Boston Questrom vs Carnegie Mellon Tepper vs UCSB (UNDERGRAD)
Hey Monkeys.
I have received admission into Boston University's Questrom School of Business and the University of California Santa Barbara (Financial Mathematics and Statistics Major), and have been given the option to be placed onto the priority waitlist (meaning I must go if accepted) at Carnegie Mellon Tepper. These seem to be my three best options at the moment, but I do need some help with the decision. For CMU, I basically have to decide if I want to go there as if it was an option, since it is a binding contract that I attend if I am accepted of the waitlist.
Some background on me : I am very interested in upper finance, and Private Equity is a career that I am very interested in pursuing. I understand going through Investment Banking is the usual route, and probably required in my case since the schools mentioned above aren't exactly targets. I understand that networking is required regardless. I have built up a solid network of PE/IB professionals and plan on expanding that network later this year. I am very motivated and driven and I know I can network like a ninja, however having some ease in the process would be nicer, so I would like to see the school with a good reputation as well.
Here are my pros and cons for each: BOSTON UNIVERSITY: PROS: -Admitted into a Finance major -Living in Boston (I prefer city anyday over a beach) -Social life seems pretty good, and that is pretty important to me. I am a very social person and I'm looking to have a good 4 years. -Questrom is up and coming. The new dean is a former MD from KKR (which might not be a big deal but sounds huge to me). From what I have read on WSO, they are on the rise.
CONS: -Not an extremely prestigious university. Brand name won't carry me far. -Cold (From California) -OCR minimal, if none (from what I've heard. Please let me know if I am mistaken) -Expensive, would have to take out a 30k/year loan if I am unsuccessful in financial aid negotiations -Linkedin search shows a few alumni at BBs
CARNEGIE MELLON PROS: -If accepted, would be admitted into a Finance major -Academics have proven to be great in engineering, and solid in Business -Brand name is there -From a linkedin search, recent alumni have seemed to have landed up at solid EBs and BBs. Not sure if anymore than BU.
CONS : -Social life is abysmal. It's 70% dudes and I doubt anyone has even heard of TCB, let alone made it on there. -Too academic oriented. I go to a HS that is a top feeder into CMU, and I definitely don't want to be in a similar situation as the HS I am at. I want a work-hard, play-hard attitude. -Also expensive (same 30K/year loan needed) -Not sure how I would adjust to Pittsburgh -Unsure on how well established Tepper's name is
UCSB PROS : -Social life is amazing -Warmer -Closer to home -Cheap (Won't need any loans) -Accepted for honors
CONS : -No business school -Not in a city (this is huge) -Wore-down campus -Academics for finance, are unheard of. -Barely any alumni with IB/PE jobs out of grad.
So you can kind of see my thinking here. It really is between BU and CMU at this point, since I am not in love with UCSB's culture/academics for finance. The question is really, how much better is CMU academically and how much more help would it give me when it comes to SA/FT recruiting over BU. Because if it would only marginally help me, I would rather take BU because I am in love with its campus and social life. I am leaning towards BU because I feel like it'd be a great fit for me and I know I have the drive to network and learn things. I've already been building lbo models and networking with people from MFs, so I know I can push myself forward without the help of a school. But if CMU would put me a lot more ahead career-wise, I might want to take that.
Thanks in advance.
Obviously if you get into CMU, take it. However, I was on the priority waitlist and it's pretty much something they offer to everybody, so they don't take too many people. Last year, like 7 people got off the list.
I think BU is better than UCSB, but it's going to depend on your money situation.
Thank you for the response! So you'd think CMU is much better than BU?
Yeah that makes sense for the priority waitlist. I'm not extremely disheartened by that.
Thanks again!
I would say so. But I doubt it's worth 120k.
My $0.02: go to UCSB. Don't undervalue graduating from college debt-free. DEBT FREE!! (sorry for yelling)
UCSB has good academics. There's a Biz Econ major. You don't need to go into debt for OCR. You can make it happen yourself.
Did you apply to other UCs? You could always transfer if you need a change.
Full disclosure: My wife is a Gaucho.
Thanks for the reply. Yeah the reason I am considering UCSB is the money. Not a big fan of SoCal or the beach scene, but they do have a lot of great options. I'm in there with Honors so thats another plus.
When it comes to private schools, what would you say about BU vs CMU? I need to make a decision between these two, and then choose between private vs public.
Thanks for the help
Voluptatibus eum est ducimus dolor. Atque totam est earum qui ratione illum velit. Architecto beatae amet suscipit. Non qui voluptatibus sapiente modi expedita eum mollitia voluptas. Quae velit dolorem in sit fugit id quod nemo. Sed veritatis occaecati ea autem autem natus.
Ut molestiae ut corrupti. Autem sit quia et quam. Laborum aut dolor in ut laudantium eos est. Officia sapiente velit error dolores.
Non impedit animi quae aut voluptate itaque sunt. Et consequatur quos aut rerum officiis. Qui voluptatem enim repudiandae tempore. Laudantium ex eius id est et.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...