Seeking Career Advice
I'm looking for some career advice from people working in finance, particularly those in asset management, investment banking, corporate finance, or who have completed the ACA through a Big 4 firm.
I'm currently deciding between two options starting this September:
- A 5-year Audit Apprenticeship with KPMG, leading to the ACA qualification. I would start at age 19 and earn while I learn.
- BSc Accounting and Management at the University of Bath.
My dilemma is that I don't see myself staying in audit or accounting long term. My ideal career would be in asset management, corporate finance, investment banking, or another finance-focused role, ideally in London and potentially abroad in financial centres such as New York, Hong Kong, or Singapore later in my career.
The apprenticeship appeals to me because:
- Big 4 brand name
- ACA qualification
- Five years of professional experience
- No student debt
- The current graduate job market seems extremely competitive, with many students struggling to secure internships and graduate roles
However, I'm concerned that beginning my career in audit could make it difficult to transition into the areas of finance that actually interest me.
On the other hand, Bath has a strong reputation and may provide better access to internships, spring weeks, and traditional graduate recruitment pathways into front-office finance. However, there is obviously no guarantee of securing those opportunities.
For those who have worked in finance or recruited into finance roles:
- Which route would you choose if your end goal was asset management, corporate finance, or investment banking?
- How realistic is it to move from Big 4 audit + ACA into those fields?
- Would employers in these areas value the ACA and Big 4 experience more than a degree from Bath?
- If you were 18 again and had these two options in front of you today, which would you take and why?
I'd really appreciate any insights, especially from people who have either gone through a Big 4 apprenticeship or work in the sectors I'm aiming for.
Based on the most helpful WSO content, here’s a breakdown of your options and insights to help you decide:
Option 1: KPMG Audit Apprenticeship + ACA
Pros: 1. Big 4 Brand Name: Starting your career at a Big 4 firm gives you a strong brand on your resume, which is highly respected across finance and accounting roles. 2. ACA Qualification: The ACA is a prestigious qualification that can open doors to corporate finance, FP&A, and even some asset management roles. It’s also a stepping stone for transitioning into finance-focused roles like M&A or valuation within the Big 4. 3. No Student Debt: You’ll earn while you learn, avoiding the financial burden of university fees. 4. Professional Experience: Five years of hands-on experience will give you a head start in understanding business operations and financial reporting.
Cons: 1. Branding as an Accountant: Staying too long in audit can pigeonhole you as an accountant, making it harder to transition into front-office finance roles like investment banking or asset management. The "sweet spot" for transitioning is typically 2-3 years, as staying longer can limit your options. 2. Limited Exposure to Finance: Audit roles are not directly aligned with the skill sets required for investment banking or asset management, such as financial modeling or valuation.
Realistic Transition to Finance: - Moving from Big 4 audit to corporate finance or asset management is possible, especially if you leverage internal opportunities like valuation or M&A services within the Big 4. Networking and potentially pursuing an MBA later can also help bridge the gap to front-office roles.
Option 2: BSc Accounting and Management at Bath
Pros: 1. University Reputation: Bath has a strong reputation and is well-regarded by employers in finance. It may provide better access to internships, spring weeks, and graduate recruitment pathways into front-office roles. 2. Networking Opportunities: University offers a chance to build connections through career fairs, alumni networks, and societies focused on finance. 3. Direct Path to Finance: A degree can position you directly for roles in investment banking, asset management, or corporate finance, especially if you secure internships during your studies.
Cons: 1. No Guarantee of Success: The graduate job market is highly competitive, and there’s no certainty of landing internships or roles in front-office finance. 2. Student Debt: You’ll graduate with debt, which could be a financial burden early in your career.
Realistic Transition to Finance: - A degree from Bath, combined with internships and networking, can position you well for front-office finance roles. However, success will depend heavily on your ability to secure relevant experience during your studies.
Key Considerations:
WSO Insights:
Recommendation:
If you’re confident in your ability to network and secure internships, the Bath route may offer a more direct path to your desired career in asset management or investment banking. However, if you prefer a safer option with guaranteed experience and no debt, the KPMG apprenticeship is a solid choice, especially if you plan to transition strategically into finance roles later.
If you were 18 again, the decision would depend on your risk tolerance and confidence in navigating the competitive finance landscape. Both paths can lead to success, but the Bath route aligns more closely with front-office finance aspirations.
Sources: Accounting vs Finance: Part 1 – Career Paths, Accounting vs Finance: Part 1 – Career Paths
Dropping college and work for KPMG for 5 years straight?? Hats off to you
Autem et nihil consequatur molestiae atque. Quia tenetur corporis voluptas velit ipsa sint dolore. Omnis ipsum quia deleniti dolor pariatur et sint.
Pariatur deleniti voluptas dolore similique. Quia nemo quidem voluptatem dolor. Delectus et aut ut harum molestias et at. Eaque sunt eos sit.
Adipisci aspernatur aliquam eos distinctio nobis. Et veritatis dolor dolores. Dolorum voluptas quam qui veritatis quia at sed.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...