64 Comments
 

Just wondering, anyone has any ideas that usually on average how different are the bonuses of Sales and Trading people from IBankers of M&A?

 

If given a choice, I would definitely choose S&T anytime, anyday, anywhere. I'm doing an IB internship in JPM right now and honestly, the hours are totally F@#KED up. As an analyst, you are expected to put in at least 80-100 hours per week. The money's great, no doubt. But it's just not worth it.

In S&T, if the desk/group has a bumper year, the bonus can easily outstrip the IB analyst monkeys' bonus. Furthermore, a trader works like, what? 45-50 hours per week? Go figure which is better.

 

how much less? a few of us are in the range of 50k-70k, i'm sure a few others get 80k which is the top for first year in banking as well though i can't confirm. but it's definitely not inferior to banking even at analyst level.

 

anyone recommend any books to read to get an idea about the profession? Also, where should you be looking to start (position wise, not company) if you have an undergrad degree from a non-target, high GPA, good extra curriculars/ volunteer work, but not necessarily the strongest directly applicable internships?

 

At the analyst levels, the money is virtually the same. However, this changes later on (if you're good), as the top paid guy in a bank is almost always a trader and not a banker.

 

a prop trader? Obviously you have to be good as hell at what you do, but what is a "typical" (I use that word loosely) path to becoming a prop trader? Number of years/degrees? etc etc

 

i find it hard to believe that you can reel in $140k your first year out of college fetching hamburgers for 40 hrs a week, but i'll just have to take your word for it.

 
Best Response

3 things determine bonus for analysts outside of being in a program. 1. company performance, 2. group performance, 3) personal performance. If you are in a training program on the trading side, bonuses ranged in the 20K neighborhood for the first 2 years with base of 55-60K.

In MBS, analysts generally get 1X base salary. MBA or BA doesnt really play a factor on the T & S side. I think it applies more on the banking side. My experience for T&S has been that analysts working in BB banks will make for year end comp. approx. 120-180 all in.

In Ibank, generally analysts work for 2 year then get their MBA. Hence when they return, they come in as associates.

No BS totally speaking from experience

 

Fearing that you chose the wrong career path? Have fun slaving away for less money.

 
Fearing that you chose the wrong career path? Have fun slaving away for less money.

Have fun getting fired for your mediocre P&L and having nowhere to go.

Anyway, I'm not taking back what I said. A 1st year "trading asst" is probably not going to get paid $140k to "assist traders."

 

Just read a bloomberg article in the "agenda" section. It was reported that the top energy traders at MS and JPMorgan (Olav Refvik and George Taylor respectively) took home at least $10 mil in 2006. That compares with about $1.5 mil for top bond traders.

One thing's for sure...trader's bonuses are definitely way more than ibankers's.

 

It was reported that in the l999 and 2000, Frank Quattrone of CSFB made almost 500MM.

 

Last year the top trader at goldman made $45 million. And your right, most people dont make that much but on average, good traders make a lot more than good bankers. The trading department brings in a whole lot more revenue than M&A.

 

According to the 2005 annual reports of both GS and Lehman, trading revenues account up to 70% of their total revenue. Furthermore, on a per employee basis, traders definitely bring in more revenue than ibankers.

Just quoting off GS's 2005 revenue figures: Investment Banking: US$3.67 Bn Trading and Principal Investments: US$16.36 Bn

For Lehman's: Investment Banking: US$2.89 Bn Capital Markets (Trading): US$9.81 Bn

 

do you guys think there are huge differences in bonuses between the equity desk and the fixed income desk? what are the sales bonuses like in equities or equity derivatives?

 

In nearly every bank fixed income blows equity out of the water. With equity derivs you might be a little better off, but straight equities is where they send the idiots who can't cut it. As an example, look at all the finance Phd's coming out of all the top b-schools into structured FI trading; now try to find one on an equities desk.

 

What about structuring CDOs and credit derivatives? What's the best way to get in this field and what does the bonus look like for 1st year BAs?

 

equities are where all the jocks are. you don't need any sort of finance backround to trade equities. ED's are a different story though, plenty of quants in ED's.

 

Don't think about bonuses...think about profitability and how you can contribute.....the best traders these days are hardcore quant types who live and breathe trading, mathematics, quant research etc etc. Those king bond traders are math geniuses who have figured out an arbitrage that noone else can see (espescially the FI OTC derivatives boys and their exotic models). The P&L on these highly customised and illiqui deals is mind boggling and very sustainable....Increasingly trading is becoming the domain of quants and computer scientists....the cowboy days are nearing an end...quants with high level risk management abilities will rule the roost.

 

A friend of mine is trading derivatives in London @ BNP Paribas... he took home Eur15MM last year. The year before that he was north of Eur8MM. Pebereau himself (CEO of BNP Paribas) has to sign for his compensation package... He's one of the top 3 dogs in his department though.

 

I agree with not thinking about it, but for what it's worth it really is about 5-10k less than banking....total comp can therefore be 140K. And if you're on the right desk or smart enough, most of the time wont be spent getting food.

Additionally, being quant is great and all, but not all traders are quant. There is a fine line between being a good number cruncher / model builder, and being the head of a desk. The latter requires more personality/leadership skills, and some firms are willing to sacrifice raw math skills for the softer techniques. That said, being good at math is really, really important nonetheless.

 

I completely agree that the quants are taking over, equities are a much harder game then it was even 2 years ago esp as markets are moving electronic these days. on that note, right now i work for a small group of prop floor traders, i accidently saw their tax returns from a few years ago and it was mostly in the 3-10mm range, it is significantly less this year think under 1mm....not good for me since I'm a TA that just started with them this summer :(

 

The analyst ranges are the same, ibanking can be say 5k higher which is irrelevant. Where you fall in the band can cause some variability in your actual number.

 

It's great that this board is here to help people think about career paths, but there is a ton of misinformation here. Here's the basic lowdown

analyst salaries: sales and trading bonuses for bulge bracket positions at the analyst level are almost exactly the same as corporate finance

associate salaries: here's where the differentiation starts to open up depending on your position and how you're doing. traders> --If you're a trader, your salary is going to be based on your utility as a market-maker and on your P&L. for a first year associate on a desk with decent flow and couple bucks in P&L, between 250-300. --as your P&L scales, your salary will follow approximately linearly. there are definitely associates who will make over a million, but that of that as the 5-10% tail of the distribution; it definitely helps to be in a less commoditized product area sales & research> --if you're a saleperson or in research your take-home is going to be more or less in line with banking

vp salaries: --here's where the variation becomes much more significant. while you have a much better sense of how your salary will scale in corporate finance, in S&T it will depend highly on your P&L, which goes for sales and trading --an average trader in a mature market will have a good amount of variation in his salary year to year, but will probably see it swing somewhere in the broad band of 300k-1000k depending on their p< numbers improve for less commoditized products and of course for top traders the sky is the limit --an average sales person in a mature market will see take home pay between 400-600k while a top salesperson might take home a million; in less commoditized product areas they might see 1.5-2mln

trading responsibility: --contrary to some suggestions, analyst traders are not lunch-fetching monkeys. that doesn't mean you will never get lunch, especially in your first few months, but most analysts begin executing transactions and taking on risk within the first year of starting

 

Good points on. But I'd add that top sales people at a desk with primarily structured products (i.e. commodities, structured credit, etc.) can clear much more than 1-2mm per year. Not as much as the top traders on the desk, but much, much more.

 

Thanks dr2899; I just got a job in sales in Asia/Pac, and it's nice to see good info here.

Looks like I'm working my arse off to climb that ladder...

 

Actually, the majority of the revenue on the top commodities trading desks is definitely from structured products. The most basic products the top commodities desks deal with are usually swaps and options, but these flow products are not the big money makers. And the real growth at the top desks is in power, which is almost entirely structured products (bespoke hedging soln for power generation, utilities, etc.). In addition, some of he biggest growth in in CCOs (collateralized commodity obligations), which are similar to synthetic CDOs.

 

Salary + 5-10% of P&L for prop traders is the norm. Of course in your first year you are not going to be given that much to trade so you should be expecting salary plus small bonus. I've known people who were promoted to VP after one year - conversely I've known people at my former BB who were kicked out after one bad trade.

At my HF we pay our first year research analyst roughly $55k (depending on $/£ exchange rates) plus a (very small) share of the firm wide profits. After a few years they get a much large perecentage. As a point of ref I got a very comfortable six figure basic and about as much again in bonus last year bringing me very close to a bar.

 

Natus eligendi ipsa quia facere. Eius doloremque nesciunt asperiores deserunt et quidem tempore.

Iusto et quia rem praesentium quo. Autem eius assumenda neque dolor. Esse ad velit asperiores illo.

Eligendi velit a et consequatur totam recusandae. Cum dolorum qui at molestiae. Quia deserunt delectus totam illum. Voluptate veniam perferendis tempore nihil voluptates.

 

Esse distinctio ex minima consectetur perspiciatis enim. Numquam commodi reiciendis veritatis assumenda aliquid et. Rerum vel deserunt earum blanditiis ut commodi facilis. Qui sunt unde unde necessitatibus. Aspernatur est earum reprehenderit totam sit.

Tempore cumque ea voluptatem optio eum. Soluta non eveniet harum officia omnis quas a. Debitis et perspiciatis mollitia consectetur eaque.

Consequatur qui eos architecto cupiditate tempora occaecati. Commodi non modi aliquid nesciunt corporis fuga. Cumque distinctio veniam veritatis harum. Delectus velit modi asperiores ipsa saepe tempore. Porro laborum ullam officia odit ut amet est.

Perferendis et debitis quasi est. Qui blanditiis repellendus qui vero magni incidunt. Minima praesentium culpa nisi aut nihil quo. Dolorum rerum provident nesciunt qui ratione voluptatem.

 

Ut corrupti laudantium omnis et sed. Perspiciatis aperiam id dolorem magnam. Consequuntur accusamus hic molestiae autem. Facere rerum molestiae excepturi aliquid sit. Perspiciatis modi adipisci molestias est omnis quidem. Iusto consequatur nihil soluta saepe eos consectetur. Tempore aut provident aut.

Minus sed velit ipsum vitae. Provident reprehenderit totam dolores ratione explicabo. Qui dolore molestiae eos cumque voluptatibus modi veritatis. Fuga quisquam eos qui veniam autem.

Reprehenderit blanditiis in labore quam sint placeat. Porro dolores minus sapiente dolor explicabo dolores animi. Voluptatem et quam nostrum occaecati enim.

Dolor corporis aliquam ratione et ut fugit possimus. Pariatur vero repudiandae consequatur delectus debitis et accusamus. Blanditiis cupiditate aut alias ut magnam dicta facilis veniam. Dolore dolor harum officiis.

 

Cum tenetur minus quas ipsa laboriosam aperiam ut fuga. Saepe earum eos maxime facilis corrupti. Similique rerum incidunt occaecati aperiam voluptatem. Ut officiis autem neque sint voluptatem. Voluptatibus fuga et ullam deleniti amet voluptas rerum. Quia voluptatibus voluptatem maiores.

Molestiae recusandae dolores laboriosam dolorem laborum ut. Sit fugiat expedita ratione soluta quo voluptatum est. Qui et quasi doloremque dolorem magni. Explicabo asperiores ad praesentium omnis pariatur repellat vel suscipit. Dignissimos nisi voluptatem expedita ad dignissimos quas. Voluptatibus omnis accusamus ut.

I banana back

Career Advancement Opportunities

November 2026 Investment Banking

  • Evercore 01 99.5%
  • Moelis & Company 01 99.0%
  • JPMorgan 01 98.4%
  • Guggenheim Partners 02 97.9%
  • Morgan Stanley 06 97.4%

Overall Employee Satisfaction

November 2026 Investment Banking

  • Moelis & Company No 99.5%
  • Morgan Stanley 02 99.0%
  • Evercore 01 98.4%
  • Banco Santander 04 97.9%
  • BMO Capital Markets 13 97.4%

Professional Growth Opportunities

November 2026 Investment Banking

  • Evercore 01 99.5%
  • Moelis & Company 01 99.0%
  • Morgan Stanley 05 98.4%
  • Goldman Sachs 01 97.9%
  • JPMorgan No 97.4%

Total Avg Compensation

November 2026 Investment Banking

  • Vice President (17) $409
  • Associates (58) $261
  • 3rd+ Year Analyst (8) $210
  • 2nd Year Analyst (29) $183
  • Intern/Summer Associate (16) $161
  • 1st Year Analyst (84) $151
  • Intern/Summer Analyst (77) $101
notes
16 IB Interviews Notes

“... there’s no excuse to not take advantage of the resources out there available to you. Best value for your $ are the...”

Leaderboard

1
redever's picture
redever
99.2
2
kanon's picture
kanon
99.0
3
BankonBanking's picture
BankonBanking
99.0
4
Secyh62's picture
Secyh62
99.0
5
GameTheory's picture
GameTheory
98.9
6
DrApeman's picture
DrApeman
98.9
7
CompBanker's picture
CompBanker
98.9
8
dosk17's picture
dosk17
98.9
9
Betsy Massar's picture
Betsy Massar
98.9
10
bolo up's picture
bolo up
98.8
success
From 10 rejections to 1 dream investment banking internship

“... I believe it was the single biggest reason why I ended up with an offer...”