Will any non-US IB ever reach the level of Barclays in the US?
Do you think any other full service IB that's not American will reach the level of Barclays in NYC (excluding UBS and boutiques)?
Considering:
Which of these do you think is in the best position to eventually compete with the US Banks in the next 10 years?
Based on the most helpful WSO content, Barclays stands out as a unique case among non-US investment banks due to its strong US franchise, largely built on the Lehman Brothers acquisition. This has allowed Barclays to establish a significant presence in the US market, which is rare for European or other non-US banks.
Among the banks you listed, none currently appear to be in a position to rival Barclays in the US within the next 10 years. Here's why:
Santander, RBC, BMO: These banks are primarily focused on their respective home markets (Spain, Canada) and have struggled to scale their US operations effectively. While RBC and BMO have had some success, they remain far from being full-service powerhouses in the US.
Deutsche Bank: Deutsche has faced significant challenges, including restructuring and scaling back its US operations. It is unlikely to regain the momentum needed to compete at Barclays' level in the US.
BNP, Mizuho, Nomura, MUFG: These banks have also struggled to scale in the US. Regulatory hurdles and competition from dominant US players make it difficult for foreign banks to establish a strong foothold. BNP and MUFG might have some potential, but they are far from achieving Barclays' level of integration and success in the US market.
In summary, Barclays' unique position as a non-US bank with a strong US franchise is unlikely to be replicated by any of the banks listed in the near future. Regulatory challenges, competition, and the need for significant investment in the US market make it difficult for other non-US banks to reach Barclays' level.
Sources: PNC to acquire BBVA's U.S. Operation - A sign of things to come, Investment Banks in 10 years - Ranking, What's up with the European banks and SA 2020? (UBS, DB, Barclays), Non US/Europe IB/PE Overview
I feel like none will really reach that same "level". But if I had to guess, it would probably be Deutsche/BNP/Nomura.
Currently at Barclays, here's how I'd rank the odds.
1. Deutsche
2. RBC
3. TD
4. BMO
5. Scotia
6. BNP
7. Mizuho
8. Nomura
9. Santander
10. CIBC
Et sint earum quo voluptatem voluptatibus et corrupti. Voluptate id dolore quo laudantium adipisci. Consequatur expedita laboriosam sit est.
Autem ea sequi ad est quae adipisci cupiditate. Magnam qui error est non beatae explicabo voluptas.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...