Buy Side Equity Execution Trading
Currently about a year into my career in a front office financing role at a bank and I'm looking to make a move into something more markets-facing. I have an opportunity to apply for an Equity Execution Trader (Analyst) role at a large fixed income-focused asset manager. Essentially execute equity/derivative transactions, work with PMs, monitor market activity/liquidity, provide color throughout the day etc... My main hesitation is that it's seemingly pure execution - implementing PM decisions, not generating investment views myself. A few things I'm trying to figure out:
- Does execution trading experience actually hurt you if you later want to move toward a PM-track role, or is that a non-issue if you've got CFA + can show you've been building investment thinking on your own?
- Are there realistic exits from an execution seat like this - into PM, or even other trading seats (rates, vol, etc.)? Or does it tend to be a track people stay on?
- Is this a better move than trying to grind for an S&T seat at a bank instead (sales or trading, something with actual risk-taking)? Trying to figure out if buy-side execution > sell-side S&T for optionality, or if it's the opposite. Obviously think that just being in the buy side building has its own benefits.
Anyone who's made a similar move, or who's closer to trading/PM hiring, honest takes appreciated - trying not to make a move that looks good on paper but boxes me in. Thanks!
Based on the most helpful WSO content, here’s what you need to know about transitioning into a Buy-Side Equity Execution Trading role and its implications for your career trajectory:
Execution Trading and PM-Track Aspirations:
Exit Opportunities from Execution Trading:
Buy-Side Execution vs. Sell-Side S&T:
Key Considerations:
Ultimately, the decision depends on your long-term goals and how you plan to leverage the role to build the skills and network necessary for your desired career path.
Sources: Sell Side Trading vs Buy Side Execution, LO to MM HF?, Routes to Buyside PM
Bump
Execution trading seats are really hit or miss. They could range from being a mindless execution monkey with some middle office work attached, to maybe managing a small allocation with a cash management mandate. Sometimes they translate into a PM-track role, but that is very dependent on the firm you land at. What could happen, and is often the case, is that you stay an execution trader as a career. If you have the opportunity or ability, I would rather recruit for a sales and trading role as that will likely have better opportunities into an investment role at a hedge fund
Source: I used to be an execution trader for a while thinking what you're thinking and it was not that at all
Can i please message you ? I just had an interview this week and i have a few questions. Thanks in advance!
sure
I sent it now. Thank you
a few things the other answers miss because your specific seat matters here.
equity execution at a fixed income-focused AM is a service desk. equities there exist to serve the bond portfolios - hedges, overlays, rebalancing. the desk doesn't run its own P&L. that's the weakest version of the execution seat for PM-track purposes: at an equity-focused shop you'd at least sit next to equity PMs, at an FI shop you're structurally far from the people who could sponsor you.
on why S&T screens better for PM: recruiter and HF screens price attributable P&L. sell-side seats give you something close - desk attribution, the flow you worked, product depth. pure execution gives you none. you implemented decisions, you didn't make them. the CFA signals intent but it doesn't fix that.
your best path might be the one you're already on. internal transfer at your bank from financing into an S&T desk is a higher-probability route to a risk seat than jumping to an external execution desk and hoping it converts. financing sits next to trading, people move between them all the time.
Thanks for the response - that makes sense. In terms of the path I am on (hoping to potentially be a PM someday), what do you think are the best steps? Currently in a NAV lending seat and don't know what the path to PM really looks like (I know a lot of, if not all have CFAs). Should I try to get to the public side in a sales and trading seat - whether internal transfer or external? I would assume trading gives me the best shot - but any input you have would be super appreciated.
Praesentium ipsa quibusdam nihil porro ut. Facilis non ea dicta deleniti neque minus. Et reiciendis consequatur quia nam totam enim iure. Iste aspernatur vero autem sit sunt fuga incidunt. Deserunt illum velit rem quam.
Provident similique provident iure ut aut. Earum deserunt qui aspernatur quam odio quo. Ex quia enim ullam eum molestiae esse. Necessitatibus et inventore officia corporis optio eos quod incidunt. Delectus ut sit atque officia et ab id.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...