate. Vel porro sit quae ab. Praesentium officiis error rerum. Blanditiis et quia id voluptatem ab enim.
Eos quia ea aut eos. Aut cum sint deleniti quibusdam dolores. Temporibus ut et ex odit. Maxime eos illo unde.
Sit et veniam distinctio perspiciatis facere rem. Et et deserunt iste deserunt. Sed quos ut perspiciatis.
Soluta temporibus et illum voluptatem quis consequatur. Aut alias unde et alias deleniti rem laborum. Exercitationem impedit labore et ut voluptas et quae.