Brain teaser
Recently got asked a brain teaser - what is the value of a tree that product $100 of cash year 1, $200 in year 2, etc.
Still can't figure out in case anyone has come across this
Recently got asked a brain teaser - what is the value of a tree that product $100 of cash year 1, $200 in year 2, etc.
Still can't figure out in case anyone has come across this
Career Resources
fucking infinity
pv of infinite cash flows:
pv= Σcf/(1+r)^t = Σ(100*t)/(1+0.05)^t
PV= 100/(0.05)*(1/ 1-(1+0.05)^-t))
let's say t=20y:
=100/ (0.05)*(1/(1-0.677429))
=100/(0.05)*(1/0.322571)
=6160
i think this is right, someone correct me if i'm wrong
Deleted
Yeah I think this is infinity because the way the cashflows work ($100 more per year as time passes, i.e. $100, $200, $300…), it’s like a stack of perpetuities. You can value a single perpetuity by discounting but can’t discount an infinite sum of them.
Answer should be 250,000 (@ 2% discount rate)
If you think about it as each tree starting in Y1, Y2, … , Yn producing a fixed stream of $100 each year when it starts, then you have a $100 perpetuity starting from Y1 onwards
Then, each year’s respective PV is $100 / (r-g) = $5,000 at r = 2% (remember each individual tree isn’t growing cash flows, rather there is just 1 additional tree starting each year)
Now what you have instead is a stream of $5,000 cash flows each year from Y1, Y2, … , Yn which can again be discounted at the growing perpetuity formula to get $250,000 at 2%
Sorry if bad formatting, on mobile
This is very close. I'm too stupid to figure out why the following is the case quickly, but the answer is actually 255K at 2%. So what you said plus the original PV of 5k.
I don’t think it will be infinity as the increase in t will make the discounted cashflow 0 beyond a certain point (e.g. 100,000 dollars discounted to the power of 1,000 will be close to 0 if the discount rate is above 1%)
However, without knowing the discount rate it will be impossible to know the exact value (and even then you would need a computer to find it)
So you are essentially receiving a $100 dividend each year. I would use Gordon growth method where
Intrinsic Value = Terminal CF * (1 + perpetual growth rate) / ( discount rate - perpetual growth rate)
The growth rate would be 0% since dividend stays $100/ year. I’ll use discount rate of 8% cause stock market.
V = $100 * (1 + 0%) / (8% - 0%)
V = $100 / 8% = $1250
(@ 5% = $2000 , @ 3% = 3,333)
In other words $100 into perpetuity is the same as receiving $1250 today iff your alternative investment returns 8%.
If I understood the question correctly, I don’t think the dividend stays the same. I believe it is modeled such as the dividend for year n is equal to n*100
As such, terminal growth cannot be easily determined as a % ( 300 is 50% more than 200, but 400 is 33% more than 300)
you might be right, but I've been asked a variation of this question where it was assumed constant $100/year into perpetuity (what value would I put on such a tree).
Otherwise the above answer is right. Each tree at 8% discount rate producing $100/year is worth $1250. Now you have 1 new tree/year…so you are just simply repeating the formula. Essentially you’re valuing infinite amount of trees with each tree’s value $1250 (same as single tree problem).
$1250/8% = $15,625.
(@2% discount it’ll be $250,000.)
Quia quo ab deserunt aperiam. Dolores est cum veniam molestiae soluta ipsam necessitatibus. Suscipit dolor ut sunt voluptas id consectetur in. Consectetur dolore suscipit inventore consequatur rerum voluptatem aut.
Rerum perferendis optio optio ea similique tempora. Et incidunt in voluptatibus ut officiis iste odio a.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...